[nicklada]

Originally posted by madonnas

He gave every post-2000 song a 7 or higher.

ffffff

[madonnas]

I want Fantasy to win though. It truly is one of the best uses of a sample ever.

[Ace Reject]

What would y'all prefer as your number one? The song that samples one of the most sampled tracks of all time - Genius of Love by Tom Tom Club, or one that recalls the wall of sound that genius producer/murderer Phil Spector employed in the sixties?

[Honey]

I can't at Emotions and AIWFCIY being top five. Those two didn't even deserve top twenty.

[alkralkra]

Her most iconic and global Christmas anthem FTW.

[TheEmancipation]

AIWFCIY is by FAR her most iconic song though. So I wouldn't be to upset. I'd love the meltdowns.

[Doc]

I'm pretty sure everybody loves All I Want For Christmas, which is why we gave it 10s.
We just didn't expect this would happen.

Originally posted by TheEmancipation

All I want for Christmas is you NEEDS to win just more the meltdowns.

I wouldn't meltdown, I'd just laugh tbh.
This rate first showed signs of going downhill when My All came in at #21,
and was officially done when Breakdown clocked a #13.

[nicklada]

AIWFCIY can win. But I think Fantasy has it.

[TheEmancipation]

Originally posted by alkralkra

The most iconic and global Christmas anthem FTW.

Fixed.

[Changes]

I always found All I Want For Christmas to be overrated. Maybe I just don't like Christmas songs.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by TheEmancipation

AIWFCIY is by FAR her most iconic song though. So I wouldn't be to upset. I'd love the meltdowns.

Oh definitely. It is to her what I Will Always Love You is to Whitney, and My Heart Will Go On is to Celine.

Except Mariah's standard is actually good!

[TheEmancipation]

Strangergab probably gave fantasy a 1 and AIWFCIY a 10 based off of his past ratings.

Christmas got this in the bag.

[Honey]

Wait, where did Fantasy rank?

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Honey

Wait, where did Fantasy rank?

It's in the top 2. The remix is the one outside the top 10.

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Honey

I can't at Emotions and AIWFCIY being top five. Those two didn't even deserve top twenty.

Get OFF it with the flawless "Emotions."

[Doc]

Let's be real.
If there is ONE Mariah Carey song that people will remember decades down, it's All I Want For Christmas Is You.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Honey

Wait, where did Fantasy rank?

It hasn't shown up yet.

By the way, Genius of Love ***** y'all. Like, scary good.

[Honey]

Originally posted by madonnas

It's in the top 2. The remix is the one outside the top 10.

Oh, I thought the "Genius of Love" in the title was referring to Vision of Love.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

It hasn't shown up yet.

By the way, Genius of Love ***** y'all. Like, scary good.

I legitimately think I like it more than Fantasy, and I like Fantasy a lot. My parents always used to play it when I was little and the "James Brown" part scared me.

[Mimie]

Originally posted by TheEmancipation

Strangergab probably gave fantasy a 1 and AIWFCIY a 10 based off of his past ratings.

Christmas got this in the bag.

Omg if that's true