[BIAATCH]

Firework but both of them suck

[notmyselftonight]

Firework.

[Robert]

Firework

[LP54]

Originally posted by LP54

Also

Born This Way
Released: February 11, 2011
#47 Lithuania
#63 Argentina
#74 Romania
#100 Japan
#122 New Zealand
#138 Costa Rica
#150 Luxembourg
#150 Peru
#155 Colombia
#173 Brazil
#183 Chile
#186 Philippines
#202 Finland
#203 Portugal
#212 Greece
#219 Hungary
#242 Bulgaria
#261 Ireland
#264 Singapore
#304 Dominican Republic
#314 Hong Kong
#368 Guatemala
#387 Estonia
#400 Panama

Vs.

Firework
Released: October 26, 2010
#17 Philippines
#23 Singapore
#29 Argentina
#52 Brazil
#52 Paraguay
#66 Malta
#71 Peru
#80 Mexico
#82 Venezuela
#86 Malaysia
#87 Norway
#88 Colombia
#95 Costa Rica
#109 Dominican Republic
#112 Honduras
#124 Italy
#127 Panama
#132 Ecuador
#137 Ecuador
#141 New Zealand
#146 Australia
#150 Venezuela
#156 Hong Kong
#158 Chile
#159 France
#159 Honduras
#160 Latvia
#180 Guatemala
#185 Chile
#190 Peru
#205 Czech Republic
#209 Switzerland
#210 Canada
#219 Taiwan
#224 Sweden
#238 United States
#244 Japan
#257 United Kingdom
#293 Spain
#315 Greece
#324 Thailand
#331 Bolivia

Winner: Firework

I forgot to metion the youtube views.

Born This Way: 99,104,015
Firework: 319,549,990

[Katy V.!]

Which will have the longer standing impact/known as an "Anthem"

Firework 71 52.21%
Born This Way 65 47.79%

I mean, Firework winning in a forum infested by Monsters shows how clear it is.

[swissman]

Originally posted by LP54

I forgot to metion the youtube views.

Born This Way: 99,104,015
Firework: 319,549,990

So is On The Floor a bigger anthem than both with 594,238,343 views? This isn't a discussion about which is the bigger hit.

[futurelove92]

Firework>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

[Chemist]

Originally posted by swissman

So is On The Floor a bigger anthem than both with 594,238,343 views? This isn't a discussion about which is the bigger hit.

BIGGER anthem means which is the one that most people refer as anthem. We cannot make an anthem chart, so the only thing we have are singles charts

[KRL]

Originally posted by swissman

So is On The Floor a bigger anthem than both with 594,238,343 views? This isn't a discussion about which is the bigger hit.

Exactly.. firework is just another generic pop song that's made for radio stations and elevators worldwide.. so obviously it has more views, sales and airplay.. but the one that people remember more is born this way.

[LP54]

Originally posted by KRL

Exactly.. firework is just another generic pop song that's made for radio stations and elevators worldwide.. so obviously it has more views, sales and airplay.. but the one that people remember more is born this way.

[Liberdade mi amor]

Originally posted by KRL

Exactly.. firework is just another generic pop song that's made for radio stations and elevators worldwide.. so obviously it has more views, sales and airplay.. but the one that people remember more is born this way.

Theys till havent given us any legit facts about sales records... But they keep saying it is a huge seller.

[cherrychapstick]

Firework, easily.

[ChandlerBing]

Originally posted by Liberdade mi amor

Theys till havent given us any legit facts about sales records... But they keep saying it is a huge seller.

Firework sold 5,85 million in the US only as of yesterday. I am not sure BTW even cracked 4m mark, it stayed in the top10 for 18 weeks, it had major longetivity and impact, the video means something also. There is no competition here, Firework wins and it's not even close.

[Liberdade mi amor]

Originally posted by ChandlerBing

Firework sold 5,85 million in the US only as of yesterday. I am not sure BTW even cracked 4m mark, it stayed in the top10 for 18 weeks, it had major longetivity and impact, the video means something also. There is no competition here, Firework wins and it's not even close.

Born This Way slays Firework in terms of WW impact [sales+awards] , even in the US Vmas it won over Firework two times and lost 0 to it.

[phreshprince]

Fireworks is played more like at the Olympics

[swissman]

But wait guys.


What do sales have to do with this? Someone needs to define what an anthem is and then judge these two based on that criteria.

Why is it on ATRL that when discussing something sales always come up? Its taking the easy way out of proving your point and a lot of times it not even relevant to the discussion. (Unless the discussion is sales)

[2AM]

Firework.
It sold more, is more known, stretches past just a certain demographic, more views, etc etc.

[Hoolikat]

Originally posted by Liberdade mi amor

Born This Way slays Firework in terms of WW impact [sales+awards] , even in the US Vmas it won over Firework two times and lost 0 to it.

This only means that Gaga's fanbase is bigger. We already know it.

[Liberdade mi amor]

Originally posted by Hoolikat

This only means that Gaga's fanbase is bigger. We already know it.

But you KatyKats claimed that impact = sales and awards.

Born This Way has more sales and more awards.

[LP54]

Originally posted by Liberdade mi amor

But you KatyKats claimed that impact = sales and awards.

Born This Way has more sales and more awards.

Born This Way does not have more sales worldwide or in the US. At the end of 2011, according to Media Traffic Born This Way sold a little over 6 million worldwide while Firework was closing on 8 million. And Firework is out selling BTW now worldwide see iTunes.

Originally posted by BeamMeUp

You've been misinformed. This is what happens when you just run with what Mother tells you.

Firework
#10 Philippines
#22 Argentina
#27 Singapore
#51 Peru
#52 Brazil
#68 Colombia
#80 Mexico
#80 Malaysia
#82 Venezuela
#91 Hong Kong
#92 Norway
#109 Dominican Republic
#112 Honduras
#115 Costa Rica
#126 Italy
#126 Panama
#127 Ecuador
#132 Ecuador
#135 Latvia
#139 France
#140 Chile
#149 Venezuela
#152 Australia
#155 Honduras
#168 Chile
#169 Peru
#180 Guatemala
#180 Sweden
#186 Switzerland
#193 Taiwan
#203 Czech Republic
#220 Canada
#231 United States
#249 Spain
#254 New Zealand
#257 Japan
#284 United Kingdom
#293 Thailand
#313 Greece
#331 Bolivia
#391 Slovakia

Born This Way
#42 Lithuania
#67 Argentina
#69 Romania
#97 Japan
#97 Luxembourg
#130 Peru
#140 Colombia
#159 Brazil
#159 Costa Rica
#165 Chile
#170 Portugal
#177 Philippines
#209 Greece
#214 Bulgaria
#217 Hungary
#241 Singapore
#251 Hong Kong
#291 Dominican Republic
#306 New Zealand
#354 Finland
#366 Guatemala
#372 Estonia
#386 Canada
#390 Australia
#394 Panama
#397 Spain