Host commentary - This song is pretty reductive of her past work and the production is a little messy. I did give it a 10 because MDNA got me into Madonna and this was a standout for me on my first listen. It hasn't aged as well and it looks bad compared to the rest of her discography, but it is still fun for occasional listens. It is just a fun song without being breathtakingly bad like her troll songs.
Im A Sinner guest commentary
Reinvention– Love, love, LOVE this song. It’s euphoric, and should be a party anthem. Let me buy up the overpriced “I’m a sinner” merch on ha store.
eli’s_rhythm - I forgot how many good tracks there are on this album. This song has Beautiful Stranger vibes.
Subomie - A stand-out on the album for sure, it's just breezy and she even sounds alive here. A nice, refreshing. The bridge is great.
Edit:thank God, it's not.
I quite like I'm a Sinner although the "Jesus Christ hanging on a cross / died for our sins it's such a loss " lines make me cringe
I'm a Sinner... Eh. I tried to get into it but it's honestly so boring and unnecessary. A cute throwback to her earlier work when you listen to MDNA in full (not that anybody does that), I guess.