[Hooligan]

Who does it better, brethren?

[KevinKDC]

Kelly without a doubt.

[Mzd]

Originally posted by Ryan

Carrie you're not good enough, you're not good enough....

Carrie brings the country to this song, Kelly brings the soul and everything else to this song
Kelly makes you actually FEEL the song and really owns it

[stoopidjenna]

Carrie is definitely a good singer but she just doesn't sing with the emotion Kelly does in my opinion. Like, when Kelly belts, it's to express heightened emotion. Half the time when Carrie does it, it just sounds like she is getting louder. Of course... maybe it's just because of my Kelly stan ears...

Oh and I don't care what anyone says... you can't deny that Kelly's head voice ***** on Carrie's.

[FAN]

Kelly, DUH!

[Hooligan]

Originally posted by stoopidjenna

Carrie is definitely a good singer but she just doesn't sing with the emotion Kelly does in my opinion. Like, when Kelly belts, it's to express heightened emotion. Half the time when Carrie does it, it just sounds like she is getting louder. Of course... maybe it's just because of my Kelly stan ears...

Oh and I don't care what anyone says... you can't deny that Kelly's head voice ***** on Carrie's.

Her falsetto too, ,IMO. How effortlessly she shifts between the two is just

[tell_me_a_lie]

I wonder now if carrie has stans here. I never see them and never know how they look like.

[Strangergab]

Kelly

[Hooligan]

Originally posted by tell_me_a_lie

I wonder now if carrie has stans here. I never see them and never know how they look like.

They certainly have the numbers on Youtube.

[Mzd]

Originally posted by tell_me_a_lie

I wonder now if carrie has stans here. I never see them and never know how they look like.

She has a couple here, like 5.
Those youtube comment trolls are just so pressed

[face]

#carriewho

[Mzd]

Originally posted by face

#carriewho

Flawless

[mandym]

Queen Kelly.
Who else?

[Roberto]

Kellllllllllllllllyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

[PopBoi]

Where are all these Kelly stans popping up out of nowhere?

But yeah, klearly kelly

[Hooligan]

Originally posted by PopBoi

Where are all these Kelly stans popping up out of nowhere?

But yeah, klearly kelly

They've been here.

The three I named in the title are basically the main ones.

[Mr. Duff]

I prefer Carrie's. I can't believe most of you have said Kelly's has more emotion. Carrie sings with emotions too. Plus I prefer Carrie's big voice over Kelly's husky one.

[Mezik]

No one can cover IKYW the way Carrie sings it.

[dhilamilan1899]

kellyyyyyyyyyyyyyy all the way!!!!!

[DejaVu]

Carrie's performance showcases big notes and vocals but she doesn't really interpret the song very well. It's basically a vocal marathon to show you the notes she can hit and how long she can hold them.

Kelly's a masterful interpreter of lyrics and really knows how to let the lyrics shine while still delivering a master class vocal. That's what make her a better vocalist than Carrie. Well I guess having a wider range and stronger chest & head voice helps...