No offense to Gaga stans or whatever, but I don't see Gaga as iconic. Just kind of... weird. I like some of her songs though, just not when she gets preachy.
And as for the general public, I think it genuinely just depends on who you like to listen to best. That's the way I used to be, I never really cared, until I got obsessed with Nicki and found ATRL.
No offense to Gaga stans or whatever, but I don't see Gaga as iconic. Just kind of... weird. I like some of her songs though, just not when she gets preachy.
And as for the general public, I think it genuinely just depends on who you like to listen to best. That's the way I used to be, I never really cared, until I got obsessed with Nicki and found ATRL.
But Nicki isn't just kind of.... weird?
Gaga has seriously impacted pop culture. She's shifted a lot of the focus onto being eccentric and entertaining. See what your fav wore at the VMAs as evidence.
Britney can't sing (well) live. She tries, but she can't. Rihanna can sing circles around her. I like Britney, but she doesn't even write her songs AT ALL. Katy and Rihanna (co)-wrote almost every song from some of their albums. Britney is an amazing entertainer, but I'm not here for fake voice played on playback. Old Britney is been better than Katy, when I think better, I give you that.
Katy is a basic songwriter ('Do you ever feel like a plastic bag ) and rihanna BARELY writes anything, she's credited LAST in every song she's written meaning she wrote the least.
Britney wrote and composed this WORLDWIDE #1 hit.
As well as this:
Britney in her prime was a much better singer, dancer, entertainer, etc, you name it, than rihanna and katy. She also plays the piano (which you can hear in everytime and someday).
Not to mention she can still dance better than either of them ever could/can or will.
Talent wise:
So those are the points accumulated which would rank them as such:
1) Gaga 2) Ke$ha
3) Old Britney
4) Beyonce*
5) Adele*
6) Rihanna, Katy*
8) Britney
*= Not enough knowledge about artist.
And this is the list now considering talent lbr
To answer the question: Britney, Beyonce & Gaga are above the rest because they are icons unlike the other girls whose impact in pop culture is non-existent.
If you have judgement than try the list and be honest and fair. It's what I got with the knowledge I have and the 4 points I made. 5 being the highest. Beyonce could be higher but I dont know if she plays instruments
Quote:
Originally posted by Stevie
Are you serious?
Who is your fave? Ke$ha does all on the list, you can't deny that is talent whether you think otherwise! oh well
Ke$ha is actually talented guys. She's not above Bey but she's a very good songwriter. She can sing surprisingly high (3 octaves) and she plays the guitar. She's more talented then Britney and Rihanna.. that's for sure.
Gaga has seriously impacted pop culture. She's shifted a lot of the focus onto being eccentric and entertaining. See what your fav wore at the VMAs as evidence.
You mean when she wore the red thing with the pope at the Grammys? She was a mess, I'll give you that one.
If you have judgement than try the list and be honest and fair. It's what I got with the knowledge I have and the 4 points I made. 5 being the highest. Beyonce could be higher but I dont know if she plays instruments
Bey doesn't. But Katy and Ke$ha both play the guitar.
Writer(s)
"Mad House" Makeba Riddick, Will Kennard, Saul Milton, Robyn Fenty
"Hard" (featuring Young Jeezy) Terius Nash, Christopher Stewart, Robyn Fenty, Jay Jenkins Tricky Stewart
"Rockstar 101" (featuring Slash) Nash, Stewart, Robyn Fenty, Tricky Stewart
"Fire Bomb" Fauntleroy II, Brian Kennedy, Robyn Fenty
"Rude Boy" Eriksen, Hermansen, Ester Dean, Riddick, Rob Swire, Robyn Fenty
"G4L" Kennard, Milton, Fauntleroy II, Robyn Fenty
"Te Amo" Eriksen, Hermansen, Fauntleroy II, Robyn Fenty
"The Last Song" Fauntleroy II, Kennedy, Ben Harrison, Robyn Fenty
"Here I Go Again" (featuring J-Status) Rogers, Sturken, J-Status, Robyn Fenty
"Willing to Wait" Rogers, Sturken, Nathan Watts, Robyn Fenty
"Music of the Sun" Diane Warren, Rogers, Sturken, Robyn Fenty
"Now I Know" Rogers, Sturken, Robyn Fenty
"A Girl like Me" Robyn Fenty, Rogers Sturken,
"Kisses Don't Lie" Evan Rogers, Carl Sturken, Robyn Fenty
"Break It Off" Sean Paul Henriques, Robyn Fenty, Donovan Bennett, K. Ford
"Run This Town" Shawn Carter, Robyn Fenty, Kanye West, Ernest Wilson, Jeff Bhasker, Alatas Athanasios
You mean when she wore the red thing with the pope at the Grammys? She was a mess, I'll give you that one.
That... and when she decided to dress up as a stuffed animal ninja. Or with the wigs, etc, etc.
Nicki basically jacked Gaga's whole "I'm weird" thing and used it for herself. Katy's E.T video had eccentric visuals despite the song being about alien sex. She could have easily made that video into what she normally does, but instead she went all weird.
All you all laughing! Try and fill in the list! see what happens when you really accumulate all the talent your fave has. I am not just making this **** up. so SIT
