[Grin Toll]

Originally posted by Honey

Too bad "On the Floor" wasn't a #1.

And too bad J. Lo didn't have to sink to the level of using Lil Kim to get a #1 hit.

Pink never had any features on one of her singles (even Dear Mr President was released as solo version in select countries). Lady Marmalade had equal billing and is considered as a solo hit unlike:

"Ain't It Funny (Murder Remix)" (featuring Ja Rule and Caddillac Tah)

"I'm Gonna Be Alright (Track Masters Remix)" (featuring Nas)

"Jenny from the Block" (featuring Styles P and Jadakiss)

"All I Have" (featuring LL Cool J)

"I'm Into You" (featuring Lil Wayne)

"Hold You Down" (featuring Fat Joe)

"Dance Again" (featuring Pitbull)

"Goin' In" (featuring Flo Rida)

NOT TO MENTION JLO's CLOSE TO ZERO HIT/FLOP RATIO

[fanoftalent]

[Underdogs]

Originally posted by Grin Toll

Pink never had any features on one of her singles (even Dear Mr President was released as solo version in select countries). Lady Marmalade had equal billing and is considered as a solo hit unlike:

"Ain't It Funny (Murder Remix)" (featuring Ja Rule and Caddillac Tah)

"I'm Gonna Be Alright (Track Masters Remix)" (featuring Nas)

"Jenny from the Block" (featuring Styles P and Jadakiss)

"All I Have" (featuring LL Cool J)

"I'm Into You" (featuring Lil Wayne)

"Hold You Down" (featuring Fat Joe)

"Dance Again" (featuring Pitbull)

"Goin' In" (featuring Flo Rida)

NOT TO MENTION JLO's CLOSE TO ZERO HIT/FLOP RATIO

Screaming

[Grin Toll]

J.lo. Being discussed in a consistency thread

[Honey]

Originally posted by Grin Toll

Pink never had any features on one of her singles (even Dear Mr President was released as solo version in select countries). Lady Marmalade had equal billing and is considered as a solo hit unlike:

"Ain't It Funny (Murder Remix)" (featuring Ja Rule and Caddillac Tah)

"I'm Gonna Be Alright (Track Masters Remix)" (featuring Nas)

"Jenny from the Block" (featuring Styles P and Jadakiss)

"All I Have" (featuring LL Cool J)

"I'm Into You" (featuring Lil Wayne)

"Hold You Down" (featuring Fat Joe)

"Dance Again" (featuring Pitbull)

"Goin' In" (featuring Flo Rida)

NOT TO MENTION JLO's CLOSE TO ZERO HIT/FLOP RATIO

None of those hit #1.

Whatever, I'm not here to defend J. Lo, she's not my fave.

I'm just saying that the Nelly Furtado/J. Lo dragging was unnecessary and it shows how you P!nk fans are insecure about your fave's success to the point that you need to attack other artists to make your fave look better.

[Honey]

Originally posted by Grin Toll

J.lo. Being discussed in a consistency thread

You P!nk stans brought her up.

[YSL]

Originally posted by BoyOnBoy Wonder

'Try This' happened.



Not to mention, her consistency makes her dull. She's simply middling; other than Australia, no others location is *obsessed* with her.

Originally posted by Ahmed.

I just find pink dull and boring to be honest, just my opinion though. She does have some really good music though

Basically all of this. She has some great music but the more she goes into her career, the more boring she gets. She hasn't really changed her musical style either. It's all the same. Like I knew what to expect with her last single and I know what to expect with every future single.

I guess in that sense she is VERY consistent to the point it all kind of sounds the same.

[P!nkInside]

Originally posted by YSL

Basically all of this. She has some great music but the more she goes into her career, the more boring she gets. She hasn't really changed her musical style either. It's all the same. Like I knew what to expect with her last single and I know what to expect with every future single.

Doesn't have any thing to do with consistency. That's just a lame excuse people are giving when they can't deny P!nk is more consistent than her peers.

[Underdogs]

Originally posted by YSL

I guess in that sense she is VERY consistent to the point it all kind of sounds the same.

Guess 70 Million people have bought the same song over and over again

Must be some kind of record

[princedonte]

Yes she is very consistent. She has proved herself time and time again and will do so again wit her new album.

[Devon]

Why is anyone even arguing about this. Just shut this thread, it's not even about Pink anymore!

[Harajuku]

Yes. No question

[Honey]

Originally posted by Devon

Why is anyone even arguing about this. Just shut this thread, it's not even about Pink anymore!

No one is saying that P!nk isn't, it's just that the P!nk stans are doing to most by dragging J. Lo to make their fave's sales look better.

[Grin Toll]

Originally posted by Honey

None of those hit #1.

Whatever, I'm not here to defend J. Lo, she's not my fave.

I'm just saying that the Nelly Furtado/J. Lo dragging was unnecessary and it shows how you P!nk fans are insecure about your fave's success to the point that you need to attack other artists to make your fave look better.

Originally posted by Honey

You P!nk stans brought her up.

I just pulled their receipts since someone downplayed GHSF's success, acting like it's an easy feat. I wasn't dragging either, until you begged me to do so

Obviously we'll compare her sales to others, this doesn't make her look better, it makes her sales look better. Obviously chart success doesn't equal talent. I just think Pink's talent is recognized by general public and supported with consistent sales -one of the most consistent if not the most-

[lpd446]

Originally posted by Honey

None of those hit #1.

Whatever, I'm not here to defend J. Lo, she's not my fave.

I'm just saying that the Nelly Furtado/J. Lo dragging was unnecessary and it shows how you P!nk fans are insecure about your fave's success to the point that you need to attack other artists to make your fave look better.

Coming from a bey stan?

[PoisonPill]

Yes, I'd say she is the consistent pop star of the past decade She's never truly flopped.

[fanoftalent]

Everything was going great in this thread, until some insecure butthurt stans decided to weave their faves into here and diss Pink at the same time.

Just another fun day on ATRL

[rihannabiggestfan]

Originally posted by lpd446

Coming from a bey stan?

Oh I like you even more now

[lpd446]

Originally posted by rihannabiggestfan

Oh I like you even more now

[UnusualBoy]

Originally posted by fanoftalent

In terms of consistency in 2000s (girls with 3 or more albums qualify only):

1) Pink
2) Rihanna
3) Beyonce
4) Alicia Keys
5) Britney
6) Xtina

I agree but I'd put Bey over Rihana, however when they haven't had massive sales it's easier to have consistency