[J a y]

Originally posted by PopFan

You're right. Hope is what keeps humanity alive. I'm glad you still have the faith

Hope? Gaga delivered a great album and I'm thoroughly enjoying it. Waiting for her performances, interviews, documentary, and upcoming half time show in front of 160 million people worldwide. I look forward because that's exactly where I'm going.

It's a shame not all of us are as fortunate to experience that genuine happiness

[istan4badgalriri]

Originally posted by Brooke Candy

Joanne is by far the best album of 2016. People just love to bring Gaga down and hate on her. But the queen always wins at the end <3

How exactly is she winning right now?

[One Nation]

Originally posted by Brooke Candy

Joanne is by far the best album of 2016. People just love to bring Gaga down and hate on her. But the queen always wins at the end <3

[J a y]

Originally posted by istan4badgalriri

How exactly is she winning right now?

the queen always wins at the end

Hate to butt in, but reading is key. My post above even kindly explains that we're looking forward. Try again hun.

[PopFan]

Originally posted by J a y

Hope? Gaga delivered a great album and I'm thoroughly enjoying it. Waiting for her performances, interviews, documentary, and upcoming half time show in front of 160 million people worldwide. I look forward because that's exactly where I'm going.

It's a shame not all of us are as fortunate to experience that genuine happiness

Ok but then why are wasting time in this thread?

[J a y]

Originally posted by PopFan

Ok but then why are wasting time in this thread?

That was actually my first post? This is now my forth. Keep counting.

[Leptine]

Originally posted by jacklovesyou1

The problem is for the past couple of years is that bad reviews get more attention than good reviews and reviewers know this. Bad review = people wanting to see what they said about it = clicks for their website.

Tea.

Gaga + Bad Reviews = Combo of that.
Just look at this thread.

[One Nation]

Originally posted by ♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚

I'd rather have a reviewer review the ALBUM and make that their primary focus rather than a reviewer review and focus so much on the artist and no on the music itself. There's literally NO POINT to review an album if you're going to focus your review on the artist.

You're not getting it.

They also have to analyze the artist and their previous works to determine if the album is in fact progressive or regressive.

[Brando]

Originally posted by Matangi

Y'all have clearly never read a review from a certified, professional publication like Rolling Stone if y'all think "track-by-track" reviews are the common method to reflect on music. Track by track reviews are done by maybe MTV or such

!!!

They clearly never read any of the outstanding, in depth reviews from credible publication like Pitchfork. I only seen Billboard do track by track reviews

[Matangi]

I feel bad for J a y. He's such a nice dude and y'all are constantly going on his nerves.
He's definitely different than those other monsters, which are living in their box.

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

Originally posted by Ressti

I haven't heard the album yet, but honestly, if PI is any indication, then im not surprised that they're not only focussing on the sound, but also her career and life as whole. It's a really drastic drop in quality from her previous work, so one is going to wonder what sparked it.

I'm sorry but just because one out of 12 other tracks turned out to be, something they don't like, doesn't mean they should go around giving up on the album, straying away from the real focus.
They shouldn't be doing this as a full time job, then.

They are 12 other tracks on the album, and them being professional music critics, should be very familiar with the fact that lead singles don't always epresent the album as a whole nor are they the best tracks on the album

[PopFan]

Originally posted by J a y

That was actually my first post? This is now my third. Keep counting.

For someone who claims to not be obsessed with critics reviews, it seems that the current MC score has you concerned.

[Suilen]

An album like Joanne cannot be reviewed without focusing on Gaga since it's supposed to be a defining album for her artistry Critics aren't going to pretend that ARTPOP didn't happen and restain from making comparisons. Pretty sure that some of the upcoming reviews will hail her as an artist and those complaints will be gone.

[Brando]

Originally posted by ♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚

I'd rather have a reviewer review the ALBUM and make that their primary focus rather than a reviewer review and focus so much on the artist and no on the music itself. There's literally NO POINT to review an album if you're going to focus your review on the artist.

Go read Billboard reviews then that consist of "such and such track is fun" and then cite the lyrics.

[J a y]

Originally posted by Matangi

I feel bad for J a y. He's such a nice dude and y'all are constantly going on his nerves.
He's definitely different than those other monsters, which are living in their box.

Don't feel bad for me. I chose to come here since everyone has been dragging my base left, right and center

Someone said that there's another review and I wanted a link. I don't see it in the OP

Originally posted by PopFan

For someone who claims to not be obsessed with critics reviews, it seems that the current MC score has you concerned.

There's 4 reviews? Apparently there's now 5? I came for the new one. Take a chill pill

[beatinglikeadrum]

Originally posted by Matangi

I feel bad for J a y. He's such a nice dude and y'all are constantly going on his nerves.
He's definitely different than those other monsters, which are living in their box.

This !

[BaddiéBéy]

Originally posted by PopFan

When an album flops in sales but is acclaimed by critics, you can argue that it was misunderstood by the GP.

When it is panned by critics but is a success with the GP, you can argue that it was misunderstood by the reviewers.

But when it is rejected by both camps, how can you defend that?

[One Nation]

Originally posted by J a y

That was actually my first post? This is now my forth. Keep counting.

But you were in here all yesterday but abruptly left after someone called you out

[careerfatality]

76 pages wow gaga has atrl shook

[Brooke Candy]

Anywayss, Joanne is better than your faves whole discography ( just like every other Gaga album but, ok). And that's a fact