[Doc]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Well, up to this point.



Let's review!

Vision of Love

Emotions
Can't Let Go
Make It Happen

Dreamlover
Anytime You Need a Friend

All I Want for Christmas is You

Fantasy
Fantasy (Bad Boy Remix)
Always Be My Baby
Underneath the Stars

Honey
Butterfly
Breakdown
The Roof

Heartbreaker

It's Like That
We Belong Together
Don't Forget About Us
Fly Like a Bird

Bolded Top 10.

Why are you shocked at ATYNAF? It's a fan favorite.

[supaspaz]

That's actually a fairly strong top twenty overall. There's nothing I dislike, even if not all the songs are among my favorites.

[ECNEICSNOC]

Originally posted by Doc

Won't settle for less than Top 10.

Oh you all are not ready for the meltdown that would follow Breakdown being snubbed like that.

[Taste of Honey]

I'm surprised DFAU managed to sneak in, but considering the era not so much I guess.

And I almost forgot about "Make It Happen". It belongs here without a doubt.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by supaspaz

That's actually a fairly strong top twenty overall.

So much better than the Kylie rate top twenty. SO MUCH BETTER.

[Mariah4life]

Vision of Love - YES! This song better be in the top 5

Emotions - I WON'T be mad if this win at this point

Can't Let Go - GEM! Wurk@ people stanning for it

Make It Happen - Great Song. I like it!

Dreamlover - Top 5 PLEASE

Anytime You Need a Friend - YES! Get that recognition it deserved

All I Want for Christmas is You - Xmas is coming! Top 5, i wont be mad.

Fantasy - AMAZING SONG.

Fantasy (Bad Boy Remix) - YES! Top 5

Always Be My Baby - This is my like my favorite. If it wins DDDD

Underneath the Stars - Pretty Good. Top 15

Honey - Top 10 maybe?

Butterfly - Still in? <333

Breakdown - NEXT

The Roof - EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW WWWWWWWWWWWWWW

Heartbreaker - WTF? BYE

It's Like That - It's okay

We Belong Together - LOVE. TOP 6?

Don't Forget About Us - This needs to go

Fly Like a Bird - Horrible that it makes it this far

[Doc]

Originally posted by Taste of Honey

I'm surprised DFAU managed to sneak in, but considering the era not so much I guess.

And I almost forgot about "Make It Happen". It belongs here without a doubt.

DFAU's sneaky ass.
My All can take DFAU's place. If It's Over can take The Roof's place. Then the Top 20 would be perfect.

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

So much better than the Kylie rate top twenty. SO MUCH BETTER.

The great difference is probably that most Kylie fans on ATRL only know her post-Fever work, whereas the Lambs have been with Mariah for life.

[Mimie]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Let's review!

Vision of Love

Emotions
Can't Let Go
Make It Happen

Dreamlover
Anytime You Need a Friend

All I Want for Christmas is You

Fantasy
Fantasy (Bad Boy Remix)
Always Be My Baby
Underneath the Stars

Honey
Butterfly
Breakdown
The Roof

Heartbreaker

It's Like That
We Belong Together
Don't Forget About Us
Fly Like a Bird

The ones in my iconic font will be the next to

[skyler]

ewwwwww Dont forget about us

[skyler]

Originally posted by supaspaz

The great difference is probably that most Kylie fans on ATRL only know her post-Fever work, whereas the Lambs have been with Mariah for life.

im a kylie fan and i know all her work

[Mariah4life]

Originally posted by skyler

ewwwwww Dont forget about us

Madonnas prob gave it a 10.

[skyler]

Originally posted by Mariah4life

Madonnas prob gave it a 10.

i wouldnt be surprise if he gave that a 0

[EJQL8]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

So much better than the Kylie rate top twenty. SO MUCH BETTER.

The fact that laughable at first sight won
Wow and timebomb making it far
What do I have to do not making top 20
Confide not winning
That rate was a mess for the most part

[Wii]

I'm from Vietnam, a little country on Asia and My All/Hero/I Still Belive/Without You are her most famous songs

And Make It Happen, Anytime you.... (that mess ruined her streak of top 10 hits ) and Fly Like a Bird needs to GTFO i mean...

Ideal top 10



Emotions
Can't Let Go


Dreamlover


All I Want for Christmas is You

Fantasy

Always Be My Baby
Underneath the Stars


Butterfly


Heartbreaker



Don't Forget About Us

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Taste of Honey

I think madonnas needs a schooling on the art of BALLADS.

If he gives "Can't Let Go" a 0...

I gave it an 8.5, but honestly wish I gave it a higher score

Pretty decent top 20!

[Tariq~]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

HEY!

21.



Average: 8.17
Highest: 10 [Jaay, Kworb, Doc, MiguelPortugal, Wecangetstarted, Great Username, StateoftheWorld, berberocka, fortheloveofmusic, Tariq, MP2K, Sawdust, waryofothers, skyler, Neptune, Wil. Pop pop 123, Beyond Say, EJQL8, Soda Pop Queen, Honey, Mariah4life, KoolAidKing]
Lowest: 1 [Strangergab, Jessa., alkralkra]

By far the most top tens. My All did have a bit of work cut out for it, as it had to repair the "damage" Butterfly had done. It did, sending Mariah back to the UK top five (Butterfly missed the top 20) and back to the top of the US Charts. Arguably the biggest song from this album.

ARRRRRRRGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

U MONSTERS .. U TASTELESS FLESH EATING MONSTERS

.. how .. could .. u .. ... My All leaves before Don't Forget About Us & Fly Like A Bird .. now I gave them 10s .. but MY ALL IS LIKE .. 12/10 ..

Honey better be in the top 10 or I'm goin ghetto on all of ur asses .. with a cleaver!

[Kworb]

This rate is a JOKE. What an injustice to Mariah to have so much of her garbage in the top 20. She is known as the best female vocalist of all time, yet most of these 20 songs could've been sung by Britney or Ke$ha and it wouldn't make much of a difference. Oh well. Only three deserving songs are left (We Belong Together, The Roof and Fantasy) so let's hope they are the actual top 3.

[Flashing Lights]

Forever: I was never familiar with this, but I'm starting to like it.

Love Takes Time: Yeah, not bad, but I don't really use her first album much.

I'll Be There: What kind of cluster****? This is one of my favorite covers of all-time and it's not even in the top 20. medoners?



One Sweet Day: Some might say it's too low, but I think it's just about right.

If It's Over: I think I gave it an 8, but I'm starting to love the song now.

Someday: A highlight from her debut, but she's had better (in some cases, MUCH better) up-tempos.

My All: About time. The fact that this made it over legitimate masterpieces sickens me. If I had known it was going to, I wouldn't have been as generous with my score.

[Pecinta Mariah]

The winner is Fantasy, Thanks Ace for the great show