"Rolling in the Deep"
"Rumour Has It"
"Turning Tables"
"Don't You Remember"
"Set Fire to the Rain"
"He Won't Go"
"Take It All"
"I'll Be Waiting"
"One and Only"
"Lovesong"
"Someone Like You"

Vs

Which one had the better songs, singles,& impact? What are your likes and dislikes for the album? And which one is better overall? This won't be a poll since that is biased, I want to hear reasons. And now sales or any of that crap, its only your opinion.

4,by lightyears.

Why? I like them both too, and they both have a perfect flow. But why is 4 better?

21 is much more of a cohesive album. Love both though.

4, 21 gets boring after a while. I only use the singles from 21 now.

4 is just better in every aspect.

4.

4 but barely. I just think the vocals on 4 is better, but 21 has better "highs" on the album

Pretty much this. I can actually listen to 4 all the way through, 21 is only good for the mega-hits.

Both 4 and 21 go in a story.

But 21 does it a little better. She's angry at its start, and then at the end she accepts it for what it is, and moves on. Its the how everyone feels after a bad break-up.

4 is an overall amazing R&b album, Bey used influences from different genre's and periods and put them together. End of Time and Countdown are perfect examples of that. However, the shinning moment is her voice, and how she never overdoes it. While 21 is a downer, 4 has its ups and down, so you're never bored.

That's my quick perception.

4 had an army behind it.

21 has Adele's voice, which is like an army!..... But still doesn't compare

I liked 4 better
21 had the bigger impact tho. 22 million copies sold worldwide. That's incredible, it's also won 6 Grammys.

I am sasha fierce vs 21 would be fairer

Somebody should add a poll

I am sasha fierce >>>>>>21>>>>>>4

4, definitely. Seriously one of the best albums in recent memory.

4 i think is a better album. it just isn't as catchy as the stuff on 21

4

Never listened to the whole 21...too boring after the previews. Only good song is Set Fire To The Rain