[iHype.]

If we're gonna bring flop after death into this, let's NOT put Aaliyah's name in this.


Her album went from #19 to #1 after death, her songs after death all charted in the Top 5 on R&B Charts and within the Top 25 on Hot 100.

Her posthumous album debuted at #3 DURING THE WEEK OF CHRISTMAS and #1 on the R&B Charts and sold almost 300,000 while one of the singles topped the R&B Charts for 2 weeks and was #3 on Hot 100.

Queen of the Damned went straight to #1 in the Box Office the week it debuted.

Shall we get further into this?

[QueenBLadyG]

Originally posted by abc1990

okay...they're acting as if this list came from Billboard or Rolling Stones

+1

I can't believe they are so pressed right now! I guess it means more to them than we know.

[Kool_Aid_King]

Originally posted by iHypeMusic

How was her 'single' a flop?!?!?! Omfg, I'm not gonna.

Aaliyah hadn't had anything released in 10 years, and the song wasn't even a SINGLE nor was even buyable and only depended on airplay and still charted on R&B Charts.

Let's not now.

OMG, Gurl. I'm talking about Rock the Boat, not that stupid Drake song :aah:

[satellites.™]

Yas queen, not the best in the last 30 (YET).

But for now.

[iHype.]

Originally posted by Kool_Aid_King

OMG, Gurl. I'm talking about Rock the Boat, not that stupid Drake song :aah:

Rock the Boat was a flop?


Girl, let's not now. It stayed at #2 on the R&B Charts all the way through til around February 2002 when it was released around her death which was in August.

The song retired on 106 & Park, the song topped the Rhythmic Charts, and the video was the most viewed video online between 2001-2002 according to her IDMB page.

[QueenBLadyG]

Originally posted by Kisuke

Cause Beyonce on there when those lists come out aswell

That she is. King slays professional critics as well as music lovers judging by this result.

[ECNEICSNOC]

So in conclusion 4 still won, Voodoo and The Velvet Rope and Butterfly still slay, Aaliyah is still no longer with us, and no one but the top of Billboard's Bubbling Under R&B Songs know who Ciara is.

[Lasers]

Originally posted by iHypeMusic

Rock the Boat was a flop?


Girl, let's not now. It stayed at #2 on the R&B Charts all the way through til around February 2002 when it was released around her death which was in August.

The song retired on 106 & Park, the song topped the Rhythmic Charts, and the video was the most viewed video online between 2001-2002 according to her IDMB page.

this is a pop forum sis. These girls think if a song didn't chart at # 1 in every country, it's a flop

[Kool_Aid_King]

Originally posted by iHypeMusic

If we're gonna bring flop after death into this, let's NOT put Aaliyah's name in this.


Her album went from #19 to #1 after death, her songs after death all charted in the Top 5 on R&B Charts and within the Top 25 on Hot 100.

Her posthumous album debuted at #3 DURING THE WEEK OF CHRISTMAS and #1 on the R&B Charts and sold almost 300,000 while one of the singles topped the R&B Charts for 2 weeks and was #3 on Hot 100.

Queen of the Damned went straight to #1 in the Box Office the week it debuted.

Shall we get further into this?

I really do, but I don't want a WP.

4 > Aaliyah (album)

ATRL knows the tea.

[iHype.]

Originally posted by Lasers

this is a pop forum sis. These girls think if a song didn't chart at # 1 in every country, it's a flop

Yesss gurl, and in Aaliyah's standards - mind you when music was good, and getting awards and #1's were worth something, how was Rock the Boat a flop?

People were acting like every song she released before she died was a #1 hit tho...

[Jaxsin]

Originally posted by iHypeMusic

Rock the Boat was a flop?


Girl, let's not now. It stayed at #2 on the R&B Charts all the way through til around February 2002 when it was released around her death which was in August.

The song retired on 106 & Park, the song topped the Rhythmic Charts, and the video was the most viewed video online between 2001-2002 according to her IDMB page.

[Kool_Aid_King]

I CAN, however whole-heartedly agree that 4 is the best R&B album of the 2010's

[Energy]

Noooo, I missed all of it.

[Lasers]

Originally posted by Jaxsin

106 was huge back then. It's not local or as ratchet as it is now.

[iHype.]

Originally posted by Kool_Aid_King

I really do, but I don't want a WP.

4 > Aaliyah (album)

ATRL knows the tea.

Why are you sitting here trying to compare Beyonce and Aaliyah tho?

Like wtf, nobody even brung up Aaliyah's name in this thread til you came mad we said 4 wasn't the best album.

Why are you so pressed on Aaliyah?

Said by her the best, "Enough Said".

[BLaCKPoWeR]

The Red Album debuted at #2 with 183K.

Her previous albums both spwaned a slew of Top 10s.

Leave it at that PLS.

[iHype.]

Nobody brung up Aaliyah's name tho. Why do you want a death match between 4 and Aaliyah?

If you were so confident in 4 all you would need is this thread where it clearly says she's #1, instead of bringing up deceased singers who made an album 11 years ago.

[Big Smoke]

4 is Beyonce only good album. Its a DAMN good album. (outside of that girls crap)

But cmon son, this is some Dhalsim style reaching lol

[iHype.]

Originally posted by BLaCKPoWeR

The Red Album debuted at #2 with 183K.

Her previous albums both spwaned a slew of Top 10s.

Leave it at that PLS.

And you do realize her past 2 albums both sold over 100k+ weeks, and opened up with 70k+ weeks something that can easily get you a #1 nowadays, where charts aren't worth much.

How about you stop leaving the discussion to Queen Aaliyah and be happy Beyonce won.

[Lasers]

Originally posted by BLaCKPoWeR

The Red Album debuted at #2 with 183K.

Her previous albums both spwaned a slew of Top 10s.

Leave it at that PLS.

but where's 4's top 10s? The b*tch had a huge campaign, promoted on oprah, award shows, , glatson bury, DVD'S, not to mention BABY publicity. So what's the logic here?