No she wouldn't have.

fffffdfff;;;

Good question.

Did I say Janet would win the X Factor? Anyone with working ears knows Britney cannot out-sing Beyonce. LMAO @ the delusional believing LA Reid is actually being genuine.

So its MY fault that Britney lip syncs and uses pre recorded vocals?

How is he going to say this when he was so hard on Simone Battle for her limited vocal range during the competition? Out of all the girls that season she was the closest in spirit to Britney!Prime and he went so far as to question why Simon brought her back at every opportunity.

She had solid vocals when she was younger, and plenty of star quality. Obviously, L.A. was just saying things, but it's not an outrageous thought.

Given that simply the audition phase requires singing I think it's safe to say she wouldn't have even come close.

Of course he would say that, I mean let's not ignore reasons why he would say that.

But no, she wouldn't have.

what did you expect for him to say?

of course he would say that

Yes, she would. Haters stay mad.

She almost has the whole package. The live vocals would be the only problem.

When she was 16/17, but not now