Christina's voice is more mesmerizing. Her gift is inborn, not just a result of training like Beyonce's. In my country it's called "golden voice." You won't hear that voice from anyone else and no one can mimic it. Just like Andreita said, you can learn techniques, you can improve on delivery and vocal performance, but you can never possess such an amazing and unique tone like Christina's.
Christina's voice is more mesmerizing. Her gift is inborn, not just a result of training like Beyonce's. In my country it's called "golden voice." You won't hear that voice from anyone else and no one can mimic it. Just like Andreita said, you can learn techniques, you can improve on delivery and vocal performance, but you can never possess such an amazing and unique tone like Christina's.
Maybe you're right...I don't agree totally but to each is own.
But the question was the best Vocalist. Which means who can use her voice BETTER. And on that plan Beyoncé wins Hands down.
I don't think Xtina was ever as good as Beyonce in terms of power or vocal stamina, even at her "peak." Listen ***** on Xtina's best ballads IMO, and I love some of Xtina's slow stuff (The Voice Within, Beautiful, etc.)...
HOWEVER, Xtina's voice has wayyyy more soul and emotion than Beyonce's. (At Last is proof)
You actually mean this
is better than this?
Those two videos highlights every reason why Beyoncé's much better vocalist than Xtina: better voice control, better interpretation of the song, better technique, better musicality, better ear, and don't get it twisted more soul and emotion (it's not forced!!) ALL infavour of Beyoncé!
I can't believe it. People have no ear in this thread!!
Ew, I think Christina's version of At Last is absolutely pretentious and disgusting. That "big" note at the end simply shows that she can't support a note w/ vibrato (unlike Bey), which is why she has to do the acrobatics.
Ew, I think Christina's version of At Last is absolutely pretentious and disgusting. That "big" note at the end simply shows that she can't support a note w/ vibrato (unlike Bey), which is why she has to do the acrobatics.
Yes Gurl Xtina could never hit the note Beyoncé hit at the very end. It's maybe the most impressive note Beyoncé hit, it's so sharp, accurate. It's like an instrument. She's BADD!!
Ew, I think Christina's version of At Last is absolutely pretentious and disgusting. That "big" note at the end simply shows that she can't support a note w/ vibrato (unlike Bey), which is why she has to do the acrobatics.
Please vocal knowledge is not welcome in this thread!
Both are very skilled singers, but everybody knows that Christina is a better vocalist. Her vocal runs and falsettos are out of this world and she is capable of singing in the whistle register, while Beyonce can't. She is a very average singer and there are thousands of people who can sing like her with enough training.
Beyonce's rendition of A Song for You:
Christina's rendition of A Song for You: (And it's only a rehearsal)
And for all those who say Chrissy can't control her voice. That's just a lame excuse, because:
Bey's runs are far more skilful and controlled than Christina's. Christina recycling the same midrange riffs from performance to performance is not impressive.
Christina's falsetto is usually flat and weak. I'll take Bey's resonant head voice any day.
Neither have used whistle voice live. And even if they had, it's pretty much a gimmick unless you have a Mariah/Minnie Riperton level of skill with it. A lot of people who can't sing worth a damn can squeak out whistle notes.