[Lee!!]

Originally posted by 2travis2005

• Chris – Best
• Gideon
• Elliot
• Ace
• Bucky
• Taylor
• Will
• Kevin
• David
• Chris – Worst

I guessing you meant to say Sway as the worst

[Travis10]

Originally posted by Lee!!

I guessing you meant to say Sway as the worst

*Smacks himself across the face and corrects*

[Mikal]

Originally posted by FranklinComesAlive

Um, surely that freakzaoid should be placed on the bottom just for the fact that he looks like he eats babies?

Nah, that's clearly Kellie's job

Carmen will chase her down for stealing Uncle Nigel's love and babies later

[Kworb]

Paris: 8.3
Ayla: 7.5
Melissa: 6.7
Lisa: 6.5
Brenna: 5.5
Mandisa: 5.5
Kinnik: 5.2
Katherine: 5.0
Kellie: 4.8
Heather: 4.3

Elliott: 8.1
Will: 8.0
Chris: 7.9
Gedeon: 7.8
Taylor: 7.5
Bucky: 6.7
Ace: 4.9
Kevin: 4.7
Sway: 4.5
David: 3.6

Top 20:

1. Paris: 17.3 (=)
2. Ayla: 15.0 (+4)
3. Lisa: 14.3 (+2)
4. Mandisa: 14.0 (-2)
5. Melissa: 13.7 (+2)
6. Kinnik: 13.2 (-3)
7. Katherine: 12.9 (-3)
8. Elliott: 12.6 (+5)
9. Taylor: 12.5 (+3)
10. Gedeon: 11.9 (+5)
11. Chris: 11.9 (+5)
12. Brenna: 11.8 (-3)
13. Kellie: 11.3 (-5)
14. Ace: 11.1 (-4)
15. Will: 10.0 (+4)
16. Heather: 9.3 (-5)
17. Sway: 8.8 (-3)
18. Bucky: 8.4 (+2)
19. Kevin: 8.2 (-2)
20. David: 5.8 (-2)

[dianasguy]

Brenna's gone!

[dianasguy]

Heather is also gone.

[GoldenBoy]

Yes! Perfect choices. They were the worst two performances.

[Kworb]

I'm pleased with those choices

[dianasguy]

David is gone. I hope kevin leaves.

[dianasguy]

Sway left

[Charmbracelet]

Mbs = message boards.

David!!

[Mikal]

Rank'em 24 - Week 2

01. Paris (NC)
*then a gap the size of the continential USA*
02. Kinnik (NC)
03. Melissa (+6)
04. Ayla (NC)
05. Mandisa (-2)
*jump over Russia, Canada, and China, then you'll find*
06. Chris (NC)
07. Lisa (-2)
08. Elliot (NC)
09. Bucky (+9)
10. Katherine (NC)
11. Gedion (NC)
12. Taylor (+1)
13. Will (-6)
*Light Years Away, hopefully in Hell soon*
14. Kevin (+1)
15. Kellie (-2)
16. Ace (-2)
17. Patrick
18. Becky
19. Stevie
20. David
21. Heather
22. Brenna
23. Bobby
24. "Sway"

[.:Froggert:.]

This has become such a predictable season.

Poor David.

I hope Paris, Bucky, Kevin, Gaedion are all next

[Travis10]

The choices were right-on this week. - (The Mariah Mishap, The Crooner, The Frankie J Wannabe, and "Brenna.")

But if I had it my way, and had the power to change the rules, I would've kicked out Kevin in Heather's place, because performance-wise, she was better than him.

I actually see a lot of ticken 12 year olds going off next week if Will and Kevin don't step it up.

It seemed the judges came straight from "Happy Hour" to the show. It seemed one had a couple Coors, one had some cosmos, while the other one decided what to drink by opening up a fortune cookie.

And Carrie did awe-mazing with her performance.

[GoldenBoy]

Bucky over Katharine? Really, Mikal? Really?

[.:Froggert:.]

1. Ayla
2. Elliot
3. Lisa
4. Katherine
5. Mandisa
6. Chris
7. Paris (Cant stand her but she is cute and has talent!)
8. Ace
9. Mandisa

everyone else I just want off. Please god.

[Nick The Third]

Originally posted by .:Froggert:.

1. Ayla
2. Elliot
3. Lisa
4. Katherine
5. Mandisa
6. Chris
7. Paris (Cant stand her but she is cute and has talent!)
8. Ace
9. Mandisa

everyone else I just want off. Please god.

You want Mandisa on twice, huh? =P

1) Paris
2) Mandisa
3) Chris
4) Elliot
5) Katharine
6) Lisa
7) Kinnik
8) Ace
---
9) Melissa
10) Will
11) Ayla
12) Gedeon
13) Bucky
14) Kevin
15) Kellie
16) Taylor
---
17) Becky
18) Stevie
19) Brenna
20) Sway
21) Patrick
22) Heather
23) David
24) Bobby

[Sir. Will]

Oh man tonight was soo good.

1. Mandisa

Well, she's done it again beating everyone in the studio and killing out any possible competition. Way to go Mandisa! Oh and everyone, please remember that on the first page of the actual American Idol Season 5 page, I said she was the best singer... look who's right now!?! YEAH! ^___^

2. Katharine

She's so good, getting a bit too much publicity, but of course, the bitch is back. Love her so much, she's so good and what she does, what a great choice! Aretha ^_______^

3. Kellie

Oh come on, that **** was AWESOME. Melissa Etheridge has one of the best songs of all time and Kelly did it justice.

Kellie, I feel so sorry for her. They keep making fun of her stupidity, and even if she is, don't laugh about her in front of her face! SALMON. Oh and Simon what the ---- you like her more than Carrie you dumb ----? G-D I hate Simon.

4. Lisa

She's like soo good and hot but she needs to pick newer songs, I guess according to the judges so I don't have to hear about it anymore. Lisa is like so good though, she's up there.

5. Paris

Well, well, well the top 5, and the top 5 best girls... Well she rocked tonight, AGAIN and this is like an 8 in rating so it's still hott. Paris has an awesome voice but I don't think it's cool for her to sing Latin music. I want a powerful maybe gospel ballad from her.

6. Melissa

She did better than Ayla tonight, and it should keep her safe! Heart was an awesome choice and you can NOT deny she sounded awesome. Hopefully America keeps her around!

7. Ayla

NATASHA BEDINGFIELD!?! 2004 MUSIC!?! WTF AYLA!?! What the hell were you thinking???? It's the last week until Top 12 and you chose the biggest risk of them all. What a sissy song! She's like such a damn robot, too. I'm scared! She BETTER go, I don't like her at all, really, but she's pretty good and this is like a 7.5 so it's still REALLY good, but WHY contemporary music Ayla???

8. Kinnik

Ya'll already know how much I dislike her. She has such a good voice and I thought Alicia would be a good choice. It's like one of the best songs of all time and I remember Vonzell sang it last year, didn't she??? Anyways, Kinnik was off key throughout almost the whole song, I don't agree that she was that good at the beginning. During the middle it started to shape up but given the talent of the 7 people above her, it ain't good enough to keep her around.

Bottom 3:
Kinnik
Ayla
Melissa

Should Be Gone:
Ayla
Kinnik

Will Be:
Melissa (OR AYLA, there's an equal chance there...)
Kinnik (I'm 100% sure she'll be gone)

[.Chad.]

Overall, good night

01. Melissa - 10/10
02. Mandisa - 10/10 (better than Vonzell)
03. Katharine - 9/10
04. Kelly - 8/10
05. Ayla - 7/10
06. Paris - 7/10
07. Kinnik - 7/10
08. Lisa - 6/10

Should Be
Bottom 3 - Lisa, Kinnik, Ayla
Going Home - Lisa, Kinnik(even though I like her)

Will Be
Bottom 3 - Kinnik, Ayla, Melissa
Going Home - Kinnik & ???? (IDN, Melissa was way better but idn how many ppl like Ayla)

[Charmbracelet]

1. mandisa
2. katherine
3. melissa
4. kellie
5. ayla
6. kinnik
7. lisa
8. paris