who's prettier? who do you like more?

Hilary Duff


Lindsay Lohan

I'm pretty sure this thread has been done many times before.... but I won't be the one to report this seen as you are a newbie (sort of)

But Lindsay

Lindsay was prettier back in the day, but I don't prefer either of them personally. I like them both.

Lindsay. I used to stan for her. Speak >>>>

Even though Hilary probably turned out the best.

Lindsay, I like her more. She was prettier during her peak.
She's the bigger actress, Im not sure about her as a singer.
And she's more famous worldwide

Hilary...such a classy woman.

Hilary was always the prettier one, however, Lindsay had the better body.

When it comes to both music and movies: Hilary > Lindsay.

I would've called you crazy if you said Hilary would've been prettier than Lindsay 5 years ago. But Hilary is absolutely gorgeous now.
Music and acting wise, i like both equally. So i guess Hilary edges lindsay out b/c i prefer her looks/personality.

Both are actually REALLY pretty and talented.

Rumors is my absolute jam though, but I love Dignity.

Hilary Duff all the way

The pictures. I refuse.

why is this thread reported? :S

AH. Those pictures.

Hilary looks like an alien and Lindsay looks like a cocaine addict

Hilary.

OK I see you OP... using a nice picture of Hilary but a bad one of Lindsay... not here for that mess

because of the pictures you used probably.... or the fact that this thread has been overdone so many times before

Lilo

All those mugshots! Iconic

YOU KNOW WHY.

Hilary. And I always thought Hilary was prettier btw.

I agree