You guys are delusional. Why would a writer that's worked with Beyoncé throw her under the bus and out her as not being responsible for her music? So they could never be employed again by any Roc Nation artists? So they'd lose creditability as discreet ghost writers in an industry that relies on them? She's a talented woman, this isn't one of her talents, though, and I'm not sure why you can't just accept that
I don't understand how pressed the Hive can be at times regarding this woman. You'd think that she gave birth to each one individually, paid their college tuition, and has a nice little trust-fund set-up for each one that she regularly contributes to.
I don't understand how pressed the Bey Haters are. You would think, she killed your mothers, stole your boyfriends, got you fired from your jobs etc...
She gave her opinion that artists in general if they do just change really miniscule aspects of a song they aren't really songwriters. Plus the damn interviewer brought Beyonce up in the first place. You Hive are so quick to jump down anyone that mildly criticizes Beyonce's throat and attack them.
I mean... no one is attacking Linda... check the first pages you will see trolls coming...
You guys are delusional. Why would a writer that's worked with Beyoncé throw her under the bus and out her as not being responsible for her music? So they could never be employed again by any Roc Nation artists? So they'd lose creditability as discreet ghost writers in an industry that relies on them? She's a talented woman, this isn't one of her talents, though, and I'm not sure why you can't just accept that
Because there's nothing to accept. Why people don't accept the fact that Beyoncé is involved in the creation of her music? Accept, move on.
You guys are delusional. Why would a writer that's worked with Beyoncé throw her under the bus and out her as not being responsible for her music? So they could never be employed again by any Roc Nation artists? So they'd lose creditability as discreet ghost writers in an industry that relies on them? She's a talented woman, this isn't one of her talents, though, and I'm not sure why you can't just accept that
A better question is why do you (and others in this thread) have this need to prove she's not a talented songwriter? Why does it get under your skin so much?
You guys are delusional. Why would a writer that's worked with Beyoncé throw her under the bus and out her as not being responsible for her music? So they could never be employed again by any Roc Nation artists? So they'd lose creditability as discreet ghost writers in an industry that relies on them? She's a talented woman, this isn't one of her talents, though, and I'm not sure why you can't just accept that
So we're supposed to believe a writer who's NEVER worked or been in the studio with Beyonce?
Lets just have in mind that 5 other writers worked on Irreplaceable which means that the slight changes made on Ne-Yo's demo were not made only by Beyonce herself, she had a lot of help. Her input on the song is about 5% If that makes you think she's a real songwriter than good for you but that's just not the truth.
I know right! Beyonce is a great singer so I don't understand their desperation(and Beyonce's) to get recognition in every other area even when she doesn't deserve it.
Exactly. She's vocally gifted and she's an entertainer. Her fans enjoy her shows and that should be enough. I don't know why she has to take sole responsibility for every single thing. It's like being a successful musician isn't enough. She has to have credit for the lighting, the directing, the staging, songwriting, production or it doesn't count.
Beyonce has done many collaborations, but she also has projects that she's worked from the ground up.
No one can really make the blanket statement that she changes one word and that's it. That may be the case sometimes, but that's why she'll be listed last or second to last on the credits. Like in Smash Into You/Satellites where she's listed last or not listed at all like in If I Were a Boy/I Was Here.
That doesn't mean all her credits are attained that way.
In the case of Diva/Irreplaceable/Partition/Drunk In Love she wrote whole verses and it shows.
see. this is how thes rumors go .lol who is pressed?
why people can't accept you get the credit for your input.
it is what is is nowadays in mainstream pop/urban music.
producers,beat makers get credit for their beats. not juse whole track but some parts beat.
that's why you can see 4~8 people in 1 hip-hop song.
just like drunk in love's 8 writer credit list.
Noel Fishe (detail) - producer
Andre Eric Proctor, Rasool Diaz, Brian Soko - prroduction team 'the order' they made the original track with detail.
Timothy Mosley (timbaland) Jerome Harmon(timbaland's partner) - additional production.
boots - additional production.
beyonce - lyrics, melodys
jay-z - lyrics
Lets just have in mind that 5 other writers worked on Irreplaceable which means that the slight changes made on Ne-Yo's demo were not made only by Beyonce herself, she had a lot of help. Her input on the song is about 5% If that makes you think she's a real songwriter than good for you but that's just not the truth.
So by your logic any artist who work with other songwriters once or a few times, should remove "songwriter" from their resume? C'mon, you're making yourself sound crazy now and I don't want people to think that of you
So basically another "did you hear beyonce rumor? Oh that's awful.
News:He/she expose beyonce!"
So far everyone worked with beyonce in person said other things.
Only those internet gossip people ride those fake rumors. Boring.
It's not a rumor though. She got songwriting credit for changing one word in this song from the Jon McLaughlin version:
This interviewer knew damn well what they were trying to stir up, but in any case, this is NOT some kind of far fetched rumor. It actually has happened and it she gave a valid response to this situation.
The Hive wants to discredit logic from this situation and just spew PR propaganda that Beyonce has tried to convince everyone of for years. Linda Perry is not some random songwriter of the street trying to speak negatively of the Golden Cow that is Beyonce. The woman has written some of the biggest hits for some of the most influential artists thus far. Get a grip and some sense.
The thing is that most of today's pop stars doesn't do SH*T for their music... and the people who stan for them is proud of it because "at least my fave doesn't pretend... my fave is honest"
I mean... what a self drag talentless chanteuse that is...
I don't understand how pressed the Hive can be at times regarding this woman. You'd think that she gave birth to each one individually, paid their college tuition, and has a nice little trust-fund set-up for each one that she regularly contributes to.
The fact of the matter is that Beyonce even has a writing credit for "Silent Night" of all songs which was taken from DC's Christmas album. You do the math.
Mariah Carey also has a writing credit for "Joy to the World." Was she the original writer?
It's called getting credit for vocal arrangement sis.
The Hive wants to discredit logic from this situation and just spew PR facts that Beyonce has tried to convince everyone of for years. Linda Perry is not some random songwriter of the street trying to speak negatively of the Golden Cow that is Beyonce. The woman has written some of the biggest hits for some of the most influential artists thus far. Get a grip and some sense.
Sis, you've been clocked with receipts left and right and you're still vomiting your same speech?