Member Since: 1/28/2008
Posts: 34,491
|
The Judges Had Spoken
Quote:
Originally posted by SIMon1120
Same rank earlier L -> N -> A
1-10 is the rate among these 3 songs only, not compared to the other songs earlier. These 3 scores would be scaled down much lower if they were to compare with those.
L: 9/10. Emblem3. MLD deserves to stay because he delivered the right ballad that has a real message regarding the fact that he misunderstood the round criteria and he still managed to send in something.
--- Sad song, feel the pain in the message that it delivered: being together and then torn apart by attending different collages. It reveals an emotional side of Emblem3 that makes us want to run to their side.
N: 7/10. Serena Ryder. I appreciate Kamil for sending a very risky entry, but she does know what is a true talent.
--- The singer's distinct talents: her voice that captures the listeners, and the rare quality of that voice unlike factory-produced popsters who currently dominate pop music charts, and lastly she writes wisely aged songs. Her vocal characteristic is amazing, a tremolo that wrings pain from a lyric of such painful anger that it seems to make the beautiful melody seem almost ironic.
A: 5/10. Eskimo Joe. Sorry Marnie, but it's the weakest among the 3, the song itself does not attract me from the beginning until the end, i could not approach a message from it, and there's nothing about this artist that appeals to me. A good song but not the best entry to defeat all the other ones.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by ♥jONE731♥
Single A --- > This song is simple yet it makes me wanna repeat the play button... (9.5)
Single L --- > This is the song i love from this set, i evenly ranked it as my 1st and yet it still go down to the bottom 3. Rate (10)
Single N --- > I like this song, it's quite powerful and lovable (7.0)
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Miles Caulfield
MLD: 5
Kamil: 8
Marnie: 6
MLD: The song was a bit generic for me. I realize you thought you had limited options, but even so I'm sure you could have chosen better.
Kamil: Loved the song. It had great lyrics and an overall good sound. The instrumentals were a bit off for me but otherwise good.
Marnie: I just was not feeling this one. Sorry.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by e437
Kamil24 - 9/10
Gosh, why did this song make the Bottom . And the last spot too . In my opinion, it's a great indie bop and the singer has some good vocals, so definitely it is an underrated song. It's my fave out of the three
Marnie - 6/10
Ok, so I gave this song a 6 because it shines a bit over Ryan's song, but it's not the best song ever :/. I hope to see more from you
MLD - 5/10
Ryan sis . I am sincerely sorry for doing this to you, but I don't really like that song. Their voice is annoying and you know, it's the typical sound of a boring boy band.
In b4 you drag my fave tho
|
Total Scores From The Judges
Kamil24 --- > Qwerty
Serena Ryder - Weak In The Knees = 31 Pts
MusicLoverDude --- > R Sully
Emblem3 - 3000 miles = 29 Pts
Marnie --- > Marnstar <3
Eskimo Joe - London Bombs = 25.5 Pts
The
1st
Contender
Vanish
In
the
Game
Is
Marnie --- > Marnstar <3
Eskimo Joe - London Bombs = 25.5 Pts
Tnx For Playing
|
|
|