[Flawle$$]

Originally posted by Cookie

No. Performing at the SB doesn't make you a legend (see Bruno Mars, Coldplay and Katy Perry).

Coldplay are legends tho
But i agree

[Madonna]

Originally posted by KillingYourCareer

I dunno, is Paula Abdul considered a legend? If so, then Gaga can be considered one too.

Ofc not, but she's the Katy Perry of the 80s
OT: Yes, Gaga is a legend

[GlitterfiedCyrus]

A pop fad with one maybe two hit eras who is best remembered now for wearing raw meat, a legend? No.

[DevonDreams]

No.

[mrnick]

ahmmm... NO.

[uhton]

Yes, she is. Close the thread now

[Hall Of Flames]

Originally posted by GlitterfiedCyrus

A pop fad with one maybe two hit eras who is best remembered now for wearing raw meat, a legend? No.

[yogosans14]

Nope and she'll never be one

[Reinvention]

She has been since "Beautiful, Dirty Rich."

[Salvatore]

She isn't yet. But she's on the way of becoming one.

The answers of the OGHs though are tragic
If Britney and Beyonce are legends, then Gaga is one too.

[Pedro]

no

[GypsyPrince]

She was destined to be a legend since 2008, and she is definitely one now.

The OGH can TRY to disagree, but even their disagreements will end up making her more of a legend because that status has no correlation to chart success.

A true legend.

[T.C]

Originally posted by Salvatore

She isn't yet. But she's on the way of becoming one.

The answers of the OGHs though are tragic
If Britney and Beyonce are legends, then Gaga is one too.

Comparing her to them. They had more than two successful eras and have been around for nearly 20 years.

[Petty Bourgeoisie]

She's... quite famous and somewhat popular... still... but not a legend. Never will be. Not when Fame Monster CDs are still being sold with this sticker attached:

"The defining pop star of 2009"

Katy ain't, Bruno ain't, Gaga ain'T.

[ahauntingnearu]

don't think so. she really lost all the momentum she had built for herself, and she had a great year last year in terms of critical acclaim, but she does NOT have the GP even slightly, so she needs to rebuild some of what she built for herself.

obvs just a prediction, but i don't think she'll ever be huge again, and i think in 20+ years time, she will absolutely not be huge, but rather just be remembered as a fad who was talented. please prove me wrong, though, gaga

[misterbroro]

Originally posted by ultraviolento

nah, the impact + influence + iconic catalogue is definitely lacking

Ironic coming from a Charli XBOX stan

[Truffle.]

Lmao.

[Survivors]

Originally posted by GlitterfiedCyrus

A pop fad with one maybe two hit eras who is best remembered now for wearing raw meat, a legend? No.

I agree

[One Nation]

No.

[Duca]

nah