[OnlyManInTheWorld]

Both are iconic queens, having a huge impact on pop culture. Congrats to both

Gaga was my fave long before Taylor so y'all better shut up

[eddytws]

Why the **** is this still not closed

[RicanoRuben]

And Mariah has more than all of them, sooooo until one of these pop tarts get 19, it doesn't really matter how many they have.

[AMENHOOKER]

Getting more than 3 #1s in this day and age isn't an achievement.
Make a tread when Taylor has an album bigger than The Fame/Monster and a single bigger than Poker Face.
At least those will be worth writing home about and monumental.

[Kuntmonster]

Originally posted by LoKoPaNdA

Considering Katy is second only to Taylor in terms of success right now, I don't see how she works well as an example?

#1s are useful to brag just like Grammys and stuff like that.

She has the least impressive receipts of all the pop girls. Lowest album sales, lowest grammies, lowest tour gross total etc. so I am just pointing out that #1s do not hold as much weight as some people want them to.

I mean the fact that Gagas #2 peaking song Bad Romance sold more than any Katy, Taylor, etc single just proves it really

[LoKoPaNdA]

Originally posted by ezra

Gaga and Taylor are both GRAMMY winning artists so having #1's doesn't really matter when you're music's good.

But congrats to Taylor for having the first album since you-know-what to have 3 #1 singles from it

Why do you refuse to name Adele's 21, ezra?

[Schhh]

Originally posted by Kuntmonster

She has the least impressive receipts of all the pop girls. Lowest album sales, lowest grammies, lowest tour gross total etc. so I am just pointing out that #1s do not hold as much weight as some people want them to.

I mean the fact that Gagas #2 peaking song Bad Romance sold more than any Katy, Taylor, etc single just proves it really

Lmao, that's a lie.

[mariomania]

Like it matters. She's still a better artist than taylor and all her contemporaries lol.

Anybody can get #1's with a big machine around them.

[Nemo]

Originally posted by RicanoRuben

And Mariah has more than all of them, sooooo until one of these pop tarts get 19, it doesn't really matter how many they have.

[LoKoPaNdA]

Originally posted by Kuntmonster

She has the least impressive receipts of all the pop girls. Lowest album sales, lowest grammies, lowest tour gross total etc. so I am just pointing out that #1s do not hold as much weight as some people want them to.

I mean the fact that Gagas #2 peaking song Bad Romance sold more than any Katy, Taylor, etc single just proves it really

Not anymore, Katy is slaying everyone but Taylor.

[OnlyManInTheWorld]

Originally posted by LoKoPaNdA

Not anymore, Katy is slaying everyone but Taylor.

Bad Romance was bigger than any Katy's single tbh.

[ezra]

Originally posted by AMENHOOKER

Getting more than 3 #1s in this day and age isn't an achievement.
Make a tread when Taylor has an album bigger than The Fame/Monster and a single bigger than Poker Face.
At least those will be worth writing home about and monumental.

Of course it's an achievement? Taylor's 4th single from an album that's already sold like 4 million copies in the US is a big deal. I'm happy that GRAMMY winning real artists can achieve success in today's tragic pop music scene.

[Cain]

wow, four #1s, that hardly ever happens in pop music...

[Remixed]

Gaga's #1s all sold more and were global though.

[Nemo]

Originally posted by OnlyManInTheWorld

Bad Romance was bigger than any Katy's single tbh.

Mediatraffic says 'Roar' was bigger

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by Artemisia

Impact is in the eye of the beholder, my dear.

Very true but the Bad Romance video alone had more impact on the Pop music landscape than any of Taylor's #1s/MV for those #1. All GaGa. No hype of other celebrities to raise the profile of anything. All GaGa and her talents and vision.

Originally posted by Cain

wow, four #1s, that hardly ever happens in pop music...

It doesn't come easily to all Pop girls. Rih and the Navy were blessed.

[Artemisia]

Originally posted by mariomania

Like it matters. She's still a better artist than taylor and all her contemporaries lol.

Anybody can get #1's with a big machine around them.

Surely her Metascore average should be higher than Taylor's, then! Can anyone confirm?

[LoKoPaNdA]

Originally posted by OnlyManInTheWorld

Bad Romance was bigger than any Katy's single tbh.

Great for Gaga and her 2009 song

[OnlyManInTheWorld]

Originally posted by Nemo

Mediatraffic says 'Roar' was bigger

[chilicheese01]

Originally posted by Goddess of Love.

Poker Face is about her talking about her bisexuality, so yeah it is

It's about equally as creative as the inspiration behind Blank Space... They're cute, little pop ditties. Let's not act like Gaga is topping the charts with some experimental, avant-garde, poetic masterpiece.