Quote:
Originally posted by MJ Boston
I can't believe the amount of reaching in this thread. Has Give Your Heart A Break even hit the Top 20 on the Hot 100 yet? Hasn't Demi only had one top 10 solo hit with Skyscraper at #10? Her current album has 330k in sales and has BARELY outsold Bionic which is far and away Christina's worst performing album. How is anyone going to even consider Demi being nearly as successful as Christina with these kinds of stats? Demi's first two albums are merely Gold, both right around 500k in sales. Even digitally she's not a strong force. Skyscraper, her biggest hit, is only 1x platinum.
I'm sure her stats will pick up with the X Factor exposure and maybe her album will get a 2nd wind but that's not going to do much in this case against Christina. We'll talk when she gets some real success. And by that I mean at LEAST a few #1's on the Hot 100, a multi-platinum WW album, about 5 or 10 more Top 10 hits and a few Grammy's. Then we can consider whether she will even come close to being on Christina's commercial level.
And vocally, well, no. Your earlier comment about Christina not being nearly as good as Demi when she was 19 is completely bogus and I'm not sure you even have a clue what you're talking about. I understand her stans are happy she's seeing a little bit of success, but don't be overrating the hell out of her. This thread should be closed.  |
No one said she will reach her status and get a 9xplatinum album
no one can get that
anymore (Adele is an expection) not even Miley reached Christina's status, all of them are Disney stars.
And this thread was clearly talking about the vocals not success, all of us know Xtina is way successful
already contradicting yourself.
Are you seriously gonna deny THAT now?Christina's vocal techniques are often inappropriate but she's on the Whitney/Mariah level intrinsic vocal capability wise.Demi's voice is cute but don't even try.