[Sinister]

Both eras heavily use the color Red...but which one was more successful???
Choose wisely

[Diar7]

Loud.

[Sinister]

poll added

Make sure to take into account touring and what not

[Losing my ground]

Loud WW.

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Loud.
*Insert Taylor being pushed by her tour dancer on her pedestal gif*

[OnlyManInTheWorld]

The one that sold 1.2M copies in its first week.

But Loud was also successful.

[EnigmaPopstar]

Red

[TheCheetahwings]

Obviously Red.

Album Sales
Smash Singles
Massive World Tour
Critical Acclaim

What else could you want?

[GiftFromGod]

Album sales: Red = Loud
Single sales: IKYWT >>>>
Tour: Red Tour >>>>
Acclaim: Red

[Rihinvention]

The era that delivered 4 Billboard Hot 100 #1s

**** note it says 'era' not 'album'

[QueenBeé]

They're pretty equal, RED's tour was bigger than LOUD's but LOUD's singles were bigger than RED's.
Voted for LOUD since I like Rih more.

[Summertime Love]

Red

[GiftFromGod]

Originally posted by TheCheetahwings

Obviously Red.

Album Sales
Smash Singles
Massive World Tour
Critical Acclaim

What else could you want?

But did Taylor's hair make an impact?

[lonnie]

LOUD
more #1s
More memorable
The album sales are about equal

[BreatheOnMe]

loud

[JBJT2786]

Originally posted by OnlyManInTheWorld

The one that sold 1.2M copies in its first week.

But Loud was also successful.

Yet it failed to outsell Loud worldwide...local much?

[QueenBeé]

Let's not forget that like %90 of RED's total sales solely come from the USA.

[pablozedd]

I dont know which is bigger, but i prefer Loud. Rihanna's best era.

[Cheers]

Loud is more memorable and made more impact. And it had huge global singles (Only Girl, S&M) and Love the Way You Lie is from the era too so it's a clear win.

[EdwardB]

I don't know about the US,but as an european citizen Loud was waaaay bigger!