[EloiseheartsRiRi]

I mean, I have been one of the biggest critics of her talents and massive dominance as if she deserved it or not. But the girl did her thing and I was speechless to see her doing so great and put on such a great show and show immense levels of confidence with every American perched on their TV. And Firework finally got the right live treatment that it deserved. So is she now an established Icon or has she yet to prove something?

[Remixed]

no

[EloiseheartsRiRi]

Originally posted by Remixed

no

You didn't even read the OP. You wanted the first post.

[Starstruck.]

Yes.

She established herself now and she isn't going anywhere.

She even already has a classic!

[Miichael]

No.

[KatyLegendperry]

She was already an icon

[J a y]

Katy Perry isn't distinctive, instantly recognisable, nor is she associated with cultural significance to a cultural group.

Katy Perry is therefore not an icon.

[If U Seek Amy]

Yes everybody knows her simply. Her performance was praised and her songs are classics

[Darkroth]

She's not established yet because she wants to be American dominant pop singer. She will be, if she decides to broaden her horizons.

[If U Seek Amy]

Anyone who says no is just jealous their fave is a nobody.

[Fantasea]

Not even close.

[Luminary]

[Bounce]

Katy Perry is not an icon and she never will be.

[Tuxedo]

Originally posted by J a y

Katy Perry isn't distinctive, instantly recognisable, nor is she associated with cultural significance to a cultural group.

Katy Perry is therefore not an icon.

pretty much

[Exile]

Yes, the other pressed souls will say no because their faves aren't and they have the delusion of wanting Katy to be with them

[Gavroche]

Nope, but she's very successful at the moment.

[If U Seek Amy]

Katy Perry is more successful than Lady Gaga, Rihanna, and all other irrelevants

[Mariano]

Originally posted by J a y

Katy Perry isn't distinctive, instantly recognisable, nor is she associated with cultural significance to a cultural group.

Katy Perry is therefore not an icon.

this.

She can be a pop icon tho, top 40 u know

[BudBud]

Nah, any artist performing would have went HAM, Katy just did what was required of her - nothing more.

[RomanNavy]

I'm not sure.
I feel the same about her as I do about Taylor
Very successful but there's nothing to them that makes them defining for our time.