All I Ever Wanted as a whole really isn't that good tbh. It had great tracks but was all over the place and the whole era was kinda tacky with the colours and the lollipops and the weaving dirty blonde hair.
I agree it could have been bigger.
They just released the wrong tracks. I Do Not Hook Up was definitly not her strongest choice. And All I Ever Wanted as a single? LOL
Looking at how What Doesnt Kill You is doing, I think My Life Would Suck Without You should have been the second single.
:S