I hate these "who started.." debates on ATRL. Theyre always a silly mess that throw up ridiculous answers. Too many kids here who can't see past a certain(recent) point. Its like the 50s, 60s, 70s, 80s and even 90s never happened.
You wish
P!nk had a WW smash i.e Get The Party Started in 2001. AND it was an actual dance song. She did pop-rock with M!ssundaztood in 2001
Sorry but once she started working with Luke, her songs sounded like SUBG knockoffs. I stan for P!nk too but its true. So What, u + ur hand, Leave me Alone, etc.
Sorry but once she started working with Luke, her songs sounded like SUBG knockoffs. I stan for P!nk too but its true. So What, u + ur hand, Leave me Alone, etc.
Most Kelly songs have a simple formula: short, simple verses...HARD HITTING chorus, Reach-for-the-sky-Bridge...Viola.
Each and Every song of p!nk's is VERY different from each other.
The only p!nk songs Dr.Luke has worked on are:
Who Knew
Cuz I Can
U + Ur Hand
Out of those, only U + Ur Hand is somewhat comparable to Since U Been Gone, but still, the two songs are very different.
Though the debate anyway is who brought back pop-rock / dance-pop music and p!nk's M!ssundaztood came 3 years before Breakaway so
Most Kelly songs have a simple formula: short, simple verses...HARD HITTING chorus, Reach-for-the-sky-Bridge...Viola.
Each and Every song of p!nk's is VERY different from each other.
The only p!nk songs Dr.Luke has worked on are:
Who Knew
Cuz I Can
U + Ur Hand
Out of those, only U + Ur Hand is somewhat comparable to Since U Been Gone, but still, the two songs are very different.
Though the debate anyway is who brought back pop-rock / dance-pop music and p!nk's M!ssundaztood came 3 years before Breakaway so
Hun, So What, u and ur hand, and It's All Your Fault are all SUBG knockoffs. P!nk probably wouldn't have even worked with Max and Luke if it wasn't for Kelly. Bye.
Hun, So What, u and ur hand, and It's All Your Fault are all SUBG knockoffs. P!nk probably wouldn't have even worked with Max and Luke if it wasn't for Kelly. Bye.
U+Ur Hand and So What are both S U P E R I O R to SUBG.
And please listen to It's All Your Fault again.
P!nk has always worked with the best producers. Ever since her debut; Babyface, tricky stewart, Linda Perry etc etc etc
And SUBG was NOT the first song Dr.Luke produced/wrote.
As far as Max Martin is concerned, he had already produced massive hits for Britney, Backstreet Boys, Celine Dion, N'Sync, Bon Jovi, 5ive, Robyn, Bryan Adams etc... before Kelly even auditioned for AI.
P!nk doesn't need Max Martin/Dr.Luke for huts tbh. She had massive smashes before Dr. Luke
was even known and will continue to make amazing music without him.
Oh and i almost forgot, GET THE PARTY STARTED 2001 (AN ACTUAL DANCE
U+Ur Hand and So What are both S U P E R I O R to SUBG.
And please listen to It's All Your Fault again.
P!nk has always worked with the best producers. Ever since her debut; Babyface, tricky stewart, Linda Perry etc etc etc
And SUBG was NOT the first song Dr.Luke produced/wrote.
As far as Max Martin is concerned, he had already produced massive hits for Britney, Backstreet Boys, Celine Dion, N'Sync, Bon Jovi, 5ive, Robyn, Bryan Adams etc... before Kelly even auditioned for AI.
P!nk doesn't need Max Martin/Dr.Luke for huts tbh. She had massive smashes before Dr. Luke
was even known and will continue to make amazing music without him.
Oh and i almost forgot, GET THE PARTY STARTED 2001 (AN ACTUAL DANCE
SONG)
What kinda delusions? Where are U + Ur Hand and So What's Grammys? Do they even still get the type of radio play that SUBG gets?
At the end of the day SUBG made the world see Max/Luke as great producers on pop/rock songs. Without it, P!nk most likely probably would not have worked with ether of them and created her many songs that are inferior to SUBG. I love both P!nk in Kelly and its clear that they take inspirations from eachother, whether P!nk likes to admit it or not. Deal with it.
What kinda delusions? Where are U + Ur Hand and So What's Grammys? Do they even still get the type of radio play that SUBG gets?
At the end of the day SUBG made the world see Max/Luke as great producers on pop/rock songs. Without it, P!nk most likely probably would not have worked with ether of them and created her many songs that are inferior to SUBG. I love both P!nk in Kelly and its clear that they take inspirations from eachother, whether P!nk likes to admit it or not. Deal with it.
P!nk is original. Kelly is not.
And really Grammys
Are you going to use the 'grammy' card to determine the quality of a song? the same grammys in which P!nk and Kelly lost to the Black Eyed Peas?
Max Martin was already VERY famous as i mentioned before. ...Baby One More Time came way before SUBG
And yes, Kelly's SUBG kind of put Dr. Luke on the map BUT p!nk only worked on 3 songs with him. 2 of which are superior to SUBG and sound nothing like it.
And p!nks breakout hits have come from the M!ssundaztood era in 2001. No Kelly. No Luke. No Martin.
And Kelly is often dubbed as 'p!nk rip-off' but p!nk being the generous that she is, denied that. (just to be nice)