[KK_Lover]

Rihanna Lana Del Rey Adele

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by caerbayn

I wanna know who exactly came up with the idea that gaga has no falsetto..on the basis that they've never heard her use it. Like REALLY?

Guess they've never heard the opening to Governement Hooker.

Not that I would be putting Gaga in any vocal trinity. She's good and knows how to use what she has, but her natural instrument isn't on par with what others have.

[Mimie]

Reason why Rihanna will never be a part of no vocal trinity:



I know she was only 15, but she hasn't improved much.

[BoyOnBoy Wonder]

Beyoncé and Adele. There is no "vocal trinity," but if you HAD to have a third, I guess Florence would work.

[Fiendfire]

Originally posted by MiMiLamb

Reason why Rihanna will never be a part of no vocal trinity:



I know she was only 15, but she hasn't improved much.

That has her highest note in as well.

[Guy]

Originally posted by Glam

I think I know you! We used to be lovers

Also I LOVE Carrie Underwood but I don't see why she's considered part of the trinity

There isn't really anyone as strong as the top two (or at least I couldn't think of any at that moment), so I chose Carrie. She's better rounded than others discussed in this topic.

[Mimie]

Christina

-Range (also has whistle register)
-Power
-Good Head Voice

Beyonce

-Clear lower register
-Good Head Voice
-Control

Kelly Clarkson

-Power Belter
-Range

Carrie Underwood

-Overall great singer, just isn't the best at anything

Adele

-Clear low notes
-Ample power in mid-belting range

Mariah

-Range, Range, Range !!
-Best Whistler
-Control
-Tone
-Lower Register
-Clarity
-Great Mid-Belter
-Amazing upper-belter

GaGa, Jennifer Hudson, and Leona Lewis are out of the running.

Would anyone like to add?

[lestat111]

beyonce, xtina and some of them-brandy, adele, kelly c.
and mariah is better then all of them.


in atrl world that would be britney, gaga and victoria beckham.

[Cap10Planet]

Does it have to be only pop girls? I ask because I canname a few non-pop girls who would wipe most of these girls out of the water in several different areas.

[Mimie]

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

Does it have to be only pop girls? I ask because I could name a few non-pop girls who would wipe most of these girls out of the water in several different areas.

Hmm, tell me who they are and we'll see.

[Fiendfire]

You know damn well Beyonce has more than that...
Beyonce:
Chest belts are resonant and belted with great technique throughout
Can sing while Dancing which mean she has excellent breath control
She has the best crecendos and best transitions out of all of them
Uses her complex melismas to a tea
They're just a few of the many excellent things about Beyonce's singing.

[DAKA]

Originally posted by Kade

Adele, Beyonce and GaGa

.

[Mimie]

Originally posted by Fiendfire

You know damn well Beyonce has more than that...
Beyonce:
Chest belts are resonant and belted with great technique throughout
Can sing while Dancing which mean she has excellent breath control
She has the best crecendos and best transitions out of all of them
Uses her complex melismas to a tea
They're just a few of the many excellent things about Beyonce's singing.

Her chest belts are weak compared to these other gurls.

I said control.

No she doesn't.

Her melismas are basic.

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

Does it have to be only pop girls? I ask because I canname a few non-pop girls who would wipe most of these girls out of the water in several different areas.

Well I guess it's kinda like the situation in the 90s with Whitney/Mariah/Celine. There are always other types of talented vocalists who may not be as prominent on the radar, but those were the ones people would look to because their music had mass exposure.

[ElectricFrancis]

Katy , Britney and Ke$ha

[Mimie]

Originally posted by MrPeanut

Well I guess it's kinda like the situation in the 90s with Whitney/Mariah/Celine. There are always other types of talented vocalists who may not be as prominent on the radar, but those were the ones people would look to because their music had mass exposure.

Were there any gurls that could sing better than Mariah/Whitney/Celine though?

[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by MiMiLamb

Hmm, tell me who they are and we'll see.

Ledisi
Melanie Fiona
Tamia
Brandy
Amy Lee
Jill Scott
Fantasia
Miranda Lambert
Martina McBride

But I guess they aren't popular enough regardless of their vocal ability. Shame.

[Chunk]

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

Ledisi
Melanie Fiona
Tamia
Brandy
Amy Lee
Jill Scott
Fantasia
Miranda Lambert
Martina McBride

But I guess they aren't popular enough regardless of their vocal ability. Shame.

I like you so much more now.

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by MiMiLamb

Were there any gurls that could sing better than Mariah/Whitney/Celine though?

Probably not when it comes to range/belting power, but there are other ways to be vocally talented.

[Mimie]

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

Ledisi
Melanie Fiona
Tamia
Brandy
Amy Lee
Jill Scott
Fantasia
Miranda Lambert
Martina McBride

But I guess they aren't popular enough regardless of their vocal ability. Shame.

I've heard of most of them. You need to tell me why they deserve to be in the trinity though, only thing most of these gurls can do is belt high. (from what I know about them)