She embodies pure raw and vocal talent. She has one of the best instruments we have heard in the last few decades, so its actually a very solid answer. This thread is about vocal talent, not just skill or technical singing.
Raw is right. She never developed and took care of her instrument, which is why it's in the condition that it's in now.
She has a fully connected range from bottom to top, 4 octaves, F2-F6.
She has incredible breath support, sustaining passages in every area of her voice regardless of the choreo.
She carries far more resonance than Kelly in a majority of areas, Kelly only wins in passages from E5-A5, and even then Beyoncé could beat her on F5's.
She has FAR more agility than Kelly, Kelly's standard is her 5 note riff, while the longest I've heard her go is about 12 notes. Beyoncé could double that with twice the speed, and has also mastered roulades.
She has far more dynamic control, demonstrating this control in a wide variety of songs both between songs and in them. She's mastered crescendos and decrescendos and everything related to those two techniques.
She has far more control over her registers, being able to transition from head voice to chest voice and back to head voice with ease. She can start from head voice and crescendo into chest voice, which is a technique singers try for YEARS to master.
She has a far fuller head voice, that demonstrates operatic resonance. Kelly's head voice thins out above A5, and she lacks the accuracy Beyoncé does.
She also has a far better sense of intonation, she rarely falls off of her scales, and has mastered key changes IN songs that go up by SEMI-TONES. Kelly has never demonstrated more than ONE key change in a song, if even one.
But yes, Kelly can belt higher and has an F#6 under her belt, and sang live at the inauguration. There's no contest!
is that all? So you want me to come back with everything Kelly can do? Nah opinion is an opinion One is the better vocalist one is the better performer, one can sing one genre the other adapts to any genre
, one doesn't always sing live one does end of story. I sing myself not going to use all those fancy words to try and prove my point . Put them on stage together and it would be embarrassing for Beyonce
She embodies pure raw and vocal talent. She has one of the best instruments we have heard in the last few decades, so its actually a very solid answer and I definitely can see why she's being named. This thread is about vocal talent, not just skill or technical singing.
Christina's voice is among the most beautiful I've ever heard; however, having a beautiful voice isn't talent, it's happenstance.
is that all? So you want me to come back with everything Kelly can do? Nah opinion is an opinion One is the better vocalist one is the better performer, one can sing one genre the other adapts to any genre
, one doesn't always sing live one does end of story. I sing myself not going to use all those fancy words to try and prove my point . Put them on stage together and it would be embarrassing for Beyonce
is that all? So you want me to come back with everything Kelly can do? Nah opinion is an opinion One is the better vocalist one is the better performer, one can sing one genre the other adapts to any genre
, one doesn't always sing live one does end of story. I sing myself not going to use all those fancy words to try and prove my point . Put them on stage together and it would be embarrassing for Beyonce
Please, do come back with everything Kelly can do better than Beyoncé, since you have been making such articulate arguments in this thread, I'd love to hear it!
This is such a sad response that illustrates everything wrong with ATRL. If only this site could maintain decent conversations not hellbent on blind stanning.
Chanted Moore isn't part of Beyonce's generation. All she has going for her is the whistle register. Other than that, her bottom register is weak.
Ummm...no.
Chante regularly dips as low as Eb3 in live performances and she's a coloratura soprano. In I'm What You Need alone her range spans from C3 to A6 - and she can sing the entire song live, low notes, runs, whistles and all. HER agility runs throughout her range from top to bottom as does her control and finesse.
Chante is MUCH MUCH MORE than whistle. She has a style, class and restraint that has been rare in R&B for decades.
I'm perched..
Here to uproot and dismantle any lies or biased filled fallacies..
I'm an expert at this woman's voice.. Been studying her growth and technical prowess over the past 10 years
Come at me, bro!!
She is..
Any arguments for Kelly? Xtina? And Gags before I get started??
Please, do come back with everything Kelly can do better than Beyoncé, since you have been making such articulate arguments in this thread, I'd love to hear yours!
This is such a sad response that illustrates everything wrong with ATRL. If only this site could maintain decent conversations not hellbent on blind stanning.
Girl if Beyonce was an actual threat to Kelly I would write a book on here with everything she can do. It does not bother me what you think you know Kelly is praised for her vocals all the time Beyonce is not. Beyoncé had to lip at the inauguration because she was singing at the same event as a true vocalist. Blind stanning? Hahahaha go back to stanning for Demi sis
Christina's voice is among the most beautiful I've ever heard; however, having a beautiful voice isn't talent, it's happenstance.
Well, she hasn't got the best technique as stated earlier in this thread, but I would rather call it a stretch to not think of Christina Aguilera as vocally talented.
Girl if Beyonce was an actual threat to Kelly I would write a book on here with everything she can do. It does not bother me what you think you know Kelly is praised for her vocals all the time Beyonce ia not. Beyoncé had to lip at the inauguration because ahe was singing at the same event as a true vocalist. Blind stanning? Hahahaha go back to stanning for Demi sis
Praise does not equal vocal prowess. Christina gets more praise than Kelly but you wouldn't consider Christina a better vocalist, no? Regardless of what Beyoncé has lipped, she has proven that she can sing it live with technical proficiency regardless.
It does not bother me that you choose to live in ignorance as opposed to facing the facts that Beyoncé is a better vocalist, and instead choose to blindly stan Kelly - whom I love and respect - and advance poorly laid out arguments. But keep on trying sis!
although I would state that Brandy's musicianship rivals and would even surpass Beyonce's if it weren't for Bey's insane development of virtually every aspect of the voice..coupled with that versatility ...her technical Arsenal rivals even the greats..
By far, Beyoncé is the greatest technically trained vocalist of our time, no other artists comes close to what she can do, in her breathing techniques and in her runs.
What other artist you know out here using Mezzo Soprano ability for BACKING vocals? x
I knew Beyoncé was the one when she snatched Celine's wig.
But personally my favourite performance from her as a vocalist has to be ANYTHING she did on The Beyoncé Experience, no other R&B artist has given a vocal performance so clean from her time.
Praise does not equal vocal prowess. Christina gets more praise than Kelly but you wouldn't consider Christina a better vocalist, no? Regardless of what Beyoncé has lipped, she has proven that she can sing it live with technical proficiency regardless.
It does not bother me that you choose to live in ignorance as opposed to facing the facts that Beyoncé is a better vocalist, and instead choose to blindly stan Kelly - whom I love and respect - and advance poorly laid out arguments. But keep on trying sis!
Kelly gets more praise then Christina boo my Kelly praise videos alone prove that. Plus I still got two more coming. Keep on living in denial sis and LOL at that NA performance
Girl if Beyonce was an actual threat to Kelly I would write a book on here with everything she can do. It does not bother me what you think you know Kelly is praised for her vocals all the time Beyonce is not. Beyoncé had to lip at the inauguration because she was singing at the same event as a true vocalist. Blind stanning? Hahahaha go back to stanning for Demi sis
Actually try to refute his points instead of deflecting with your subjective banter..
Or should I just start posting receipts of vocal feats exhibited by Beyoncé that surpasses the mild proficiency in the upper chest register F#5-A5 ..which is about 4 notes..
Something as subtle and delicate as transitioning from a piano head note to fortissimo chest not all in on breath without break/connection would not even be picked up by a casual listener.. But it's one of the most difficult forms of dynamic control Ever along with and impeccable mix!! Only Whitney and Mariah has shown this mastery in mainstream pop!
Kelly gets more praise then Christina boo my Kelly praise videos alone prove that. Plus I still got two more coming. Keep on living in denial sis and LOL at that NA performance
He clearly meant the media, and general public not a random YouTube video's comments. Beyonce, and Kelly Clarkson have never topped X on a Best Singers list ever for a reason. They, like the world, know that CA >>>>>>>>>> Bee, and KC.
Actually try to refute his points instead of deflecting with your subjective banter..
Or should I just start posting receipts of vocal feats exhibited by Beyoncé that surpasses the mild proficiency in the upper chest register F#5-A5 ..which is about 4 notes..
Something as subtle and delicate as transitioning from a piano head note to fortissimo chest not all in on breath without break/connection would not even be picked up by a casual listener.. But it's one of the most difficult forms of dynamic control Ever along with and impeccable mix!! Only Whitney and Mariah has shown this mastery in mainstream pop!
He clearly meant the media, and general public not a random YouTube video's comments. Beyonce, and Kelly Clarkson have never topped X on a Best Singers list ever for a reason. They, like the world, know that CA >>>>>>>>>> Bee, and KC.
I did mean the media. Not co-signing anything else on the post as fact, but X certainly gains more media attention and praise (for better or worse) for her vocal... performances than Kelly.
He clearly meant the media, and general public not a random YouTube video's comments. Beyonce, and Kelly Clarkson have never topped X on a Best Singers list ever for a reason. They, like the world, know that CA >>>>>>>>>> Bee, and KC.
Ummmm to bad I meant the media and the videos I was talking about was from celebrities/other singers not random youtube comments boo