Quote:
Originally posted by Stepfon
Laugh all you want but it's true, (not trying to throw shade at all) but look at look at Madonna, do you think she sold on her vocal range? I mean come on Demi fans, you all talk about vocals all day long, try to drag Selena Gomez's vocals, and do this stan war thing but the facts are the facts. At the end of the day everything is NOT about vocals, if that was the case Leona Lewis, Jordin Sparks, and many other people would be on Adele's level.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Stepfon
I can compare Demi to some CURRENT popstars as well. (The point of bringing up Madonna was to show you that vocals have never really mattered. But, I guess your little mind didn't really grasp that concept at all.) Let me clock you by point dealing with the reality shows: Sure, The Voice is ABOUT singers having "the voice" BUT in the end the show was NOTHING more than a vehicle for the judges to shine. Does anybody even remember who won that show? Yes, Idol is also about having a good voice BUT notice the makeovers the contestants have to go through, if it was completely about the voices then they wouldn't have to be groomed and plucked into becoming stars, it's about the overall package. Sidenote: Do you think the teenage girls that called in to vote for Scotty really care about his one-note voice? Nope.
My fave ADMITS she is NOT Mariah Carey, so come after her vocals all you want, it's nothing that she doesn't already know, lol.
|
I think you are just focusing on her voice and disregarding her amazing music.
Honestly, her voice is what made me take notice in her when I heard This Is Me but her music is what made me become a stan. She has what Jordin or Leona do not have, which is the ability to poor her soul on paper. I love them both but neither of them are known as strong song writers.
Demi's writing impresses me more everyday and I think you should listen to her second album Here We Go Again before you say she doesn't have any star quality.
She's written with well respected song writers like John Mayer and John McLaughlin and has been praised by them and she is still growing every day.
I do think she has star quality. She just hasn't had the right label backing or team backing her to really shine imo.