1. Shendelzare
Rian. 8.5/10
Great job!
The billboard looks very good.
Britney looks great.
The fonts and their color work perfectly.
I just wish you would’ve put a catchphrase/slogan on it to make it look a bit more real.
Overall this looks professional and like a real billboard.
Element 9.5/10
This is STUNNING! I absolutely love the color scheme that you chose, and the fonts are elegant and perfect for a billboard. The swatch of paint/makeup behind Britney is fantastic, and I think it was great compositionally to have that pink leak out into the white border a bit. The only questionable part of this for me is how the perfume bottle is emphasized with the drop shadow. It's not bad, but I think you could have placed it in a different spot -- perhaps the bottom right corner?
Phoenixstar 8/10
Wish there's no pink brush outside of the border
2. Dom
Rian. 8/10
CUTE!!
I love the flower background. Automatically makes it look more realistic.
Ariana is cute and her look fits perfectly on the billboard.
I like how you made the color of the bottle match Arianas dress.
The fonts are nice but kinda hard to read.
Overall very cute entry
Element 7.5/10
Nice picture of Ariana, and I think the font choice works well with the design of the bottle and the purpose of the ad. The background is really not a good pick, in my opinion. It is way too busy to be an effective advertisement, and the text and bottle get lost in the mix. You want the name of the perfume and the bottle to be the stars of the ad. If you wanted to keep that background, maybe you could have done like a white paint splash behind the text/bottle to make them stand out more.
Phoenixstar 7/10
The bottle doesn't match the vibes of the pics. Could have chosen better pics
3. Xedretinz Lododnz
Rian. 7.5/10
This is nice.
Only flaw I can find are the fonts.
If it was a floral background, then the fonts would have worked nice, just like Dom’s entry.
But you went for a more dramatic background, which is not a bad thing at all. I just wish you used a different font.
The slogan fits well with the bottle and the way Brendon looks on the billboard.
Element 8/10
You have created a pretty suave, sophisticated atmosphere that matches the classy promise of your fragrance's slogan. The color scheme is simple, but effective, and I like the way that the bottle is echoed in the background. There are a few questionable choices, such as the blurred effect around Brendon's head, as well as the quality of the font, which looks a bit pixelated at times. But this entry is solid.
Phoenixstar 6/10
Terrible cutting. The font deserved to be better than that basic
4. Hurem
Rian. 10/10
This is a standout entry!
I love the color scheme.
I love that picture change.
I love that Gaga is serving in both pics.
I love the fonts.
I love the fact that you put the stores logos on the billboard.
Slayed.
Element 10/10
Take my money.
Phoenixstar 10/10
Would love to see more coloring and effects on that pics by making background more haunting. Love the gif idea
5. Marnie
Rian. 6.5/10
The pics of Rih
There are some flaws that make it look unrealistic as a real billboard tho.
First off, the fonts.
Sometimes it’s good to have two different fonts, but the two fonts you chose don’t go well together.
The color don’t work well with each other either.
Supernova is touching the upper edge, which should never be done!
Secondly, the bottle.
I see that the cutting is not even bad, it’s just that you reshaped it and tilted it a bit.
That makes it look very LQ and the edges very sharp and pixelated.
The coloring of the bottle is very nice tho.
Element 6/10
Ooh I've never seen this photoshoot before actually! It's intriguing, but I feel like the theme of Rihanna's photos kind of contrast with the connotation of the bottle. I get a very feminine, elegant vibe from the bottle, and the raw, earthy photographs just don't correlate. The bottle cutting out is pretty choppy, but I like the idea of the box in the bottom corner.
Phoenixstar 7/10
Love everything but the font ruined everything.
6. Royal Culture
Rian. 10/10
No flaws.
I love the concept.
I love the execution.
I love the pic of Selena.
I love the color scheme.
I love the fonts.
I love the billboard in action and the packaging.
Element 9.5/10
Another really really strong round from you. I think that your colors and composition are perfectly tied into the design of the bottle, and I love how you went above and beyond with the billboard and the box -- nice 3D manip for that side panel of the box, by the way! One of my favorite elements of this entry is the fact that you made Selena's "S" into the handle of the bottle. Little things like that, as well as perfectly done gradient text, are what take a design to a higher level of magic and creativity. Well done!
Phoenixstar 9.5/10
A bit disappointing after the good album cover. This is very professional,honestly.
7. ririfan21
Rian. 6.5/10
Not bad!
The background is really nice.
Angelina looks kinda flattened tho. You should hold shift when resizing, so the shape doesn’t change.
The fonts are not bad but kinda small.
I would’ve made them bigger, the bottle too.
The Angelina Jolie font is touching the upper and left edge, which is a huge no-no.
Element 7/10
If I blocked out Angelina with my hand, this ad would be pretty strong. I like the blue, purple, and pink palette, and I think that all of the background effects came together really really well to create an elegant, mystical, and intriguing base layer. The colors and lighting and composition are all very appealing in that regard. The main problem with this entry, unfortunately, is Angelina -- whose size distracts from all of the great parts of the design. She's disproportionate, and her skin appears overexposed to me. This half of the billboard throws it all off, but you have some good moments here!
Phoenixstar 4/10
Terrible cutting. Dislike the font and its placement.
8. Cantaloupe.
Rian. 9.5/10
I like this!
I like the flower background.
The color scheme is nice.
The fonts are nice.
And the little shooting stars add just enough life to the billboard.
Element 9/10
Absolutely love the shooting stars effect, which really makes the billboard shine in a unique manner. I do find myself a bit torn about the floral background, as I think it is a bit busy. This one is better than Dom's though, which I attribute to the blur you placed on the flowers. The fonts also are underwhelming to me. However, the more I look at the design, the more I realize how good it is as an artpiece.
Phoenixstar 9/10
Gorgeous effect. I really loved it. I wish there's only one of her.*
9. Desire
Rian. 8/10
Nice!
I love that the blue background turns into a galaxy.
The coloring of the bottle is also very gorgeous.
The fonts are a bit bland tho and you should’ve centered them.
Element 7.5/10
Omg the background caught me off guard in a very exciting way! Love that effect. This is your best entry so far IMO. I think your design is simple but pretty effective. I don't love the placement of the bottle as it feels like a bit of an afterthought that doesn't have any interaction with the text or the picture of Olly. I also think that you could have chosen some more intriguing fonts, at least for the title of the fragrance. Usually, having two different fonts for a person/title combo is advisable, unless you really have a modern, sleek layout in mind for those fonts. Good job though!
Phoenixstar 7.5/10
You could do a lot better honestly. But this is nice to see ,I guess.
10. Dancehall
Rian. 10/10
HOT.
Zayn always looks hot.
I love the creativity and the mosaic effect.
The bottle placement is alright too.
Overall this looks professional to me and I could see it being a real billboard.
Element 10/10
I really really really love this and how out of left field it is. I adore graphic artwork that deals with shapes and geometry like this, and your use of the squares is just stunning. The pictures and colors are intriguing, and I think that this billboard would have people stop in their tracks to see what the fuss is about.
Phoenixstar 4/10
Really weird to me, honestly. I just don't really like it , tbh
11. Kingie
Rian. 9/10
Very nice.
I love the color scheme.
The fonts are okay.
Tinashe should’ve been bigger tho and the bottle also since there’s a lot of space there.
Otherwise there isn’t much to criticize.
Element 8.5/10
You created a beautiful golden landscape that borders on a fantasy realm, which is not easy to do! I really like the way you blurred Tinashe in order to create that effect, although I think you could have made her size a decent bit larger in order to fill the billboard and be more a focal point. The blurring on the bottle itself is a bit questionable, since that should be something that stands out from the background rather than blending in. I like the font choice for the SUBtitle, but I think you could have found a font that was more intriguing for "Supernova" itself. Cool design overall.
Phoenixstar 4.5/10
I honestly don't know to say,sorry. It's very blurry everywhere.
12. skwonderfactory
Rian. 7/10
This had a lot of potential.
The background is very nice.
The fonts and their colors are nice too, you should’ve put some effect on it to make them easier to read tho.
Katy has a very unnatural glow, you should’ve adjusted her lighting.
Overall it’s pretty.
Element 8/10
There's a lot going on here, and I think this billboard would definitely catch attention. Some of the fonts are placed in locations that make them difficult to read, and I feel like the confetti explosion behind the bottle is not really necessary. Color scheme is pretty good.
Phoenixstar 6.5/10
The cutting is what gives it bad score,but that's all.
13. LiMe
Rian. 9.5/10
I love you.
I really love your creativity.
The concept is very nice and executed well too.
The fonts are stunning.
And I know how much PS skills this actually required so I really appreciate the effort.
Element 8/10
This interpretation of the billboard is very unique and unexpected, but it works with Avril's personality. I think that technique-wise, you have some really solid cutting and layout. The only questionable placements for me are Avril Lavigne, which might look better above Supernova, and the slogan, which might look better in a smaller font under Supernova. I don't know if I could see this as an actual billboard, but it's a cute and refreshing entry.
Phoenixstar 8.5/10
So funny ,love the concept. But it's not really professional and that's the problem here.
Round 3 scores
1. Royal Culture 9.4
2. Cantaloupe. 9
3. Hurem 8.9
4. Shendelzare 8.75
5. DevonDreams 8.25
6. Dancehall 8.2
7. LiMe 8
8. Dom 7.7
9. ririfan21 7.2
10. Xedretinz Lododnz 6.7
10. Marnie 6.7
10. skwonderfactory 6.7
11. MasterXPosed 6.5
12. Kingie 6.25
13. URBAN 6.2
14. Desire 5.7
Round 4 scores
1. Hurem 10
2. Royal Culture 9.65
3. Cantaloupe. 9.15
4. Shendelzare 8.65
4. LiMe 8.65
5. Dancehall 8
6. Desire 7.65
7. Dom 7.5
8. Kingie 7.35
9. Xedretinz Lododnz 7.15
9. skwonderfactory 7.15
10. Marnie 6.5
11. ririfan21 5.85
Leaderboard
1. Cantaloupe. 36.75
2. LiMe 35.2
3. Royal Culture 35
4. Hurem 34.9
5. Shendelzare 32.15
6. Kingie 29
7. Dom 28.7
8. Xedretinz Lododnz 27.45
9. skwonderfactory 26.6
10. Dancehall 27.2
11. Marnie 26.7
12. Desire 26.4
13. ririfan21 25.3
14. URBAN 19.4
Eliminated
URBAN, obviously, for not submitting.
So that means that two people will be eliminated due to having the lowest score on the leaderboard.
ririfan, I’m very sorry, but you’re eliminated.
You brought us a lot of creativity.
I hope you had fun and enjoyed being a part of this game.
Thank you very much for participating
And
Desire.
You improved a lot since the last time you played in S2.
You were very active and always submitted a creative entry.
I hope you had fun and enjoyed being a part of this game.
Thank you very much for participating
Congrats on the rest for making it to the top 11.
But I'm happy to finally win a round. 
I'm eliminated next challenge. 
