I vote yes.



These pop girls today can't touch Gaga.

Well sorta, I mean some of these artists and their sudden change in music videos and the fashion. Obviously she must've changed something...

She definitely helped dance-pop grow on the radio. Pop stars are also putting much more effort into their image now, on and off stage.

So yes, and I think she'll continue to do so, particularly with this next era. Gaga and Interscope are planning huge things.

yes

I can see Katy and Xtina before Gaga, but I mean Beyonce?

She has done these things before Gaga. She is obviously not influenced by her

Yes, with regards to music video quality and live performances. Her music's not really that different from pop songs in the past. She was just consistent prior to BTW and she seemed like she knew the formula to gain mega monster hits.

Nope, Adele did though.

Musically, nothing new yet. Artistically, nothing yet. Eccentricity mixed with high fashion has been done before gaga. She is still a newbie, she hasn't changed the game yet.

I think I reported you instead of replying to you forgive me, I'm sorta out of it

Absolutely.

Yes and whoever votes no, is pressed.

I don't really think she's made much of an impact tbh and I'm a Gaga stan.

All of these songs except Hot N Cold are either heavily hip-hop influenced or by an rnb artist because that was the music that basically dominated since 2003. To prove my point.. back in 2008 Gaga's people couldn't even get the original RedOne version of Just Dance played on the radio because it was "too dance".. and they originally sent this:



of course it wasn't just Gaga, but she was for sure one of the main reasons we have pure dance pop on the radio. According to redone himself:

"Dance music always existed but now it's popular. After… Gaga happened, it opened a lot of doors," he explained. "I have big DJs, I'm not going to mention names, but who came to me and said, 'Oh, thank you, you opened the doors for us, finally we're doing productions.' Because dance music before, the DJs used to do remixes. Now the radio song is a DJ version. So it's an amazing opportunity that happened and i think the dance music is going to stay."

As much as you try to prove it. The fact is that many artists have done dance music succesfully before Gaga. you will deal.

Of course they have. that doesn't mean they changed anything like Gaga did.

Okay...

She didn't bring anything new, but she revived elements of music and pop culture from the past.
That's why her debut was fresh and interesting. People of this generation hadn't seen anything like her before.