[Honey]

Ace, imma need you to reveal the rest of the rankings tonight.

[skyler]

i love underneath the stars and cant let go

[nicklada]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

My heart BREAKS on that last line. More honest than anything on Music Box or Mariah Carey.

With that kind of specificity, it's clear that Mariah and Taylor share a lot. That's what makes them geniuses.

fff reading your CLG writeup had me thinking maybe Mariah was the Taylor of the 90s but I didn't want to say anything.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by nicklada

fff reading your CLG writeup had me thinking maybe Mariah was the Taylor of the 90s but I didn't want to say anything.

Oh definitely, she was. Taylor gets a lot of b.s. comparisons to Shania, which are ludicrous because Shania very pointedly never wrote anything revealing or personal. (Except for You're Still the One and You've Got a Way. That's why they're the best things she's ever done.)

[supaspaz]

I liked "Can't Let Go" upon the first few listens, but didn't love it. You've given me a new perspective on the song, though, Ace. I feel like I'm hearing it with fresh ears.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

I wish too.

Let me put it bluntly. There's no way this should have finished behind Honey and Fantasy. No way in Hades.

Well I don't know about that, but it is top 5 material

[Doc]

Wait now, Taylor who?

[nicklada]

Swift.

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Doc

Wait now, Taylor who?

Dayne.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Doc

Wait now, Taylor who?

Taylor Allison "Songwriter of Her Time" Swift. GU, get to it!

[Doc]

Originally posted by nicklada

Swift.

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Taylor Allison "Songwriter of Her Time" Swift. GU, get to it!

nnn;; Good BYE. Y'all really tried it with that.

[Neptune]

Originally posted by Doc

Wait now, Taylor who?

Momsen. Although Mariah is yet to have anything that comes close to 'Makes Me Wanna Die'

[Doc]

"Mariah was the Taylor Swift of her time." dddd the DISRESPECT, I can't.

[Ace Reject]

Neptune and Doc, go listen to Sacred and repent. Heathens.

Kworb, it's a holiday, time for celebration! Come together, in every nation! #truthordare

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Doc

"Mariah was the Taylor Swift of her time." dddd the DISRESPECT, I can't.

But how many Album of the Year Grammys does Mariah have?

[Doc]

Ace, Taylor "We (EE!) Are Never, EVER Getting Back Together... like, EVER!" Swift has NEVER been on Mariah's level.

Let's just go to the next song.

[madonnas]

Honey didn't even get top 5? Ugh.

[nicklada]

Originally posted by Doc

"Mariah was the Taylor Swift of her time." dddd the DISRESPECT, I can't.

Mess. I think Taylor is... not for me but I'm not familiar with her lyrics. Let's wait for GU's long winded analysis to know the full tea.

[Taste of Honey]

"Can't Let Go" is one of her best songs ever, glad to see it get the recognition it deserves.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Doc

Ace, Taylor "We (EE!) Are Never, EVER Getting Back Together... like EVER!" Swift has NEVER been on Mariah's level.

Taylor "writer of Tim McGraw, Fifteen, Dear John, Begin Again, White Horse, Mean, Nine, Enchanted" Swift has always been on the same level as Mariah "writer of Vision of Love, Can't Let Go, Emotions, Make It Happen, If It's Over, Looking In, Butterfly, The Roof, Breakdown, Outside" Carey. This is non-negotiable.

Coming up - two songs explicitly about sex. One you'll see tonight, the other tomorrow!