[Tymps.]

A T R L ' s
H O L Y T R I N I T Y
R E S U L T S

I'm going to do these results for the Covers Trinity (aka Comeback Trinity) a little differently. I'm going to count down until we get to who will make it back in. When your place is revealed, so will be your comments and rankings. Good luck!

In fifth place is...

fifth place

MusicLoverDude

conatus ▲ #5

Legend E ▲ #4

Buddy! ▲ #5

Originally posted by Buddy!

This is definitely unique. The first two are nice, I like them. But the last one is tragic. Honestly, I don't know why you didn't take this entry seriously. Idgaf about how many views your video managed to get. Your meltdown was unnecessary and you're gonna throw in one of your covers, and for what? Self-humiliation? Don't waste my time.

Originally posted by conatus

Got ha titty out and everything. Aside from the inclusion of the obviously messy one, the other two just aren't that interesting.

Originally posted by Legend E

I sort of like your idea, but I feel like your entry lacks that something special. Sure, the covers are good and everything (+ congrats for sending yourself ) but something's missing. You could have found some covers that truly changed the vision the original artist had.

#JusticeForMLD

Fourth place...

fourth place

JustLuke

conatus ▲ #4

Legend E ▲ #5

Buddy! ▲ #2

Originally posted by Buddy!

I was so sad when you left. I liked all of your entries. Even though they were a taD basic, I still thought they were well put together and, for the most part, spot on. Anyway, regarding your comeback entry- I think you did well. Aside from the last one, I feel like the first two could have been sung by the same person.

Originally posted by conatus

These are all kind of the same thing. Kitschy covers of pop songs, yawn.

Originally posted by Legend E

Oh, how I love it when you send youtubers...Good entry, but again very basic choices. If you remain, try to send something that not the entire ATRL knows.

Third place...

third place

prezli

conatus ▲ #1

Legend E ▲ #3

Buddy! ▲ #4

Originally posted by Buddy!

Where is the range in songs? Idk I like the Britney cover. The first two sound like they're sung by the same person. And they're really not good covers either. :///

Originally posted by conatus

I happen to love all three of these songs (Daughter's version >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Daft Punk's). Plus, the songs aren't too similar.

Originally posted by Legend E

I love what Daughter did with "Get Lucky". The same problem here, as Scene, Tom's Diner is too poppy for the rest of the tracks. Other than that, not bad.

And as for first/second place... there was a tie, which I broke myself based on who I thought submitted the better entry. Scene. and Theus, you both are avid supporters of Holy Trinity and also good friends of mine. However, I can only let one of you back into the game for the top 11 and Phase II, and based on your entries, that player is...

first place

Scene.

conatus ▲ #3

Legend E ▲ #2

Buddy! ▲ #1

Originally posted by Buddy!

Whew lord. Slay a bit. Each song is so different from each other.I really like the range of music you meshed together. It was a shame you left us so early, because if this entry is any indication, you definitely didn't deserve to go.

Originally posted by conatus

The PVRIS and Karmin covers just feel too similar. Also, Gaga, her Sound Of Music did not surpass the quality of Julie's. What kind of nonsense?

Originally posted by Legend E

Eh, Gaga's tribute doesn't really fit in with the other two poppier songs. Also, maybe I am deaf, but I hear little to no rock influences in PVRIS' cover ). It's still a pretty good trinity!

Congratulations, Scene.! I know you really wanted to be back in the game and your entry proved to me you deserve a second chance. Plus, I think the Lady Gaga Sound of Music performance was a brilliant choice.(Ironically, in Season 2 you were sacrificed right before the finale, and this time you're being reborn, much like the game. )

This means...

second place

Theus

conatus ▲ #2

Legend E ▲ #1

Buddy! ▲ #3

Originally posted by Buddy!

omggg what kind of throwback. I had no clue Girls Just Wanna Have Fun was a cover either, mess. Overall, you really had a nice entry. I really enjoyed these songs. Good luck boo<3

Originally posted by conatus

I know I should know better than to expect it from you, but I was looking for a little more versatility.

Originally posted by Legend E

You know, there are good covers outside the 80's too, right? Anyway, your covers are pretty good and some classics indeed.

Theus, I'm sorry. I'm glad you gave this another shot after I asked you but I was really hoping you added more diversity into your selection. I know you have a diverse music taste that you didn't display with this entry.

Current contestants, make sure to congratulate the returning player! This was very close, much closer than I expected, and everyone who submitted an entry should be glad you at least gave it another shot! Also, your Elemental Trinities are due soon, in two days. If you haven't started working with your team, do it ASAP. If you haven't selected your songs, it's time to narrow the selection down and start your write-ups/formatting (if you have any). Good luck and I'll see you all back here in two day's time!

[Scene.]

omg, thank you so much judges! I'll make sure not to let you down and prove I deserved to come back.

[Lukey]

Congrats Scene. !

Thanks Buddy, great judge and always so open-minded

[DripDrip]

YAS SCENE

[Buddy!]

Congrats Scene

Well deserved!

Sorry to the others<3

Also, Gaga, her Sound Of Music did not surpass the quality of Julie's. What kind of nonsense?

xP,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

....................

...........

[Tymps.]

Originally posted by Darcy Edwards

YAS SCENE

The Original Four + Kitt is back, baby

[Legend E]

Congrats Scene

[Buddy!]

Petition to throw kkkontANUS off of the judging panel

1:Buddy!

Join the movement, otherwise you're gay

[conatus]

Originally posted by Buddy!

Petition to throw kkkontANUS off of the judging panel

1:Buddy!

Join the movement, otherwise you're gay

Stay press'd!!1! [;

Congrats Scene., I did like your entry. I honestly would have been fine with any of my top 4 returning.

[feelslikeadream]

Congrats Scene! I was rooting for you!

[MusicLoverDude]

So whenever I try to be cohesive but diverse, I flop. And whenever I try to do something different that stands out, I flop. The fact that I couldn't even get even one place higher

I did try and take this seriously Buddy. I thought sending in my cover, plus the video that was inspired by the other cover, and the cover that got Niykee into the music industry, would stand out. Apparently, I was wrong.

I might as well stop posting entries for fun. Apparently my taste isn't enough to even last one round in this game or even be successful in it when I do last past it.

I might as well not even sign up next season if there is one, because my music taste is just ridiculed by negative judges as are my entries, regardless of whether I try to be cohesive or not. I've already expressed myself genuinely as well and I feel like I can't convey myself any other way without coming off as fake. I feel like my personality isn't enough for this game either. Or for this season.

[MusicLoverDude]

he other two just aren't that interesting.

Do you ever have anything nice to say? You're such a Squidward. Be like my Spongebob like self.

[MusicLoverDude]

Originally posted by conatus

Stay press'd!!1! [;

Congrats Scene., I did like your entry. I honestly would have been fine with any of my top 4 returning.

That obvious as hell shade

[conatus]

Originally posted by MusicLoverDude

Do you ever have anything nice to say? You're such a Squidward. Be like my Spongebob like self.

Drag me!

Originally posted by MusicLoverDude

That obvious as hell shade

Well, your entry was my least favourite for this round, and one of my least favourites in the round you did compete in. You haven't given me anything that is as good as the other four showed me. Not going to sit here and be like "Yes!!! Come back and serve more subpar vanilla pop!!!" because I'd rather focus on contestants who come up with interesting concepts and entries.

[Theus]

Congrats Scene!

[MusicLoverDude]

Originally posted by conatus

Drag me!



Well, your entry was my least favourite for this round, and one of my least favourites in the round you did compete in. You haven't given me anything that is as good as the other four showed me. Not going to sit here and be like "Yes!!! Come back and serve more subpar vanilla pop!!!" because I'd rather focus on contestants who come up with interesting concepts and entries.

Jesus christ. It's like everything I do is blah boring to you, regardless of what I send in. Like, do you like ANYTHING on this ****ing planet? Its' like Eeyore drugged you or something as well.

It's one thing to be a harsh judge, but your way too negative. You also fail to even provide CONSTRUCTIVE criticism to people. Like...really...you're a terrible judge. You're just negative without being constructive. Calling something interesting or boring doesn't help me make my next entry better at all. Not one bit.

[conatus]

Originally posted by MusicLoverDude

Jesus christ. It's like everything I do is blah boring to you, regardless of what I send in. Like, do you like ANYTHING on this ****ing planet? Its' like Eeyore drugged you or something as well.

It's one thing to be a harsh judge, but your way too negative. You also fail to even provide CONSTRUCTIVE criticism to people. Like...really...you're a terrible judge. You're just negative without being constructive. Calling something interesting or boring doesn't help me make my next entry better at all. Not one bit.

I'm not going to humour you and your childish sore loser ways anymore. My job is to judge, yours was to submit entries. I didn't like the entries you submitted, and neither did the other judges, it seems. But sure, I'm the bad guy here!

[MusicLoverDude]

Originally posted by conatus

I'm not going to humour you and your childish sore loser ways anymore. My job is to judge, yours was to submit entries. I didn't like the entries you submitted, and neither did the other judges, it seems. But sure, I'm the bad guy here!

Because you're a bad judge who only says their negative opinion without offering advice. It doesn't help at all.

Maybe my entry would have been better if I wasn't so in the dark on how to construct a good entry. My cohesiveness in my first entry got me eliminated, which is why I went for something more outside of the box this time around, and then still failed. If you guys wanted good entries, then why don't y'all give more constructive criticism. Not every bitch in this game is like Scene and can make a good entry like it's a piece of cake. Or at least, in your guy's eyes.

collin offered better advice than you did and he gave me a lower score than you in that one round. I actually used that advice for my comeback entry.

You also couldn't even point out positive stuff about my entry that I noticed myself, which shows how ****ing bad of a judge you are.

I have things to do now.

Bye.

[Scene.]

[DripDrip]

I love conatus as a judge