[Cupid]

Thank god! They were so vile to that poor man. Karma is wonderful.

[CarterTax]

I went to sleep when this thread was ~5 pages long and now it's 85 Not this thread having more longevity and staying power than any of her sings or albers

[Lanallah Del Slay]

Originally posted by RihsusChrist(ATG)

Didn't Simon Cowell say nastier things on X Factor and American Idol? This seems like a gross overreaction, tbh. Isn't it a judges job to critique, and be entertaining?

Bitch gonna make bank in that lawsuit... and I hope she, and hubby get a reality show; forget Speidi...make way for Willia!

Simon is wayyyyy worse.

And the couple name will be Nally Koons

[Wonderland]

Originally posted by RihsusChrist(ATG)

Didn't Simon Cowell say nastier things on X Factor and American Idol? This seems like a gross overreaction, tbh. Isn't it a judges job to critique, and be entertaining?

Bitch gonna make bank in that lawsuit... and I hope she, and hubby get a reality show; forget Speidi...make way for Willia!

There's a line between criticism and bullying, sis.

If you don't see Natalia and Willy breaching that line, then I don't know what to say

[popmagic]

Originally posted by Lanallah Del Slay

Simon is wayyyyy worse.

And the couple name will be Nally Koons

Ok this was bad but it was the first auditions.

[Lanallah Del Slay]

But wait at the couple name I chosed having a big meaning

and everyone knows what is a Koon.

[kaiba]

The peak of ha career

[Snoopy]

Originally posted by Wonderland

I can think of many examples which disprove that

Hmm, what do I know... I just live here. Right?

[Slim Shady]

85 pages?!?

[Dollas n Diamonds]

Originally posted by Lanallah Del Slay

Simon is wayyyyy worse.

And the couple name will be Nally Koons

Not Simon calling them corpses

but no Natalia is a demon that should be lynched

"bois will be bois "

[JesusORGod]

The queen did it better.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-L8d4ExlwsA

[Slim Shady]

Originally posted by Lights and Waves

EDIT: YES! First page of a hit thread! If you're reading this, go buy ARTPOP on iTunes. Thanks!

Kii

[Javan]

C'mon guys. Let's get this to page 100. We can do it.

[leightxn]

But of an over reaction even if her comments were awful

[Cap10Planet]

The difference between Natalia Kills and Simon Cowell is that Simon "trashed" the talent if he thought it was bad. He didn't go on a tirade about fashion and 'artistic credibility' and tried to shamelessly promote his significant other's look on national TV. That's not what the show is about. Natalia was clearly not giving "criticism." She was attention-seeking, and no one with good taste or a brain would want to watch that every single week.

[❄ Frosty ❄]

But Natalia is amazing!!! Maybe it was a little vicious, but sometimes criticism is best served bitter. The world outside the X Factor is a lot harsher.

[Lanallah Del Slay]

Originally posted by Dollas n Diamonds

Not Simon calling them corpses

but no Natalia is a demon that should be lynched

"bois will be bois "

She deserves to sue cause she didn't settle for pickle juice.

[Rihinvention]

She's suing because it means more attention and infamy. She knows she's not going to make bank out of it.

[Dollas n Diamonds]

Originally posted by Javan

C'mon guys. Let's get this to page 100. We can do it.

the draggings on both sides in this one

is everyone horribly untalented in NZ? obvs not cause Lorde came from these but why the cheering and applause???

setting them up to crash

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

The difference between Natalia Kills and Simon Cowell is that Simon "trashed" the talent if he thought it was bad. He didn't go on a tirade about fashion and 'artistic credibility' and tried to shamelessly promote his significant other's look on national TV. That's not what the show is about. Natalia was clearly not giving "criticism." She was attention-seeking, and no one with good taste or a brain would want to watch that every single week.

except that exactly what Simon did he even wet in on their looks. you should watch the video

[Snoopy]

Originally posted by ❄ Frosty ❄

But Natalia is amazing!!! Maybe it was a little vicious, but sometimes criticism is best served bitter. The world outside the X Factor is a lot harsher.

What criticism, though? She went off on an artistic integrity rant and accused the guy on stage of stealing her husband style (who I don't think any body even knows, let alone use him for his style...) before he, himself, went off on some whacky rant about Norman Bates....

That is not criticism. That is idiocy.