[geddymonster]

vs.



Which song is better?


I'm going to have to go with Madonna's "I Love New York." Everything on Confessions on a Dance Floor is perfect and I think Madonna's song does a better job of capturing the New York attitude. Taylor's song is nice too, but Madonna's is the perfect New York anthem!

[Toxicity.]

I Love New York is the worst song on Confessions...

"I don't like cities, but I like New York. Other cities make me feel like a dork!"

"Other cities always make me mad. Other places always make me sad"

"New York is not for little ******* who scream!"

The instrumental is really good though

[jose168]

Originally posted by Toxicity.

I Love New York is the worst song on Confessions...

"I don't like cities, but I like New York. Other cities make me feel like a bore!"

dork* get it right, bore doesnt even rhyme

ILNY is one of the best songs ever so it wins

[Delilah.]

WTNY. i love new york is my least favorite madonna song.

[geddymonster]

I Love New York is NOT one of the worst on Confessions on a Dance Floor!

[Toxicity.]

Originally posted by jose168

dork* get it right, bore doesnt even rhyme

ILNY is one of the best songs ever so it wins

[Jaspurr]

Welcome to New York is like so much better.

[downbywednesday]

I Love New York >>>

[Icarus]

Originally posted by Toxicity.

I Love New York is the worst song on Confessions...

"I don't like cities, but I like New York. Other cities make me feel like a dork!"

"Other cities always make me mad. Other places always make me sad"

"New York is not for little ******* who scream!"

The instrumental is really good though

Are these actual lyrics

[Temporal]

Originally posted by IcarusIsFlying

Are these actual lyrics

Yes My music teacher told me that I Love New York is the worst song of all time

[Britney Is Fierce]

I Love New York is one of those Madonna cocky songs with cringeworthy lyrics that I should hate, but I can't because it's too catchy and its production is flawless Welcome To New York is one of the weaker tracks on 1989, it's kinda boring imo.

[lousaysthings]

Both are amongst the weakest on their respective albums but Madonna's lyrics are ridiculously cringe-inducing and not even the gllittery production can rescue that mess

[Rama]

Taylor's.


ILNY is cute but it kinda ruins COADF.

[minho]

I Love New YooooooooOOOOOOOoooork. Its actually one of my favourites from Confessions. Of course, Welcome To New York is really great too.

[KatyLegendperry]

Taylor's. I Love New York is possibly the worst written song I have ever heard