[americanshameless]

Originally posted by St. Charles

Yes! I plan on doing this every January.

And thanks so much. It was so much fun hosting (my first time) and everything happened all at once. This thread isn't even a week old!

That's what's genius. Your thread is one of ATRL's most viewed front-page.The week long exposure.

[Sakamoto]

the only thing wrong about this rate is that Adele should've been #5 instead of the other, the perfect top 5 that got away
oh well, not everyone can have good tastea

[St. Charles]

Originally posted by Retro

Y'all wish that you could be like the cool kids
All us cool kids, we seem to fit in

Originally posted by americanshameless

That's what's genius. Your thread is one of ATRL's most viewed front-page.The week long exposure.

I like how this thread didn't really have any WP's given out in it (mod can confirm this?) I thought it was going to be a MESS.

[St. Charles]

Can a mod tell me how many WP's in this thread were done?

[Raphy23]

AVRIL WAS ROBBED!

[St. Charles]

For Gaga, 60 people put her in their top 3.

29 put her in their bottom 3.

That's why she was #3.

[Marvin]

#22 Demi
#21 Avril
#20 Selena
#19 Janet
#18 Kylie
#17 Nicki
#16 Kelly
#15 Pink
#14 Kesha
#13 Miley
#12 Christina
#11 Taylor
#10 Ariana
#9 Madonna
#8 Mariah
#7 Adele
#6 Katy
#5 Beyonce
#4 Gaga
#3 Britney
#2 Rihanna
#1 Ciara

[St. Charles]

59 People put Britney in their top 3, but only 8 put her in their bottom three.

[Sakamoto]

Originally posted by Raphy23

AVRIL WAS ROBBED!

she was in my top 10

[St. Charles]

What stats would you guys like?

[Ciel]

I thought Adele would have done a lot better

Oh well, my two faves Rih & Gaga did Amazing

Thanks for the rate!

[Soda Pop Queen]

Originally posted by Tom Vercetti

Little love for R&B on a pop forum. Shocking news.

lol Janet has several pop songs that were hits. She's just as much Pop as she is R&B.

[Soda Pop Queen]

Originally posted by Kid A

Both Kylie and Janet deserve WAY higher

I concur.

[St. Charles]

So nobody wants specific stats/#'s?

[Sakamoto]

Originally posted by Marvin

#22 Demi
#21 Avril
#20 Selena
#19 Janet
#18 Kylie
#17 Nicki
#16 Kelly
#15 Pink
#14 Kesha
#13 Miley
#12 Christina
#11 Taylor
#10 Ariana
#9 Madonna
#8 Mariah
#7 Adele
#6 Katy
#5 Beyonce
#4 Gaga
#3 Britney
#2 Rihanna
#1 Ciara
#∞ Carly

Fixed

Originally posted by St. Charles

So nobody wants specific stats/#'s?

how many people put Demi in their top 10 (15) compared to Selena.

[St. Charles]

lol

[Raphy23]

Originally posted by Prismatic

Why wasn't Carly included in this? I feel like she might've just been the dark horse winner because she'll be pretty high on everyone's list.

She would made top 10 for sure

[SebaMonster]

Originally posted by americanshameless

Noted.

I don't hate her. She's just my least favorite on the list.

[Sakamoto]

#21 Talent always wins
#20 Gags
#19 The female MJ
#18 Gagaloo
#17 Queen of the universe
#16 Germanotta
#15 Angelina
#14 Joanne
#13 Stefanni
#12 Candy Warhol
#11 jo calderone
#10 Yüyi
#9 Madre Mônstér
#8 The Queen of pop
#7 Mrs.Kinney
#6 Woman of the year
#5 The G.U.Y
#4 Venus
#3 Aphrodite
#2 Mother monster
#1 Lady Gaga

[St. Charles]

Originally posted by Raphy23

She would made top 10 for sure

Now that I think of it, maybe she would have. EMOTION changed her from the punching bag of ATRL to a pop goddess.