Which do you prefer?

Katy's Live Version


Kelly's Fan Request Version
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature...v=Khxy-xF0tjU#

(Won't let me embed)

Originally posted by Lucas32 The one that sounded good

Originally posted by Hunter_13 The powerhouse voice.

Originally posted by katyperryismylife So Katy?

Originally posted by ****ingbitch Katy's live version was a vocal masterpiece, so I'm choosing that one. Kelly's was just okay, you couldn't feel the RAW emotion like you could in Katy's.

Originally posted by SAFEYEAA It doesn't make you any less of a stan to admit that Kelly's was better..

The amount of dimension Kelly added to the song is incredible. I grew to like Katy's studio version but based on these two performances, Kelly's rendition is much more powerful in its stripped nature.

Originally posted by ****ingbitch My mom is a vocal coach and I just had her sit down and listen to both, she told me that Katy's was better.

Does you mom also think Katy has better vocals and can perform as consistently as Kelly live?

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction Does you mom also think Katy has better vocals and can perform as consistently as Kelly live?