[Beatfreak]

I think that all she wanted was for people to talk it up, and that seems to be working.

[Aaron]

Don't understand, it's still a bad title.

[Twai]

Originally posted by Nicole

omg the threads, essays, analyses, impassioned arguments over 6 letters

How dare people be passionate about pop music, mirite LOL? It's just pop music, nothing is ever intentional, just dance and have fun to whatever is most popular, mirite LOL?

[Twai]

Originally posted by Aaron

Don't understand, it's still a bad title.

OK so, do you maybe see how I'm not ever going to side with you? Do you really not understand how pointless a statement like this is?

You admit you don't understand, but you insist that it categorically IS a bad title.

Maybe admit you don't understand, and try to?

I wrote that big OP about the possibilities of the era and why it's not far from what has come before, and all you respond with is "It's still bad." Wanna tell me why? Want to tell me what you don't like about it?

[Ramcoro]

We haven't even heard the album yet.

[Jack. Bauer]

Originally posted by Twai

How dare people be passionate about pop music, mirite LOL? It's just pop music, nothing is ever intentional, just dance and have fun to whatever is most popular, mirite LOL?

But naturally, only Gaga could cause such a stir.

[Twai]

Originally posted by Ramcoro

We haven't even heard the album yet.

That's exactly what the OP is saying

The title itself is not an inherently new, ludicrously offensive escalation of anything about Gaga's aesthetic. It is, in fact, a return to the themes and aims of her earlier work, which is exactly what everyone screaming about her pretentiousness wanted her to do to begin with.

[Allstar]

I'm loving this thread so much. Wonder what she's planned for the era after her next era

[Onen]

Originally posted by Beatfreak

I think that all she wanted was for people to talk it up, and that seems to be working.

Exactly, she knows what shes doing

[RobynYoBank]

Originally posted by Twai

which is exactly what everyone screaming about her pretentiousness wanted her to do to begin with.

I remember the last time she gave her fans exactly what they asked for (The Edge of Glory video).

[Gui Blackout]

Eh, stans really need to stop over-analyzing things.

[Golden]

Originally posted by Twai

OK so, do you maybe see how I'm not ever going to side with you? Do you really not understand how pointless a statement like this is?

You admit you don't understand, but you insist that it categorically IS a bad title.

Maybe admit you don't understand, and try to?

I wrote that big OP about the possibilities of the era and why it's not far from what has come before, and all you respond with is "It's still bad." Wanna tell me why? Want to tell me what you don't like about it?

Can you stop replying with an essay to every person that doesn't like the album title.

[Vini]

Such an interesting read so far y'all

[Twai]

Originally posted by Gui Blackout

Eh, stans really need to stop over-analyzing things.

You're really not adding anything to the conversation. If you disagree with anything I wrote, tell me. Don't try to act like you're automatically right and I'm automatically wrong.

There's a difference between analyzing and over-analyzing, and you don't get to decide the line.

[Jack. Bauer]

The simple rotation of the words 'Art' and 'Pop' from the original 'PopArt' is genius enough to make for a brilliant title.
PopArt was Popular Art.
ArtPop is Artistic Pop.

[Retro]

Originally posted by Gui Blackout

Eh, stans really need to stop over-analyzing things.

But it's fun.

[BoyOnBoy Wonder]

Interpretations are fun. That's why we're all doing this, to those that are asking.

[Twai]

Originally posted by Golden

Can you stop replying with an essay to every person that doesn't like the album title.

Six sentences is an essay? I worry about this forum sometimes.

My problem with so much of the reaction to this is, he's not just saying he doesn't like the title, he's saying it's a bad title. Can you see the difference?

Oops, another essay, sorry to write more than you can handle.

[Gui Blackout]

Originally posted by Twai

You're really not adding anything to the conversation. If you disagree with anything I wrote, tell me. Don't try to act like you're automatically right and I'm automatically wrong.

There's a difference between analyzing and over-analyzing, and you don't get to decide the line.

I'm saying that to both sides, and it wasn't directed to you.

[BoyOnBoy Wonder]

Originally posted by Golden

Can you stop replying with an essay to every person that doesn't like the album title.

It's called rhetoric.