[Mariano]

[Moonchild]

Unless some more positive reviews roll in, we currently have two mixed reviews (All Music and The Telegraph) and one (highly) positive review (The Chicago Tribune) to be added.

I could easily see Metacritic give The Chicago Tribune's review a 90 or even a 100, but I think I'll keep my 64-67 prediction steady once more until we get some more reviews.

[Matthew]

RetroATRL
User Score of '0'
Not a fan of this album at all. Gaga & her ancient jazz daddy scream for relevance all over this excuse for a jazz album. Flop 2 Flop will not even go gold anywhere. What a massive flop. Move on monsters. Time for me to go back to crying about what a f.a.d she's become.


Which of y'all did this? Or was it actually him?

[Almighty Gaga]

Band members: Lady Gaga, The Tony Bennett Quartet

what?

[M i x]

60 from Billboard

It's like you got 0

[Maneater]

She shouldn't have came for Billboard that one time.

[umich]

Knoxville News - 70/100 (3.5/5 stars)

The arrangements are nearly flawless, showy but still accessible, and Gaga seems to luxuriate in the experience. Her robust vocals have come across as secondary in the past, overshadowed by her visual style, her lyrics, her bulldozing pop/dance sound and her controversies. “Cheek to Cheek” lets her put that voice at the forefront, convey her interpretation of lyrics from long ago with convincing emotion. And though melodrama is inescapable (many of these songs are from musicals, after all), Gaga doesn’t just show off for the sake of showing off. When she sings, “Heaven, I’m in heaven” on the title track, she means it.

More here

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

Both of the ones posted above are eligible right?

Edit: Someone deleted their post

[Aden]

I will take a 62.

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

I predicted it to get a score of 60-65 so I'm happy with anything above that

[Bang Up]

Which scores have yet to be added, does anyone know?

Originally posted by Marooner5

60 from Billboard

It's like you got 0

I'm not the best at math. In fact, it was probably my worst subject in school, but I'm pretty sure 60 and 0 are not equatable numbers no matter the equation.

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

Originally posted by Bang Up

Which scores have yet to be added, does anyone know?



I'm not the best at math. In fact, it was probably my worst subject in school, but I'm pretty sure 60 and 0 are not equatable numbers no matter the equation.

I believe there are three more to be added. One's positive, the other two are mixed

[umich]

Originally posted by ♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚

Both of the ones posted above are eligible right?

Edit: Someone deleted their post

Not sure about Digital Spy, but the Knoxville one isn't included for Metacritic.

Originally posted by Rivington Reject

I will take a 62.

[Bang Up]

Originally posted by ♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚

I believe there are three more to be added. One's positive, the other two are mixed

Originally posted by umich

Not sure about Digital Spy, but the Knoxville one isn't included for Metacritic.

Now I'm confused. Are there two to be added or three?

I know the Chicago Tribune one needs to be added and that it should be above an 80.

If it's just two that need to be added and they add CT at above an 80, the score shouldn't be affected that much.

[umich]

Originally posted by Bang Up

Now I'm confused. Are there two to be added or three?

I know the Chicago Tribune one needs to be added and that it should be above an 80.

If it's just two that need to be added and they add CT at above an 80, the score shouldn't be affected that much.

Chicago Tribune (Positive), All Music Guide (60), and the Telegraph (60) need to be added in to Metacritic.

[Versace]

Originally posted by Bang Up

I'm not the best at math. In fact, it was probably my worst subject in school, but I'm pretty sure 60 and 0 are not equatable numbers no matter the equation.

I'm sure he didn't mean it literally.

I just want it to stay at 70, that would be perfect.

[Bang Up]

Originally posted by umich

Chicago Tribune (Positive), All Music Guide (60), and the Telegraph (60) need to be added in to Metacritic.

Thank you!

All Music's been out for a while so let me pretend they're going to ignore it.

Hoping the Tribune holds more weight than the other two.

[jhonyguy04]

Originally posted by ♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚

I believe there are three more to be added. One's positive, the other two are mixed

Aww lawd. Forget it. 😭😭😭

[Bang Up]

The average with all of the eligible scores minus the Chicago Tribune is 65 (not taking into account how the publications are weighted differently).

The average with all of the eligible scores with the Chicago Tribune being counted as an 80 is 66 (not taking into account how the publications are weighted differently).

The average with all of the eligible scores with the Chicago Tribune being counted as an 90 is 67 (not taking into account how the publications are weighted differently).

I hope they don't try to pull a fast one and score the Chicago Tribune below what it should be, but even without it the score remains higher than ARTPOP.

[Rated]

Any new reviews?