[fineandbambi]

Originally posted by Golden

You people need to learn to quote.

IKR. The ****?

[RichGirlPlanet]

Originally posted by Golden

You people need to learn to quote.

imawdwsawdthing screwed up his quote, so my reply got messed up as well.

[itsJAMESbitch]

Originally posted by iamanearthling

in my opinion she was, so tht argument is invalid to me...

lmao stop being ridiculous. if she wasn't screaming, then she wasn't screaming. you can't argue that. you can say it sounds like screaming, but that's different than saying she IS screaming. get the difference?

[iamanearthling]

Originally posted by RichGirlPlanet

Beyonce's vocals aren't about how loud she can go.
It's her range, resonance, etc.
Clearly you don't know anything about vocals
and you're trying to replace facts with unmerited opinions.

But anyways...

I prefer Beyonce's version, but Britney's is surprisingly cute.
Also, can we cut the "more emotional garbage"?
Just because you don't know anything about Beyonce, or can't relate to her,
doesn't mean her cover was emotionless.

ok mr i know many things abt vocals.....i (mr dont know anythin abt vocals) thought tht the song wasnt suited for her...she tried to bring the song into another level n failed...imo of course...

[Da beezness!]

Originally posted by Bdawg

now it's all about what they like. Like you think some bey stans didn't vote for bey? Stop shading Stans for no reason.

No Sis. Actually he has a point. It's like you feel obligate to vote for Britney everytime she's up against Beyoncé. You always vote Britney no matter what: fashion, vocals, mariage, weave, melanin and so on.
Granted you could say the same about The Beyhive but we frankly has the receipts that at least make our opions thinkable and realistic.

I could understand if the poll was about to determine which one of HIAM and RTW was the best song since they are totally different, but THIS ****? No, I refuse.

[iamanearthling]

Originally posted by itsJAMESbitch

lmao stop being ridiculous. if she wasn't screaming, then she wasn't screaming. you can't argue that. you can say it sounds like screaming, but that's different than saying she IS screaming. get the difference?

how is she not when c clearly is to me?...

[iamanearthling]

i'm sry abt the quotin thing...

[itsJAMESbitch]

Originally posted by iamanearthling

how is she not when c clearly is to me?...

girl, bye. i am not here to educate you on simple concepts.

[RichGirlPlanet]

Originally posted by iamanearthling

ok mr i know many things abt vocals.....i (mr dont know anythin abt vocals) thought tht the song wasnt suited for her...she tried to bring the song into another level n failed...imo of course...

Failed how, exactly?

[itsJAMESbitch]

Originally posted by Da beezness!

No Sis. Actually he has a point. It's like you feel obligate to vote for Britney everytime she's up against Beyoncé. You always vote Britney no matter what: fashion, vocals, mariage, weave, melanin and so on.
Granted you could say the same about The Beyhive but we frankly has the receipts that at least make our opions thinkable and realistic.

I could understand if the poll was about to determine which one of HIAM and RTW was the best song since they are totally different, but THIS ****? No, I refuse.

i agree with this, but i don't think they will get it.

[itsJAMESbitch]

Originally posted by RichGirlPlanet

Failed how, exactly?

just...don't bother.

[caerbayn]

Originally posted by iamanearthling

how is she not when c clearly is to me?...

You can't scream with vibrato. That's called singing.

[Blue.]

I chose the one that can actually sing.
The King B > The Queen B.

[iamanearthling]

Originally posted by itsJAMESbitch

girl, bye. i am not here to educate you on simple concepts.

i'm not the one here who needs education...some of u all here just need to learn how to accept other ppl's opnion and life would be easier...

[FAME.]

Originally posted by beyoncefan1

I'll take the ones who can actually sing for $1,000 Alex.

! I mean

[MovinKindaSlow]

Britney did it better, I think Beyoncé actually forgot the lyrics at one point

[iamanearthling]

Originally posted by RichGirlPlanet

Failed how, exactly?

u know everythin i'm sure you'll figure it out...

[Gui Blackout]

They both did great jobs, I like Britney's better but Bey's is really good too.

[Amaru]

Originally posted by B94

It's funny how overly sensitive and defensive the hive gets when it comes to Beyonce vs Britney. They always have to resort to insults, a lot of post in this thread are re-portable. Most Britney stans didn't even insult Beyonce or say Britney was a better vocalist than Bey. All that was said was they prefer Britney's cover over Bey.

I didn't see any insults...

This is a public forum, you have the right to think Britney sang it better, but don't whine after someone shows you how wrong you are.

I dont understand why that is difficult to understand

[itsJAMESbitch]

Originally posted by iamanearthling

i'm not the one here who needs education...some of u all here just need to learn how to accept other ppl's opnion and life would be easier...

what exactly are you not understanding? it is a fact that she was not screaming, since, for example, like someone else said, there was vibrato in her vocals. you can't scream like that. It is your opinion that it SOUNDS LIKE screaming. but the fact remains that she was NOT.