[KKCuteCat]

Originally posted by Beyond Say

In what world is Celine one of the biggest pop stars? Whitney's Influence (which includes Mariah & Celine) & Impact >>>

Celine albums and tours sales >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the other pop divas. She's actually only less successful than Madonna commercially

[T.C]

Originally posted by YoYo

Wow, just...wow

Oh and, Mariah gave us the absolute standard for flopping (AKA Glitter) at the age of 31 until Bionic came and snatched that prestigious title.

Janet DOES have more impact then Britney though. No lies were told at all.

[Beyond Say]

Originally posted by KKCuteCat

Celine albums and tours sales >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the other pop divas. She's actually only less successful than Madonna commercially

But, when it comes to OVERALL CAREER beyond commercial success Mariah & Whitney trump her.

IDK, what it is with you girls and believing that commercial success defines someone's impact or legendary status. As Chimier would say, Celine has done nothing for the progression of popular music like Madonna, Whitney, & Mariah. When we factor in commercial success, influence, respect, & impact they ALL trump her.

[atrlster]

Madonna
Britney
Gaga

[B2R4D]

Madonna, Mariah and Whitney. Although, I think Britney deserves to be there. It's hard to limit it to 3.

[ToMmY]

Madonna
Mariah Carey
Britney Spears

[YoYo]

Originally posted by tcweh

Janet DOES have more impact then Britney though. No lies were told at all.

I'd say she has a lot more influence, IDK .

[Japoy]

Madonna
Mariah Carey
Beyonce

[Robert]

Madonna, Whitney and Britney.

[T.C]

Originally posted by YoYo

I'd say she has a lot more influence, IDK .

And more acclaim and respect. Even though she hasn't been commercially relevant since Superbowl, people still are citing Janet as influences today. Not to mention she helped create the New Jack Swing genre, Brit doesn't compare really.

[Ressti]

It's not 3, it's 4.

Madonna, Mariah, Whitney & Janet.

Britney and Beyonce may be added to the list if they can remain relevant till they're 40 something.

[rbautz]

Originally posted by Ressti

It's not 3, it's 4.

Madonna, Mariah, Whitney & Janet.

Britney and Beyonce may be added to the list if they can remain relevant till they're 40 something.

Is Janet relevant in the US since she is 40?

Here in Europe I would say since the early 90's she is no longer relevant.

[MiguelPortugal]

Originally posted by YoYo

Wow, just...wow

Oh and, Mariah gave us the absolute standard for flopping (AKA Glitter) at the age of 31 until Bionic came and snatched that prestigious title.

The irony! My fave didn't flop hard at age 26, though.

5th studio albums:

Britney - Blackout - Age: 26
US chart-run: 2-7-23-41-41-51-53-41-34-37-35-35-48-60-68-77-73-87-88-89-95-97

Mariah - Daydream - Age: 25
US chart-run (top 100): 1-1-1-2-2-2-2-3-3-2-1-1-1-2-2-2-4-4-3-4-4-5-4-6-6-7-7-5-8-11-12-15-13-14-14-19-19-19-
21-22-20-18-19-24-26-27-27-35-39-47-49-54-64-72-71-76-85-86-83-86-85-72-68-70-75-84-94-102-93-91-98

Mariah's first flop album (Glitter - age 31) debuted at #1 in Japan - the 2nd biggest music market in the world. Britney's first flop album (Blackout - Age 26) didn't top ANY major market (USA, Japan or UK).

Not you talking about flops at age 31.

[DirtyMind]

1. Whitney
2. Madonna
3. Diana

[superben]

Where are Cher & Diana Ross?

Anyway, top 3: Madonna, Diana Ross & Cher

I see Whitney as more of a vocalist than a pop star, so Idk.

[Nathan's Nicely]

Mariah, Britney, and Madonna.

[Bie]

Originally posted by MiguelPortugal

The irony! My fave didn't flop hard at age 26, though.

5th studio albums:

Britney - Blackout - Age: 26
US chart-run: 2-7 23-41-41-51 53-41-34-37-35-35-48-60-68-77-73-87-88-89-95-97

Mariah - Daydream - Age: 25
US chart-run (top 100): 1-1-1-2-2-2-2-3-3-2-1-1-1-2-2-2-4-4-3-4-4-5-4-6-6-7-7-5-8-11-12-15-13-14-14-19-19-19-
21-22-20-18-19-24-26-27-27-35-39-47-49-54-64-72-71-76-85-86-83-86-85-72-68-70-75-84-94-102-93-91-98

Mariah's first flop album (Glitter - age 31) debuted at #1 in Japan - the 2nd biggest music market in the world. Britney's first flop album (Blackout - Age 26) didn't top ANY major market (USA, Japan or UK).

Not you talking about flops at age 31.

why are you comparing with Blackout? I don't think you don't know what happened during Blackout era

[T.C]

Originally posted by rbautz

Is Janet relevant in the US since she is 40?

Here in Europe I would say since the early 90's she is no longer relevant.

Oh, is that why 'Together Again' was the 2nd biggest selling female single in Europe of 1998? You tried though.

[QuitmanDJ]

Madonna
Britney
Whitney

[mermaid_ariel]

Madonna. Janet. & Whitney.