Mariah is definetely a good singer, but her music is very formulaic and follows the exact same themes and sound. She's kinda like Taylor Swift. The reason why she was so successful is because all her songs sound the same, people thought they were listening to the same song over and over again on the radio.
Plus, Madonna didn't have to sleep with/marry the head of her record company in order to be successful. And she doesn't hire her boyfriends to "throw shade" at her peers either.
Mariah is definetely a good singer, but her music is very formulaic and follows the exact same themes and sound. She's kinda like Taylor Swift. The reason why she was so successful is because all her songs sound the same, people thought they were listening to the same song over and over again on the radio.
Plus, Madonna didn't have to sleep with/marry the head of her record company in order to be successful. And she doesn't hire her boyfriends to "throw shade" at her peers either.
Well according to critics Madonna's writing,production and music is better.Not to mention performing and dancing.And Madonna's IQ is 140 and she is a genius but whatever makes him sleep at night
Madonna can literally not hold a note and her writing is below average. Either way Mariah has never released an album as tragic as Madonna's last 3 so she wins!
Mariah is definetely a good singer, but her music is very formulaic and follows the exact same themes and sound. She's kinda like Taylor Swift. The reason why she was so successful is because all her songs sound the same, people thought they were listening to the same song over and over again on the radio.
Plus, Madonna didn't have to sleep with/marry the head of her record company in order to be successful. And she doesn't hire her boyfriends to "throw shade" at her peers either.
lol at ppl citing IQ numbers.. how low can ppl stoop...
fact is: Madonna fans will say anything, do anything to deny Mariah's impact. why should we even argue with them? nobody should argue with ppl who are experiencing delusions of such extremes.
I'm not here for these cheap digs. Especially at Mariahs supposed lack of 'Experimentation"
Now, you'd be laughed at for trying to argue Madonna being a better artist than let's say Marvin Gaye, James Brown, Ray Charles and Sly & the Family Stone; who have all done only R&B/Funk.
So stop using that innacurate statement as a critique.
Ofc she is. She all those thinks to make up for her weak vocals. Too bad Mairah is extremely influential, creative and experimental musically with her VOCALS that she was BORN with.
Mariah Carey's musicality, vocal ability, songwriting, song producing, 5 Octave vocal range >> Madonna's!
You can get credit due to composing and that's how Madonna and Mirwais got their credits.And Madonna has wrote and composed 5 song by herself on her debut album.That's more than Mariah did in her whole career
lol at ppl citing IQ numbers.. how low can ppl stoop...
fact is: Madonna fans will say anything, do anything to deny Mariah's impact. why should we even argue with them? nobody should argue with ppl who are experiencing delusions of such extremes.
i know mariahs impact...but madonna's obviously bigger
You can get credit due to composing and that's how Madonna and Mirwais got their credits.And Madonna has wrote and composed 5 song by herself on her debut album.That's more than Mariah did in her whole career
Unlike Madonna, Mariah actually writes all of her songs, NOT JUST "composing"
All of her big hits in the 90s that Walter Afanasieff is credited as well is because he was composing the music. Proof:
It's so easy clocking all of you when I am right hahaha