What the actual ****?! I'm sure if this song was released in the 80's it would have smashed. It's Gaga's best record and continues only to be remembered by true fans.

The music video... has nothing to do with this. Yeah, let's not mention that, but the song itself deserves so much more. It's a modern classic along with Beyonce's Crazy in Love and Madonna's Hung Up.

The song was a hit and will be remembered.

It's a cute pop record, that's it.

It's alright

It is a classic

it's a solid song. deserved so much more.

the other songs you mentioned are overrated though

With the right video, yes

It was a sufficient radio hit, but its life was cut short. This song should have been a bar/stadium classic. It's everything.

Time will tell. So far, time it's on its side.

Yeah it's a great song but idk about classic status.

America spoke. We thought it was ok.

You will deal.

I'll never understand why the general public prefers this to judas & scheisse. I hear TEOG all the time when the smash of her life went unreleased and gets no attention.

For some reason it's still not one of my favorites. I remember being really underwhelmed when I first heard it.

Definitely deserved better single treatment though.

If the right video was released, nobody would be questioning if it

It is one of BTW's better songs and the general consensus is favorable. Don't know why it didn't smash

Basically.

Its already remembered by most non-stans as one of the best pop records. It outshines most of Gaga's early work and mostly all of her singles sans Paparazzi and Bad Romance and it will be used in sporting events and weddings for many years to come.