[Middle of Selena]

Originally posted by Liana

Don't Forget, Catch Me, Fix A Heart & Unbroken charted on Hot 100 without any promo. The first three are ballads & the last three are not even singles (Don't Forget isn't even a proper single), where is HTL though with all that promo?

HTL is 3rd single funny u guys always come for HTL and forget the CHART PERFORMANCE OF LOVE SONG AND WHO SAYS 1 SONG CAN'T DECIDE THE CHART PERFORMANCE OF THE ARTIST

GYHAB wasn't charted until it got video release and 1 months after radio adds

READ MY POST AGAIN I WAS TALKING ABOUT THE NO OF WEEKS CHARTED

[SelenitaStan]

Originally posted by Lovatostan

They released a video, sent it for adds and she performed it

I think that's enough for it to AT LEAST chart or crack top 40 on radio.

Not when Love Song is smashing and radios clearly refuse to play it.

[pika]

Originally posted by Lovatostan

They released a video, sent it for adds and she performed it

I think that's enough for it to AT LEAST chart or crack top 40 on radio.

It's a 3rd single as well, and Selena has no intentions of giving it attention whatsoever. Its been paid dust for months, I wouldn't expect it to smash either.

[Liana]

Originally posted by pika

Hit The Lights got an adds date months after all the HTL promo died down. Did you expect people to magically remember her EMA performance all the way up until now to buy the song? HTL was overshadowed by LYLALS smashing anyways, and nobody saw that coming.

You would expect HTL to do better considering the success of LYLALS. ...& let's not forget the gap between Skyscraper & GYHAB

[pika]

Originally posted by Liana

Demi wins if you consider their 'peaks'

They're pretty even once you break it down, and Selena has all the mini charts to back her up. Not everything is just about the Hot 100.

[pika]

Originally posted by Liana

You would expect HTL to do better considering the success of LYLALS. ...& let's not forget the gap between Skyscraper & GYHAB

But HTL got promo BEFORE the adds date. GYHAB is getting promo while it is a current single.

[Middle of Selena]

Originally posted by Lovatostan

They released a video, sent it for adds and she performed it

I think that's enough for it to AT LEAST chart or crack top 40 on radio.

it was her 3rd SINGLE

[RichGirlPlanet]

I think it goes something like this:
Miley > Selena = Demi

[Rob_Matteo]

Originally posted by pika

But HTL got promo BEFORE the adds date. GYHAB is getting promo while it is a current single.

second video + DWTS performance though?

[Starstruck.]

Originally posted by Middle of Selena

HTL is 3rd single funny u guys always come for HTL and forget the CHART PERFORMANCE OF LOVE SONG AND WHO SAYS 1 SONG CAN'T DECIDE THE CHART PERFORMANCE OF THE ARTIST

GYHAB wasn't charted until it got video release and 1 months after radio adds

Just like how you come to Demi when you know damn well she wasn't handled well in the first two eras, don't be a hypocrite.

GYHAB of course charted after the music video I mean duh... we all knew the music video would have the biggest effect

It charted based on the digital sales + streaming points only, she basically had NO Airplay

HTL couldn't chart without the music video or radio adds.

[pika]

Originally posted by Liana

You would expect HTL to do better considering the success of LYLALS. ...& let's not forget the gap between Skyscraper & GYHAB

That logic only works for the main pop girls like Katy Perry and Rihanna. When you're a Disney singer, they're not gonna automatically pick up your next song regardless of the previous one doing well.

[SelenaGomez<3]

absolutely

1. Miley
2. Selena
3. Demi

1 http://acharts.us/performer/miley_cyrus

2 http://acharts.us/performer/selena_gomez_and_scene

3 http://acharts.us/performer/demi_lovato

@Demi fans Why Is it so hard to believe??

[Rob_Matteo]

Originally posted by SelenitaStan

Not when Love Song is smashing and radios clearly refuse to play it.

but again this can be said for everyone, too.

You don't know how many big stations are/were refusing to play Demi's songs, especially Skyscraper.

[Middle of Selena]

Guys lets talk about REMEMBER DECEMBER

[Middle of Selena]

Originally posted by Lovatostan

Just like how you come to Demi when you know damn well she wasn't handled well in the first two eras, don't be a hypocrite.

GYHAB of course charted after the music video I mean duh... we all knew the music video would have the biggest effect

It charted based on the digital sales + streaming points only, she basically had NO Airplay

HTL couldn't chart without the music video or radio adds.

RADIO ADDS AFTER ALMOST 4 MONTHS

[Starstruck.]

Shut up about the 3rd single excuse

Don't Forget has sold over 600,000+++ with no radio adds...just with a music video and one performance (Ellen)

LYLALS is not gonna block HTL to the point where it won't chart, get real and LYLALS was already dead in April don't reach.

[Middle of Selena]

Originally posted by Rob_Matteo

second video + DWTS performance though?

2 video it doesn't count sis i am so surprised that u guys r treating 2 music video as a PROMO

[Rob_Matteo]

Originally posted by Middle of Selena

RADIO ADDS AFTER ALMOST 4 MONTHS

GYHAB was also sent for radio adds basically 4 months after everything about Unbroken died down and there was no buzz anymore.

everything you guys say can be said for all of them too, Selena isn't the only one that got messed up by HWR, if anything i'd say she was the least affected until now.

[pika]

Originally posted by Rob_Matteo

second video + DWTS performance though?

If you Demi fans don't wanna count New Years Eve or the Peoples Choice Awards as relevant promo spots for GYHAB, then DWTS doesn't count for Selena. Who the in the hell watches DWTS anymore? Exactly. And you know a second video doesn't receive as much attention as the first. Come on now.

[Starstruck.]

Originally posted by Middle of Selena

Guys lets talk about REMEMBER DECEMBER

Which was released internationally, you tried.

It had one music video and no radio adds or performances in the US.

YOU tried.