Her three floppiest albums and her three most hated ones.

Which one is the best?

American Life.

American Life.

American Life is easily the best.

- Intervention
- X-Static Process
- Die Another Day
- American Life (I like the "Rap" part)

It is completely underrated critically, while Hard Candy is just a mess and MDNA is plain average.

Intervention imo is the weakest, but Easy Ride, Xstatic Process and Nobody Knows Me are great.

I love Intervention.

I love all three.

But it's easily AL, then MDNA with hard candy being last.

Intervention is probably the best song on the record

Yes!

AL but voted for HC accidentally..

Hard Candy always losing

imo its better than MDNA... MDNA is completely worn out now to me.

I have the luxury of never listening to either, so I don't have any burnouts. Objectively, I think most people agree that MDNA's best > HC

Wait, you haven't heard either of them?!

I loved Hard Candy...haha, i think i may be alone on this one though.

No, I have. I mean... rarely listening to them. Though I never listen to HC.

American Life > Hard Candy > Madonna's other albums > MDNA

Trust me madonnas, you'll get back to it

I said the same thing but didn't admit it to anyone, but just today I listened to the CD and loved it all over again.

It's really like in periods for me. I feel like it's lackluster but then I get in those moods where I really really enjoy it. I don't get that way with HC....

oh. well the best song of MDNA > HC, but HC is more consistent. It only has two screeching abominations...

MDNA has 3


Plus, the filler on HC >>> filler on MDNA

Maybe, I mean I can probably enjoy it for being a Madonna album, but it musically doesn't impress me. I need that to really enjoy all of it.