[morbeen4444]

Hearing her at the cry in the end made it so much worse. You know she wanted this and she gets eliminated way too soon!! I definitely voted for her last night. She was the BEST vocalist in the competition. They shouldn't had a SECOND judges' save and used on her. I wish STEFANO would go home, I don't like him at all!!!! He should have went home INSTEAD of Pia.

[Fireman25]

I'm going to to be surprised if Lauren ends up winning the whole thing. I think she will be the last female standing.

Final 2 prediction Scotty VS Lauren. with Lauren winning.

[Stepfon]

Pia should not be going home this early in the season but I also blame the judges because I feel like they overly praise some of the contestants, especially Steven. Paul is the worst singer and performer, he should have left weeks ago. Idol is a sausage fest because of the teen girls so I think Scotty will be in the Final Two.

[Fireman25]

Originally posted by Stepfon

Pia should not be going home this early in the season but I also blame the judges because I feel like they overly praise some of the contestants, especially Steven. Paul is the worst singer and performer, he should have left weeks ago. Idol is a sausage fest because of the teen girls so I think Scotty will be in the Final Two.

Exactly. Most of these voters are young horny females. That is why all the guys are still on and most of the females are already gone. The males don'r really care too much for American Idol. I gave this show another chance because of the big changes they were doing , but it's still the same ****.

[Nait Phoenix]

And to think, I was ready to give this show another chance after last season's trainwreck of a show. There's no one I'm rooting for, so why should I watch? I can't wait for the record company that's going to give her a chance to come scoop her up and make her the next J. Hudson.

[Stepfon]

Originally posted by Fireman25

Exactly. Most of these voters are young horny females. That is why all the guys are still on and most of the females are already gone. The males don'r really care too much for American Idol. I gave this show another chance because of the big changes they were doing , but it's still the same ****.

Yeah, I have watched the show since the beginning so it's kind of hard for me to give it up now but that's just the way the cookie crumbles, lol.

People are acting like personality shouldn't play a part in the voting but it's apart of the complete package that you need to be a star, Pia's personality was so dull and her performance last night should have landed her in the Bottom 3, she was very stiff and brought NO emotion when singing, that is what the biggest problem I saw with her, she was just dry. But, Idol has proven this: you don't always have to finish Top 5 to be a success story, so I really don't understand all the anger people have with the results.

[DiamondDust]

I actually thought her performance last night was one of her best. The fact that she moved AND hit all those notes is still incredible to me. The fact of the matter is that she was probably the best vocalist this season and there are about five other people that should have been in the Bottom 3 besides her. She got so much **** about those ballads when most of the others except for, well, Haley do the same thing week after week without Pia's astonishing vocal ability.

Personality onstage is something that comes with experience. Most of these contestants have performance experience, but not in front of thousands and millions of people. People need to give Pia a little bit more credit.

[Partino]

WTF did i just watch ?!

My TOP 2 for this year were Pia and Jacob with Pia winning it . OH MY ****ING GEE !!!

i am so angry right now .... ugh

[FAN]

This show has gone down thr ****ing drain after Jordin.

David Cook, Kris Allen, Lee Dewyze, all clones of generic guys in the business, all pretty much flops

a girl needs to win this season, if not, this show is done.

8 contestants left and only 2 girls, & Haley kinda sucks

Lauren has been my favourite since day 1, I really hope she wins. Jacob needs to be sent home, most irratating person we've ever had on the show. Casey, James, Paul who? Stefano ain't bad .

And the judges? Holy **** they have great chemistry, but please replace them! We need someone who can actually criticise on the show?

**** **** ****. Good luck Lauren.


/end rant

[Reeces]

I was in shock when I saw her in the B3, and then she goes home. I think this rivals Chris Daughtry's elimination as the most shocking one ever.

I really hope Haley makes it far. I'm rooting for her.

[Superbitch]

Originally posted by What It Seems

If Interscope signed Medina, they shouldn't have a problem signing Pia

Whos medina

[JC.]

^looks like they didn't sign him, they kinda helped him out sorry

Medina made it to hollywood week but never made it to the top 24, he had the disabled wife.

[Superbitch]

Lol this show was already ****** since karen weny home, then when they saved that retarted looking guy i was done wit it. All.those guys r so awful n ugly lookin seriously wtf is voting.

We have scotty:ugly as hell, boring and IM NOT HERE FOR BORING ASS COUNTRY

Casey:what d id the judges saw in diz guy. He is not marketable at all..ugh i hate him.

The blonde one: meh we already have mike posner(sound da same)

Black guy: sounds like a dying.bitch. Cannot control.those.vocals. Feel like im in church everytime he.performs.

Stefano: hes.the only.decent one, hes.hawt.

Adam lambert pt.2: i am not here for.that mess

Go halye and.hmmmm watever her name is

[Solutionz]

Pia? 9th place... I really dont get it tbh.

[Ryan]

I can't believe America's flop ass sent Pia home. I knew when they judges saved Casey a few weeks ago go that it'd come back and bite them in the ass. Poor Pia

[Sapphire]

Pia???

oh gerll bye
no hope for Idol anymore

Pia should do The Voice!!!

[Deemy]

But I was seriously pissed off tonight. Paul should have went home or Casey Abrams. Why the **** did they save that hillbilly

[INTRA]

Seriously, you guys never thought that this show is rigged? I don't really care about Pia going home this early because I never really like her. I'm just here for Haley.

[Razzle]

Pia out

i guess it will be Lauren,Scotty and James for the top 3..

[SIMon1120]

Paul & Casey seriously need to go home