Originally posted by Giacobbe I support Rih and all, but saying peoples faves cant sing when both of them almost won the biggest singing competitions in the world (minus Canadian Idol, even then was still respected) is kind of invalid. Both are solid vocalists

Originally posted by KoreanDream I mean I'm not BadBitch so let's make that distinction clear. And let's not act like Carly Rae Jepsen and One Direction are on some Whitney Houston, Mariah Carey, Beyonce-type level either. If they're better vocalists than Rihanna then the gap is not a large one.

I forgot I came in the thread and said that One Direction were better singers than Rihanna and they were on par with Whitney and Beyoncé vocal wise.... Oh wait.

Sure, they're not near that level, but the problem you pointed out about Rihanna's vocals isn't a problem for them. They're consistent when it comes to vocals.

No one said the gap was massively big either.

Originally posted by Jaymz coming 3rd is not nearly winning

Originally posted by Kats She's alright. Her mixed voice is decent but her head voice is weak and her vibrato is mediocre.

Originally posted by Kats She's alright. Her mixed voice is decent but her head voice is weak and her vibrato is mediocre.

Originally posted by Life She an average singer.

Originally posted by Jack! No She needs to learn that her nose isn't her mouth and doesn't control her vocal chords.

Originally posted by gotintoririfever1 Iam amazed by the number of vocal coaches in this thread

Originally posted by J.Givenchy and in the next few threads you'll find A&R people, high-level label execs, publicists, and interns from Billboard. Welcome to ATRL

Originally posted by KoreanDream What people don't understand is that Rihanna is actually a solid vocalist, but that she's incredibly inconsistent.

Originally posted by Giacobbe You're joking right?