[Allstar]

Originally posted by rihannabiggestfan

Queen of UK

Wasn't really the answer to my question but if you think avoiding the truth is going to make it less accurate go ahead.

Rihanna has a huge catalogue of singles, many of which ONLY smashed in the US. To imply otherwise would only make your case less valid, especially considering you tried to deem Gaga local.

She was the most global popstar during her peak in decades. If she got herself together (which she won't) she could very well regain all of her previous demand.

[Bounce]

Originally posted by idkher

Katy was a nonfactor even though IKAG and Hot N Cold both sold 8 million worldwide? She just couldn't sell any albums

Kesha had a huge debut era and Tik Tok is still the biggest single of the decade so far so yes she was a main pop girl during her debut..

Circus was released in December 2008

Yeah that's why she's a none factor because she couldn't sell albums, Rihanna was selling 8m from GGGB so....

Kesha debut wasn't big, only her singles again Katy and Kesha did not sell 8m like rihanna before soo...

Circus sold 4m even Britney sold more than Rih

[Stitches.]

Only if she have huge hits like Rihanna had during the Loud era. Rih had three, let's see if Gaga can.

[H-I-M]

Originally posted by TheGreatestThing

I don't know what stats you're using, but



Without actually whipping out a calculator, that looks to be about 2.1-2.3 M, and in a much better sales environment than ARTPOP.

Unless you mean to tell me Rih sold 800,000 copies of RR in Zimbabwe or some ****, I'm not buying this 3M number.

Told yall it was an immense flop.

[rihannabiggestfan]

Originally posted by GypsyLife

But boo it only charted in 9 countries of which 8 were in Europe and the other one was Australia.
She should have released it indeed, I thought it was cause I heard it on the radio quite a few times during holiday but back home nobody heard about it
Oh well.

What about Brazil and such? http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Te_Amo_(Rihanna_song) Is that only 9

[DiaryOfG]

Doing the absolute mosT

[Rainsford]

Originally posted by SupahBass05

I think she's pulling a FF to BJ tbh.

[Bounce]

So ARTPOP is a flop because it didn't match BTW sales and she wasn't selling like her peers
But RR isn't even tho she went from selling 8m to 3m and she wasn't selling like her peers :

[GypsyLife]

Originally posted by rihannabiggestfan

What about Brazil and such? http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Te_Amo_(Rihanna_song) Is that only 9

Lol I was looking at the Dutch page. You better go update that one

[idkher]

Originally posted by TheGreatestThing

I don't know what stats you're using, but



Without actually whipping out a calculator, that looks to be about 2.1-2.3 M, and in a much better sales environment than ARTPOP.

Unless you mean to tell me Rih sold 800,000 copies of RR in Zimbabwe or some ****, I'm not buying this 3M number.

In what universe are certifications listed on Wikipedia pages the be-all end-all of total album sales? The 3 million comes straight from Mediatraffic, the same source which Monsters say DEFLATES sales because they only reported BTW as selling 5.9 million

[Rainsford]

Originally posted by GypsyLife

Te Amo charted in 8 countries in Europe with 9 being highest position in Switserland out of all places...that's not something I'd call very successful.
(Was my summer bop tho )

Te Amo was a hit in Brazil, radio played it a lot.

[Bounce]

Originally posted by idkher

In what universe are certifications listed on Wikipedia pages the be-all end-all of total album sales? The 3 million comes straight from Mediatraffic, the same source which Monsters say DEFLATES sales because they only reported BTW as selling 5.9 million

Your favorite site https://m.facebook.com/2993032868105...8&ref=bookmark clocking you again

just stop, it's getting embarrassing...

[H-I-M]

Originally posted by Bounce

So ARTPOP is a flop because it didn't match BTW sales and she wasn't selling like her peers
But RR isn't even tho she went from selling 8m to 3m and she wasn't selling like her peers :

Dragée, scalpée, photosynthesée.

[MaRy]

Originally posted by TheGreatestThing

I don't know what stats you're using, but



Without actually whipping out a calculator, that looks to be about 2.1-2.3 M, and in a much better sales environment than ARTPOP.

Unless you mean to tell me Rih sold 800,000 copies of RR in Zimbabwe or some ****, I'm not buying this 3M number.

not using these old ass receipts, do you know certifications are not updated? Rated R exited mediatraffic after 1 year at 2.6 millions and then reached 3 eons ago millions as per MT, it could be well higher now

[Rainsford]

I don't even know why this thread exist, RR is platinum while ARTPOP...

[Mr.Marvelous]

Originally posted by idkher

In what universe are certifications listed on Wikipedia pages the be-all end-all of total album sales? The 3 million comes straight from Mediatraffic, the same source which Monsters say DEFLATES sales because they only reported BTW as selling 5.9 million

Thanks for the save sis, I was doubting the 3M for a sec.

[MaRy]

Originally posted by Bounce

Your favorite site https://m.facebook.com/2993032868105...8&ref=bookmark clocking you again

just stop, it's getting embarrassing...

6.3 millions is not 7 millions
also cute to see Loud = TD despite the enormous promo efforts and singles of the latest

[idkher]

Originally posted by Bounce

Yeah that's why she's a none factor because she couldn't sell albums, Rihanna was selling 8m from GGGB so....

Kesha debut wasn't big, only her singles again Katy and Kesha did not sell 8m like rihanna before soo...

Circus sold 4m even Britney sold more than Rih

Just because they weren't huge album sellers doesn't mean they weren't main pop girls of the moment, and either way RR still outsold their albums with less single success so there really is no point to this argument.

Circus didn't sell that much, at the end of 2009 it was at 3.4 million

[H-I-M]

Originally posted by ianBK4

I don't even know why this thread exist, RR is platinum while ARTPOP...

Different climat. Stop trolling and think !

[H-I-M]

Originally posted by MaRy

6.3 millions is not 7 millions
also cute to see Loud = TD despite the enormous promo efforts and singles of the latest

This isn't about Katy, stay on topy *Freestyling like Iggy*