[MusicTalker]

Tim McGraw vs Fearless vs Mine vs State of Grace vs Welcome to New York
Picture to Burn vs Fifteen vs Sparks Fly vs Red vs Blank Space
Teardrops On My Guitar vs Love Story vs Back to December vs Treacherous vs Style
A Place In this World vs Hey Stephen vs Speak Now vs I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods
Cold As You vs White Horse vs Dear John vs All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay
The Outside vs You Belong With Me vs Mean vs 22 vs Shake It Off
Tied Together With a Smile vs Breathe vs The Story of Us vs I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would
Stay Beautiful vs Tell Me Why vs Never Grow Up vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood
Should've Said No vs You're Not Sorry vs Enchanted vs Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams
Mary's Song (Oh My My) vs The Way I Loved You vs Better Than Revenge vs The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl
Our Song vs Forever & Always vs Innocent vs Holy Ground vs This Love
I'm Only Me When I'm With You vs The Best Day vs Haunted vs Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places
Invisible vs Change vs Last Kiss vs The Lucky One vs Clean
A Perfectly Good Heart vs Jump Then Fall vs Long Live vs Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland
Teardrops On My Guitar (Pop Version) vs Untouchable vs Ours vs Starlight vs You Are In Love
Beautiful Eyes vs Forever & Always (Piano Version) vs If This Was a Movie vs Begin Again vs New Romantics

Taylor Swift:
Fearless:
Speak Now:
Red:
1989:

[MusicTalker]

Tim McGraw vs Fearless vs Mine vs State of Grace vs Welcome to New York
Picture to Burn vs Fifteen vs Sparks Fly vs Red vs Blank Space
Teardrops On My Guitar vs Love Story vs Back to December vs Treacherous vs Style
A Place In this World vs Hey Stephen vs Speak Now vs I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods
Cold As You vs White Horse vs Dear John vs All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay
The Outside vs You Belong With Me vs Mean vs 22 vs Shake It Off
Tied Together With a Smile vs Breathe vs The Story of Us vs I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would
Stay Beautiful vs Tell Me Why vs Never Grow Up vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood
Should've Said No vs You're Not Sorry vs Enchanted vs Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams
Mary's Song (Oh My My) vs The Way I Loved You vs Better Than Revenge vs The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl
Our Song vs Forever & Always vs Innocent vs Holy Ground vs This Love
I'm Only Me When I'm With You vs The Best Day vs Haunted vs Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places
Invisible vs Change vs Last Kiss vs The Lucky One vs Clean
A Perfectly Good Heart vs Jump Then Fall vs Long Live vs Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland
Teardrops On My Guitar (Pop Version) vs Untouchable vs Ours vs Starlight vs You Are In Love
Beautiful Eyes vs Forever & Always (Piano Version) vs If This Was a Movie vs Begin Again vs New Romantics

Taylor Swift: 1
Fearless: 2
Speak Now: 2
Red: 4
1989: 7

[Icannot]

Originally posted by castle13

1989 already hit 3xPlatinum in New Zealand

http://nztop40.co.nz/chart/albums

All of this support and yet She is paying NZ absolute dust.

[Achilles.]

Originally posted by ahauntingnearu

That thread with Katy was so funny. Both of them have had some horrific one-liners

I can't think of any from Taylor.

both have some really awesome lyrics

I can't think of any from Katy.

[gagacasanova]

The high pitched STAY's in AYHTDWS are the best thing ever.

[havefaithrestart]

Tim McGraw vs Fearless vs Mine vs State of Grace vs Welcome to New York
Picture to Burn vs Fifteen vs Sparks Fly vs Red vs Blank Space
Teardrops On My Guitar vs Love Story vs Back to December vs Treacherous vs Style
A Place In this World vs Hey Stephen vs Speak Now vs I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods
Cold As You vs White Horse vs Dear John vs All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay
The Outside vs You Belong With Me vs Mean vs 22 vs Shake It Off
Tied Together With a Smile vs Breathe vs The Story of Us vs I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would
Stay Beautiful vs Tell Me Why vs Never Grow Up vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood
Should've Said No vs You're Not Sorry vs Enchanted vs Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams
Mary's Song (Oh My My) vs The Way I Loved You vs Better Than Revenge vs The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl
Our Song vs Forever & Always vs Innocent vs Holy Ground vs This Love
I'm Only Me When I'm With You vs The Best Day vs Haunted vs Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places
Invisible vs Change vs Last Kiss vs The Lucky One vs Clean
A Perfectly Good Heart vs Jump Then Fall vs Long Live vs Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland
Teardrops On My Guitar (Pop Version) vs Untouchable vs Ours vs Starlight vs You Are In Love
Beautiful Eyes vs Forever & Always (Piano Version) vs If This Was a Movie vs Begin Again vs New Romantics

Taylor Swift: II
Fearless: II
Speak Now: IIIII
Red: III
1989: IIII

Speak Now wins

[castle13]

Tim McGraw vs Fearless vs Mine vs State of Grace vs Welcome to New York
Picture to Burn vs Fifteen vs Sparks Fly vs Red vs Blank Space
Teardrops On My Guitar vs Love Story vs Back to December vs Treacherous vs Style
A Place In this World vs Hey Stephen vs Speak Now vs I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods
Cold As You vs White Horse vs Dear John vs All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay
The Outside vs You Belong With Me vs Mean vs 22 vs Shake It Off
Tied Together With a Smile vs Breathe vs The Story of Us vs I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would
Stay Beautiful vs Tell Me Why vs Never Grow Up vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood
Should've Said No vs You're Not Sorry vs Enchanted vs Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams
Mary's Song (Oh My My) vs The Way I Loved You vs Better Than Revenge vs The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl
Our Song vs Forever & Always vs Innocent vs Holy Ground vs This Love
I'm Only Me When I'm With You vs The Best Day vs Haunted vs Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places
Invisible vs Change vs Last Kiss vs The Lucky One vs Clean
A Perfectly Good Heart vs Jump Then Fall vs Long Live vs Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland
Teardrops On My Guitar (Pop Version) vs Untouchable vs Ours vs Starlight vs You Are In Love
Beautiful Eyes vs Forever & Always (Piano Version) vs If This Was a Movie vs Begin Again vs New Romantics

The fifth tracks

Cold As You vs White Horse vs Dear John vs All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay

[Dani97]

she doesn't look thrilled looking calvin's set at wango tango. EDM is really not her thing

[gagacasanova]

Tim McGraw vs Fearless vs Mine vs State of Grace vs Welcome to New York
Picture to Burn vs Fifteen vs Sparks Fly vs Red vs Blank Space
Teardrops On My Guitar vs Love Story vs Back to December vs Treacherous vs Style
A Place In this World vs Hey Stephen vs Speak Now vs I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods
Cold As You vs White Horse vs Dear John vs All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay
The Outside vs You Belong With Me vs Mean vs 22 vs Shake It Off
Tied Together With a Smile vs Breathe vs The Story of Us vs I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would
Stay Beautiful vs Tell Me Why vs Never Grow Up vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood
Should've Said No vs You're Not Sorry vs Enchanted vs Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams
Mary's Song (Oh My My) vs The Way I Loved You vs Better Than Revenge vs The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl
Our Song vs Forever & Always vs Innocent vs Holy Ground vs This Love
I'm Only Me When I'm With You vs The Best Day vs Haunted vs Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places
Invisible vs Change vs Last Kiss vs The Lucky One vs Clean
A Perfectly Good Heart vs Jump Then Fall vs Long Live vs Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland
Teardrops On My Guitar (Pop Version) vs Untouchable vs Ours vs Starlight vs You Are In Love
Beautiful Eyes vs Forever & Always (Piano Version) vs If This Was a Movie vs Begin Again vs New Romantics

Taylor Swift: 0
Fearless: 1
Speak Now: 4
Red: 5
1989: 6

Poor debut.
If TMIK was included, Red and 1989 would be tied. And Red is my favorite TS album...

[ahauntingnearu]

Originally posted by JakeKills

I can't think of any from Taylor.



I can't think of any from Katy.

don't be messy

[Hunter_13]

Tim McGraw vs Fearless vs Mine vs State of Grace vs Welcome to New York
Picture to Burn vs Fifteen vs Sparks Fly vs Red vs Blank Space
Teardrops On My Guitar vs Love Story vs Back to December vs Treacherous vs Style
A Place In this World vs Hey Stephen vs Speak Now vs I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods
Cold As You vs White Horse vs Dear John vs All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay
The Outside vs You Belong With Me vs Mean vs 22 vs Shake It Off
Tied Together With a Smile vs Breathe vs The Story of Us vs I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would
Stay Beautiful vs Tell Me Why vs Never Grow Up vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood
Should've Said No vs You're Not Sorry vs Enchanted vs Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams
Mary's Song (Oh My My)vs The Way I Loved You vs Better Than Revenge vs The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl
Our Song vs Forever & Always vs Innocent vs Holy Ground vs This Love
I'm Only Me When I'm With You vs The Best Day vs Haunted vs Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places
Invisible vs Change vs Last Kiss vs The Lucky One vs Clean
A Perfectly Good Heart vs Jump Then Fall vs Long Live vs Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland
Teardrops On My Guitar (Pop Version) vs Untouchable vs Ours vs Starlight vs You Are In Love
Beautiful Eyes vs Forever & Always (Piano Version) vs If This Was a Movie vs Begin Again vs New Romantics

Taylor Swift: 1
Fearless: 1
Speak Now: 4
Red: 4
1989: 6

[Letícia L.]

Tim McGraw vs Fearless vs Mine vs State of Grace vs Welcome to New York
Picture to Burn vs Fifteen vs Sparks Fly vs Red vs Blank Space
Teardrops On My Guitar vs Love Story vs Back to December vs Treacherous vs Style
A Place In this World vs Hey Stephen vs Speak Now vs I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods
Cold As You vs White Horse vs Dear John vs All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay
The Outside vs You Belong With Me vs Mean vs 22 vs Shake It Off
Tied Together With a Smile vs Breathe vs The Story of Us vs I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would
Stay Beautiful vs Tell Me Why vs Never Grow Up vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood
Should've Said No vs You're Not Sorry vs Enchanted vs Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams
Mary's Song (Oh My My) vs The Way I Loved You vs Better Than Revenge vs The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl
Our Song vs Forever & Always vs Innocent vs Holy Ground vs This Love
I'm Only Me When I'm With You vs The Best Day vs Haunted vs Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places
Invisible vs Change vs Last Kiss vs The Lucky One vs Clean
A Perfectly Good Heart vs Jump Then Fall vs Long Live vs Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland
Teardrops On My Guitar (Pop Version) vs Untouchable vs Ours vs Starlight vs You Are In Love
Beautiful Eyes vs Forever & Always (Piano Version) vs If This Was a Movie vs Begin Again vs New Romantics

[Dani97]

Originally posted by MusicTalker

Tim McGraw vs Fearless vs Mine vs State of Grace vs Welcome to New York
Picture to Burn vs Fifteen vs Sparks Fly vs Red vs Blank Space
Teardrops On My Guitar vs Love Story vs Back to December vs Treacherous vs Style
A Place In this World vs Hey Stephen vs Speak Now vs I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods
Cold As You vs White Horse vs Dear John vs All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay
The Outside vs You Belong With Me vs Mean vs 22 vs Shake It Off
Tied Together With a Smile vs Breathe vs The Story of Us vs I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would
Stay Beautiful vs Tell Me Why vs Never Grow Up vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood
Should've Said No vs You're Not Sorry vs Enchanted vs Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams
Mary's Song (Oh My My) vs The Way I Loved You vs Better Than Revenge vs The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl
Our Song vs Forever & Always vs Innocent vs Holy Ground vs This Love
I'm Only Me When I'm With You vs The Best Day vs Haunted vs Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places
Invisible vs Change vs Last Kiss vs The Lucky One vs Clean
A Perfectly Good Heart vs Jump Then Fall vs Long Live vs Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland
Teardrops On My Guitar (Pop Version) vs Untouchable vs Ours vs Starlight vs You Are In Love
Beautiful Eyes vs Forever & Always (Piano Version) vs If This Was a Movie vs Begin Again vs New Romantics

Taylor Swift:
Fearless:
Speak Now:
Red:
1989:

OMG some of them were really hard but RED

[MusicTalker]

Anyone have that gif from Red tour where she's in a red dress & whisked off by a chair?

[Achilles.]

State of Grace > Fearless > Mine > Tim McGraw > Welcome to New York

Sparks Fly > Blank Space > Fifteen > Red > Picture to Burn

Style > Love Story > Back to December > Treacherous > Teardrops on My Guitar

Out of the Woods > I Knew You Were Trouble > Speak Now > Hey Stephen > A Place in this World

All Too Well > Dear John > White Horse > All You Had To Do Was Stay > Cold As You

Shake It Off > Mean > You Belong With Me > 22 > The Outside

I Wish You Would > I Almost Do > Tied Together With A Smile > Breathe > The -Story of Us

We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together > Tell Me Why > Never Grow Up > Bad Blood > Stay Beautiful

Enchanted > Wildest Dreams > Should've Said No > You're Not Sorry > Stay Stay Stay

Mary's Song > Better Than Revenge > The Way I Loved You > The Last Time > How You Get The Girl

Holy Ground > Forever & Always > Our Song > This Love > Innocent

Sad Beautiful Tragic > I Know Places > The Best Day > Haunted > I'm Only Me When I'm With You

Last Kiss > Clean > The Lucky One > Change > Invisible

Long Live > Wonderland > Everything Has Changed > Jump Then Fall > A Perfectly Good Heart

You Are In Love > Starlight > Ours > Untouchable > Teardrop on My Guitar (pop)

New Romantics > Begin Again > If This Was A Movie > Forever & Always (piano) > Beautiful Eyes


# of First Place Rankings
Taylor Swift: 1
Fearless: 0
Speak Now: 4
Red: 5
1989: 6

Total Score
(First place = 5pts, fifth place = 1pt)
1989: 58
Red: 56
Speak Now: 54
Fearless: 45
Taylor Swift: 27

The top 3 are so close.

Improving with each album.

[Achilles.]

Originally posted by ahauntingnearu

don't be messy

Not messy. Just honest.

Originally posted by MusicTalker

Anyone have that gif from Red tour where she's in a red dress & whisked off by a chair?

[Icannot]

dead at 1989 becoming your favourite alber.

[TaylorFantasy]

Tim McGraw vs Fearless vs Mine vs State of Grace vs Welcome to New York
Picture to Burn vs Fifteen vs Sparks Fly vs Red vs Blank Space
Teardrops On My Guitar vs Love Story vs Back to December vs Treacherous vs Style
A Place In this World vs Hey Stephen vs Speak Now vs I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods
Cold As You vs White Horse vs Dear John vs All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay
The Outside vs You Belong With Me vs Mean vs 22 vs Shake It Off
Tied Together With a Smile vs Breathe vs The Story of Us vs I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would
Stay Beautiful vs Tell Me Why vs Never Grow Up vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood
Should've Said No vs You're Not Sorry vs Enchanted vs Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams
Mary's Song (Oh My My) vs The Way I Loved You vs Better Than Revenge vs The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl
Our Song vs Forever & Always vs Innocent vs Holy Ground vs This Love
I'm Only Me When I'm With You vs The Best Day vs Haunted vs Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places
Invisible vs Change vs Last Kiss vs The Lucky One vs Clean
A Perfectly Good Heart vs Jump Then Fall vs Long Live vs Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland
Teardrops On My Guitar (Pop Version) vs Untouchable vs Ours vs Starlight vs You Are In Love
Beautiful Eyes vs Forever & Always (Piano Version) vs If This Was a Movie vs Begin Again vs New Romantics

Taylor Swift: 1
Fearless: 2
Speak Now: 6
Red: 2
1989: 5

Speak Now obliterating competitions

[ahauntingnearu]

Originally posted by JakeKills

Not messy. Just honest.

Yes messy, and simply untrue.

As for these album song ranking things, I legimstely don't know how I could do it for Taylor's albums. They're all so good it was easy for Katy's with two exceptions

[Achilles.]

Originally posted by Icannot

dead at 1989 becoming your favourite alber.

It's because more than half of the songs were top 3 in their match ups.


Speak Now, Red, and 1989 are all so close that it's hard to say which is honestly my favorite (match ups are a bit limiting, songs may come in first or fourth depending on their competition).



But yeah I'm dead too. Remember my meltdown when they said Max Martin was executive producing the album?