[M!X]

No.

[highwind44029]

Definitely. I will forever associate Irreplaceable with the last few months of my college life.

To this day, I still hear this song on the radio regularly.

[Harajuku]

Yup

[Quiqui4eva]

big fat YES

[jomarr]

No. It's a big hit but that's all it was.

[MyaKoiv]

Yes

[Lippy]

Nope.

[Invader]

No just a hit

[NOW]

Yes, it had longevity and is one of her well-known hits.
Also, did anyone else sing "You must not know what I mean" all these years without knowing the real lyrics?

[GreasyBruce]

Absolutely not. It was a generic Ne-Yo/StarGate song like many others at the time, and it's big success was only in the US. It is mostly forgotten and Beyonce has other songs that could be considered classics, not this one.

[Embustera]

Yes, it was huge worldwide

[Scuba_Dive]

Yes. I still hear it a lot.

[Sanjja]

Definitely

[Mariano]

yes

[Flashing Lights]

Yep.

[GreasyBruce]

Originally posted by Embustera

Yes, it was huge worldwide

US: #1

UK: #4

GER: #11

FRA: #10

AUS: #1

CAN: #2

ITA: #10

SWZ: #9

NETH: #3

NOR: #8

BELG: #25


It was only huge mainly in English speaking countries. A moderate hit elsewhere.

[PULSE.]

Yes.

[katyperryismylife]

No

[SebaMonster]

Yes

[Typhlosion]

Nope.