[Chunk]

Originally posted by Hooligan

Christina has had a whopping career and no one is devaluing that, yet when you look at Christina's sales compared to Pink's, you have to see the difference. The majority of Xtina's 43M came from her 17M debut. Her sales have been on the decline ever since then. Pink, however, have had her sales stabilize.

I didn't deny that. For me, Christina has the best career. That is my personal opinion. And I wouldn't have to complain, if there weren't people who question everything she has accomplished and say she's a flop, when she clearly isn't.

[fanoftalent]

Another good way to compare is to see how their GHs have done, as they both released them.

Did Xtina's GHs even crack 1 million worldwide?

P!nk's GHs is smashing and still on top of the charts with 1.5 million+ copies already sold, and its not like she's doing much promo.

[RedDlicious]

Originally posted by fanoftalent

Another good way to compare is to see how their GHs have done, as they both released them.

Did Xtina's GHs even crack 1 million worldwide?

P!nk's GHs is smashing and still on top of the charts with 1.5 million+ copies already sold, and its not like she's doing much promo.

All that shows for me is that less people had Pink's albums so they needed to buy the GH, but most of Xtina's fans already had all of the songs. Not a good way to compare imo

[D/X]

P!nk. She hasn't the last career on Earth that any girl would want, but she knew how to survive in the industry.

[fanoftalent]

Originally posted by RedDlicious

All that shows for me is that less people had Pink's albums so they needed to buy the GH, but most of Xtina's fans already had all of the songs. Not a good way to compare imo

their overall album sales are about the same so thats a moot point.

All it shows is that Pink has had a bigger and more memorable catalog of hits. Of course everything is known in comparison. Xtina has had her fair share of hits past decade, but Pink was much more consistent in delivering iconic hit songs throughout the whole decade.

[layla]

P!nk, hands down.

[Orsay]

P!nk has never been as big as Xtina.

[Stepfon]

Originally posted by Nadia

bitch please.

Christina sold more albums
Has more #1 singles
Has a better voice
Has more grammys
An album that is 8x platinum

Christina, easily

Bitch that is EXACTLY why her fans shouldn't be crying "foul" over her not winning this damn poll. They are making it seem like (once again) people are out to get Christina and not give her props as an artist when that is NOT the case at all.

[Mr. Duff]

Pink! She's the only relevant girl. Christina could make a big comeback with her next album though.

[KKCuteCat]

Pink. She's outselling Xtina and Xtina is an icon of a copy cat

[Disturbia]

Originally posted by BornThisWay

P!nk has never been as big as Xtina.

P!nk released a greatest hits album on November 12, 2010 (in the end of the year) and made it the best selling album of the year in Australia. Could Christina ever do it ?

Yes, i agree that Xtina was more successful than P!nk in 2000 but come on, we live in 2011 and P!nk is about to top billboard hot 100 with her new single soon

[Disturbia]

P!nk - 129 votes
Xtina - 44 votes

People on ATRL know the true tea

[Angelo]

P!nk because she is still on the D list nowadays
While others are on the Z LIST!

[KKCuteCat]

[fanoftalent]

Originally posted by Angelo

P!nk because she is still on the D list nowadays
While others are on the Z LIST!

is there even a letter for the list Avril is on?

[Chunk]

Originally posted by KKCuteCat

Pink. She's outselling Xtina and Xtina is an icon of a copy cat

Enjoy your warning point.

[KKCuteCat]

a big A .

Angelo is the best damn hater of Avril

[KKCuteCat]

Originally posted by xChunk

Enjoy your warning point.

Oh yeah, i knew it when i posted and i won't regret

[Ollie]

Damn I thought this was the one I preferred (Christina), but career wise now I know, P!nk >>>>>>>>>>>>

[tcatron565]

The one who is still producing #1 hits a decade into her career.

Christina is more iconic, but P!nk is definitely the most successful.