[Jaay]

AIWFCIY MUST be out next. It deserved top 10, but not above VOL or any of the remaining songs.

[MP2K]

The title change, already know!

[TheEmancipation]

I ****ing love David Cook's cover.

[Doc]

Originally posted by Jaay

AIWFCIY MUST be out next. It deserved top 10, but not above VOL or any of the remaining songs.

[EJQL8]

Originally posted by nicklada

The Roof is just such an amazing song, should have won. I mean this bitch rhymed "moet" with "liberated", I STILL cannot get over that.

The vocal layering, the small intricacies, the lyrics, the instrumentals... it's so perfect.

!!!!

[nicklada]

Jason Castro did the best Mariah cover ever.

[madonnas]

OMG, I think AIWFCIU might win

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by MP2K

The title change, already know!

Yep. And with that, all my 10's are out!

I guess I would prefer "Fantasy" to beat "All I Want For Christmas Is You," but honestly, "Heartbreaker" is a better version of that song.

[alkralkra]

I can't take

[Ace Reject]

03.



Average 9.349
Highest 10 [Ace Reject, Honey, Mariah4life, KoolAidKing, EJQL8, Wil, Neptune, Flashing Lights, nicklada, skyler, waryofothers, tcweh, MP2K, fortheloveofmusic, berberocka, StateoftheWorld, Wecangetstarted, Luigi M, RockStarShit101, MiguelPortugal, madonnas, Doc, Praise Mariallah, supaspaz, Jaay, Jessa, Green]
Lowest 6 STRANGERGAB

A true classic, and the first time I'd ever heard the word "inevitably." She's such a wordsmith! Shockingly enough, this was Mariah's first R&B Female Vocal Performance nomination.

[Taste of Honey]

"Vision of Love". Can y'all believe she was 19 when she recorded that?

[EJQL8]

**** THAT CHRISTMAS SONG!!!!

[nicklada]

WHY did you accept strangergab's ballot? Did he low rate the majority of her songs?

[supaspaz]

Wouldn't it be kind of funny if "All I Want For Christmas Is You" was both the winner and the last place song, though?

[Doc]

Originally posted by EJQL8

**** THAT CHRISTMAS SONG!!!!

We suggested a while ago that AIWFCIY might win, but nobody was serious.
Now it feels so real.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by nicklada

WHY did you accept strangergab's ballot? Did he low rate the majority of her songs?

He gave every post-2000 song a 7 or higher.

[Taste of Honey]

Originally posted by supaspaz

Wouldn't it be kind of funny if "All I Want For Christmas Is You" was both the winner and the last place song, though?

I actually kinda want this to happen now.

[TheEmancipation]

All I want for Christmas is you NEEDS to win just more the meltdowns.

[Mimie]

So many of y'all not liking AIWFCIY, yet it got this high

[EJQL8]

I can't deal with this ****ery.