I feel like you could have done so much more with what you have. You're artist has done a good amount of rebellion but I think you did good with this one.
Quote:
Originally posted by KT&T
I think your artist choice makes it easier to do this round to be honest, but your description was spot on and I like your choice of song. Hair is a great example of rebellion for Gaga; it shows that you are entitled to your hair weave and you don’t have to assimilate your style for anyone. I don't think I need to say more because many of us know about Gaga and now how retro, avant-garde her fashion could be. She is rebellious in her choice and style of clothing than others.
Quote:
Originally posted by AllThat****ery
I must admit I wasn't a big fan of Gaga during the BTW era, but you've done excellent this challenge. You were thoroughly and provided examples and the "Hair" performance (might I add I actually hated this song) fit perfect for the round!
10/10
I don't find this relatively rebellious at all because most people are like this nowadays, anyway. On top of the fact there was no rebellious act here, it was SO short, but since you didn't even meet our qualifications, I can see why.
Quote:
Originally posted by KT&T
I have a feeling they are a rebellious group just by their fashion; however I have seen other K-pop groups doing similar style to theirs. I would say they are not that rebellious in that standard. Also what they seems to display in their video is shock art. I am not that completely shocked by what they wear, though, it is like a tamed gothic style.
Quote:
Originally posted by ATF
I loved your selection this round as a HUGE fan of 2NE1 the idea of their fashion sense being rebellious was really interesting to me. The video you chose was spot on for their insane styles and honestly any video of theirs would've done well. Good job
8/10
On the fence, should have chose a song your artist actually sings, but the paragraph explaining makes up for it. You had it easy this round.
Quote:
Originally posted by KT&T
It appears as if she just covered John Lennon’s song and his footsteps. Wishing for peace isn’t really rebellion in my book because many people have done it and it is actually the norm. Many artists have done charity songs like this, for example, “Just Stand Up” by various artists to help fight cancer, or “Everybody Hurts” by various artists helping Haiti. And I am sure she isn’t the only artist in continental North America who is for The Amnesty International Campaign to Save Darfur. I think Avril has better songs for this round.
Quote:
Originally posted by ATF
Avril is a perfect example of rebellion especially during her few first eras her punk attitude and look really seperated her from the pop scene. Your essay was a tad underwhelming, I kinda expected a little more as to why she was rebellious and I couldn't really see it, even with the video I didn't feel it really fit this challenge.
5/10
Total BS, but you packaged it so well I believed you. While you had NOTHING to go off really, I think you really did a good job with what you had.
Quote:
Originally posted by KT&T
Your artist choice makes it nearly impossible to complete this task. I do agree that she doesn’t fit the true county genre completely because of her pop style too. But honestly, she wasn’t born a country girl who was raised in Wyomissing, Pa. She did not rebel truly against country style music, it just happened that way that she had pop genre following from the large fan base composed of many teenagers, especially young girls. I think your choice of song is not commendable because she have done similar and better songs.
Quote:
Originally posted by ATF
everyone knows I despise Taylor Swift and your essay to me was so well thought out I have to commend you on the genius of it all. The rebellion of her musical genre is EXACTLY what I felt the challenge represented when it comes to Swift. Hands down the best this round
10/10
It was good, but I feel like you could have really added some OOMPH into it. But you did a good job, I guess.
Quote:
Originally posted by KT&T
P!nk rebellious nature in every sense of what she does really helps you doing this task. I like your explanation because you covered the important steps she took in her music career. The song choice you chose was great, though almost any of P!nk songs could work. Sometimes though her rebellious nature is overdone that I feel her new songs are just repeats of her past songs
Quote:
Originally posted by ATF
I really enjoyed your essay. It was somewhat short, sweet, and right to the point and providing enough details about P!nk's rebellion against her label and it's clear it shows throughout every record she does! Good job this round
8/10